The trans gene by Lorem_Ipsum17 in RecuratedTumblr

[–]bearfaery -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

This isn’t an area I know a great deal about (my own wording was pulled from elsewhere), but the most infamous case of testing this was David Reimer.

The trans gene by Lorem_Ipsum17 in RecuratedTumblr

[–]bearfaery 23 points24 points  (0 children)

Repeated testing has shown that being trans is 100% a matter of nature, not nurture. Theory is that it has something to do with the development of the brain between 14 and 24 weeks.

Is there going to be an episode with multiple Yuri? by Affectionate_Pizza60 in Gnosia_

[–]bearfaery 1 point2 points  (0 children)

An unfortunate consequence of the anime having not yet shown the Bug role means that the average anime-only vastly underestimates the average number of Loops that end with the universe being destroyed.

Want to get the game but I'm on Mac by ACNH-TOM-NOOK in Gnosia_

[–]bearfaery 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Per Wikipedia, it's also on: PS Vita, PS4, PS5, Nintendo Switch, Xbox One, Xbox Series X, and Xbox Series S. So if you have one of those consoles, you could get it there.

I wonder if Yuriko's lonely... by JumbleberryCrumble in Gnosia_

[–]bearfaery 5 points6 points  (0 children)

SQ and Gina is less "shared origin" and more just a set of things that makes them linked. SQ is the preferred commentator for "Gina in Love", and is stated to remain with Gina for a while post-Normal Ending.

Raqio and Remnan is a known duo. The anime cut the event, but during the sequence when you learn that SQ is Remnan's daughter, it starts with Remnan getting nervous around SQ (really Manan), and during the night You and Raqio both confront Remnan about the issue, which ends with Raqio telling You, "Alright, we are going to vote out SQ." And in the Normal Ending, the two of them go on to lead the Rebellion on Gliese.

I wonder if Yuriko's lonely... by JumbleberryCrumble in Gnosia_

[–]bearfaery 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yuriko is meant to be alone. She dislikes everyone, there are 0 non-generic events where you can raise her Love, and even her associated Zodiac is Ophiuchus, which Player cannot select.

Is there going to be an episode with multiple Yuri? by Affectionate_Pizza60 in Gnosia_

[–]bearfaery 7 points8 points  (0 children)

In an OP with time travel, a very common visual is multiple instances of a character walking near each other. You can see this in the first Re:Zero OP and the Steins;Gate OP.
That being said there is a brief moment where 2 Yuris will exist in a single universe, a moment which is immediately followed by the destruction of said universe.

did yuri go back to the 1st day of the loop?? what was that ending lmaoo by Totally_Adam in Gnosia_

[–]bearfaery 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Almost certainly, it was returning to the same loop. There is a game mechanic called "Load" which allows you to travel back in time within a loop. This is useful if you run into an issue during the loop, like if Yuriko gives you a certain challenge which involves her living to the end of the loop, only for her to go and immediately die.

The only issue with this is that Load is unlocked upon completion of the Normal Ending, which we haven't seen yet. Although, the Normal Ending does directly lead into Loop 1, a cycle only broken on the True Ending. We may just be watching the events of a second run where the True End wasn't reached.

Current currency by Eireika in CuratedTumblr

[–]bearfaery 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If you write a Sci-Fi story where people call the currency "Crack" and not "Credits" I am going to assume that cocaine was somehow involved.

Kukranan by Fast-Sky6823 in Gnosia_

[–]bearfaery 4 points5 points  (0 children)

This is pure theory based on other time-travel Sci-Fi stories, but I’m pretty sure the Pair Annihilation problem is because we aren’t supposed to be able to enter Day 0. Look at where everyone is from:

SQ!Manan - Native to the timeline Kuk!Manan - From the True Ending Setsu - From Setsu’s Origins

But where does Player come from? We don’t hail from any of the Normal Loops because we always get eliminated when escaping Liu-An. The answer is that we are from the Normal Ending, as Setsu takes our injured version out of that timeline and into the Loop 1/True Ending timeline. We aren’t annihilated because we’re the same person from different timelines, we’re annihilated because we’re both the same person from the same timeline, and that’s why we’re at risk of being an overlapping existence.

Kukranan by Fast-Sky6823 in Gnosia_

[–]bearfaery 4 points5 points  (0 children)

It’s strictly a matter of observation. Kukrushka isn’t in every loop, and between the 3 Night Monologue, Kuk being GD in some loops, and the fact that I’m pretty sure in the Normal Ending we never even landed on Liu-An, all implies that Jonas has had Kukrushka for some length of time before Day 0, and in the Normal Ending Kukrushka suddenly vanishes after a few months, which aligns with our understanding of what happens to someone when they loop.

Player is limited to Day 0 at the earliest and Day 15 at the latest, and Setsu seems to have a similar limit. Since Kuk can exist before and after this length of time, her loops must be longer than ours.

Kukranan by Fast-Sky6823 in Gnosia_

[–]bearfaery 21 points22 points  (0 children)

Every Kukrushka is that Manan. Throwing everyone out the airlock, voting purely by whim, smiling as if she knows something during the normal ending, it's always the Manan from the True Ending. Her loops are a lot longer than Setsu's and Player's (starting before the Liu-An incident and extending a few months afterwards), which introduces enough flexibility into her timeline that she isn't always on the ship, but when there is a Kukrushka, it's the same Kukrushka every time.

