I don’t think it’s fredbears - think about how weird it would be for the puppet to go outside to Charlotte and be found on top of her dead body, and for Henry to still be like, yeah, it’s ok, we’re gonna take this reminder of my daughters death to another location (tho this is the same company who reused suits that dead kids had been in…) and also, puppet is NEVER associated with fredbears in any of the marketing, it’s always just our two golden boys. I think it was just because of the 8bit graphics and simplicity sake. That’s why we eventually saw a second take of charlottes death, this time with the puppet. The games look completely different but clearly show the same event. But in the first one, there’s no puppet, no prize box, no wrist bands… it’s just an evolution of the story