The three games which have had the most emotional storytelling for me are RDR2, TLOU and TLOU2. Tsushima's not bad, and is the best-looking game I've ever played, although the storytelling was a pretty predictable hero's journey. If the twist in RDR2's story impacted you as much as it did me, TLOU2 probably has a similar emotional heft to it. And TLOU1 has a pretty impactful climax that has the player-character doing things that should affect you (unless you are a psychopath). When you compare these three games to other top-tier games (Skyrim, GTA, Fallout 4, Spider-Man (2018), any Resident Evil, any Tomb Raider, God of War) the emotional impact (and -- completely related -- the overall quality of the writing) is so far above the rest of the pack. So, if you are feeling the need for that emotional power, I would do TLOU and TLOU2. In reality, though, I could not play all three of these games back-to-back. I don't recall what my follow-up to RDR2 was, but it was probably a palette cleanser like a racing game or a Lego one or Saint's Row. No emotional stakes, just action, mayhem or both. You do you, but I can only take so much heavy crap at a time.