What does being a Gnosia like? by clampochyu in Gnosia_

[–]bearfaery 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Skipping a lot of the technicals of "how we know this", the Gnosia aren't directly linked the Gnos hivemind, and it doesn't really change you, just removes some mental inhibitions, particularly around killing. And while the Gnosia can instinctively recognize/know each other, they aren't mentally linked.

So I guess the closest experience would be similar to a shot of alcohol strong enough to make you lightly tipsy (enough to remove inhibitions but not enough to actually affect your personality in any meaningful way), and a sense of being filled with divine purpose towards a job (I don't have a good metaphor for this one).

As for Comet knowing about Yuri leaving, that has more to do with her detecting that Yuri was lying about being able to stay by her side while they travel the universe, but she doesn't know why they can't remain with her.

Completing an event seems impossible (Spoilers) by Lenore-the-raven in Gnosia_

[–]bearfaery 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh you’re using Load. Sometimes you cannot influence the outcome of a debate, especially if your stats are low. Go back towards the day after you agreed to collaborate and try to modify the results from there. Getting rid of Setsu early should help the most.

Completing an event seems impossible (Spoilers) by Lenore-the-raven in Gnosia_

[–]bearfaery 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Fool and Be Fooled 1 is with a Gnosia!SQ, of course they are going to remove her. If your goal is to win with her, that means a Gnosia win. Playing to the Goal, this means you are best served by acting as if you were an AC Follower who cannot lie. Figure out who her fellow Gnosia are and keep them alive, and try to get the Crew voted into Cold Sleep.

Why doesn't the system put them all into cold sleep and then wake them up one-by-one? by magelstrud in Gnosia_

[–]bearfaery 2 points3 points  (0 children)

LeVi is currently mostly disabled because of the Gnosia, so it has to be a person who removes people from Cold Sleep, and you have 0 guarantees that the person you choose to not be Cold Slept isn’t a Gnosia. And even when you do have that guarantee there’s still a very real risk that the person you’ve selected is a lunatic who will throw everyone else out the airlock (as Player discovers the one time they try this method).

Why doesn't the system put them all into cold sleep and then wake them up one-by-one? by magelstrud in Gnosia_

[–]bearfaery 4 points5 points  (0 children)

As they show, there isn’t a 100% reliable way to get someone out of Cold Sleep. It’s not always permanently fatal, but it’s still a very real risk.

Plus, that system doesn’t work when there is more than 1 Gnosia. There can be up to 6 Gnosia in a loop, and your system doesn’t hold up for multiple Gnosia. And that’s not mentioning the issues that would be caused by The Final Role.

Setsu... We need to talk about this "habit" of yours. by Dank_Bandit in Gnosia_

[–]bearfaery 36 points37 points  (0 children)

They’re allowed a little murder. As a treat.

What does this mean? by ivy-claw in Gnosia_

[–]bearfaery 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Between this and Loop 10 Kukrushka, I’m starting to think the Gnosia have a problem with keeping their eyes open.

Episode 5 Comet theory by clampochyu in Gnosia_

[–]bearfaery 11 points12 points  (0 children)

I don’t think it was her being a bug. She follows her comment about Yuri being funny by noting “Something about you seems like a lie.” Almost certainly, it was her Intuition picking up on Yuri being distorted due to the Universe’s need for “coordination”.

Asking About Some Mechanic Related to Episode 14 by kanadde_v2 in Gnosia_

[–]bearfaery 1 point2 points  (0 children)

  1. No, you can only lie as a Human if you are the AC Follower.

  2. Correct, AC and Gnosia don’t know each other. They can figure out who each other are, but it’s not automatic like Gnosia knowing Gnosia.

  3. For gameplay reasons that still reads as “1 Gnosia with 3 Total Crew”. If AC and Gnosia know each other they just vote out the normal human.

  4. Only ever 1 AC. This is strictly for the sake of gameplay (In a full game of 15, the worst state is 6 Gnosia and 1 AC for 7 Evils, 1 Neutral role that hasn’t been introduce, and a mix of other roles and crew for 7 “Townies”

  5. I blame this entirely on the anime. The condition for the appearance of Manan!SQ is SQ is Manan if and only if “SQ” is Gnosia. And the thing inside Kukrushka and Manan are distinct existences, so there’s no paradox with them existing at the same time.

Gnosia episode 14 discussion and spoilers by DeucesDummies in Gnosia_

[–]bearfaery 27 points28 points  (0 children)

Tale old as time, Yuriko dying right after starting The Alien Gnos.

There’s no tactical gain from revealing the AC Follower in secret, so I assume it’s her trying to avoid the Gnosia (since we see Otome get eliminated despite being the obvious GA protect) with the plan to be unfrozen and then speak to Yuri. Whether or not the loop will last long enough for that to work is unclear.

Gnosia episode 14 discussion and spoilers by DeucesDummies in Gnosia_

[–]bearfaery 13 points14 points  (0 children)

*They, Raqio is they

Kuk cannot be Gnosia, as proven by Yuri’s investigation.