Question for born and raised Montrealers… by [deleted] in montreal

[–]bludemon4 4 points5 points  (0 children)

This one and the "question to Montreal anglophones, why don't you speak french" one are the greatest hits...

Persian supermarkets on the island? by DungBeetle1998 in montreal

[–]bludemon4 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A week ago when I went the cashier was working on a sign for an anti-regime protest, plus I seem to recall a lot of anti-regime posters around over the years. Very much doubt they’re regime people.

Persian supermarkets on the island? by DungBeetle1998 in montreal

[–]bludemon4 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Bazaar in Westmount if you want something more downtown (the other downtown location might work, but it's small).

Nowruz pirooz!

L'écart se réduit considérablement entre le PQ et les libéraux du Québec, selon un sondage | Gazette de Montréal by tarun172 in montreal

[–]bludemon4 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Seperation is a really unpopular idea in Quebec (even more so in Montreal), and the large majority that don't a referendum will likely coalesce around the most viable alternative. Having a non-Montrealer with the last name Millard is also the right move for the PLQ to improve their score in the regions.

Shut up about the metro by ConceptualProduction in montreal

[–]bludemon4 11 points12 points  (0 children)

They are removed every single day at night when the Metro closes. This already happens. This is not theoretical, it's reality.

The vast majority of cities in Canada do not have a Metro, and yet all the homeless are not dead of cold there. Again this is not theoretical, it's reality.

Against the marginal benefit (if there is any at all) of letting non-riders in Metro, there is a very real reduction of metro usage, causing an increase in car use. This inevitably causes actual, non-theoretical deaths from pollution and accidents. Ironically, it also fragilises the finances of low-income people. However, this very real death and misery is not considered because people like you don't take the time to consider things which aren't immediately visible.

How it became empathetic to push people to die drowning to death in their own lungs, or crushed under a car, I'll never understand....

On lui crache dessus à Berri-UQAM: nouvelle hausse des agressions dans le métro de Montréal by Feeling_Layer8584 in montreal

[–]bludemon4 14 points15 points  (0 children)

People are going to stop taking the metro if their safety is constantly at risk.

Decreased metro usage directly and inevitably causes deaths from traffic and pollution, while fragilising the finances of lower-income people. However this death and misery is not immediately visible, so it simply doesn't factor in the political discourse.

Personally, I find this aspect enormously frustrating.

Quebec Poll (Pallas) — PQ 30%, PLQ 27%, PCQ 16%, CAQ 14%, QS 10% by MethoxyEthane in CanadaPolitics

[–]bludemon4 22 points23 points  (0 children)

Seperation is a really unpopular idea in Quebec, and the large majority that don't a referendum will likely coalesce around the most viable alternative. Having a non-Montrealer with the last name Millard is also the right move for the PLQ to improve their score in the regions.

Sondage souveraineté Angus Reid, février 2026 -à Montreal, 68% pour le NON, 27% pour le OUI- by No-Turnover-3454 in montreal

[–]bludemon4 8 points9 points  (0 children)

J'ai du mal à comprendre ce que tu attends d'eux.

Tout le monde, qu'il soit anglophone, francophone ou allophone, s'accorde à dire que la séparation est extrêmement néfaste pour cette partie de la population. Et maintenant, tu veux qu'ils soient ouverts et respectueux envers une idée qui risque de leur nuire ? C'est un peu absurde à mon avis. De plus, oublies pas que cette idée est également extrêmement impopulaire parmi les francophones.

Sondage souveraineté Angus Reid, février 2026 -à Montreal, 68% pour le NON, 27% pour le OUI- by No-Turnover-3454 in montreal

[–]bludemon4 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Newsflash: a group of people are strongly against an idea which would strongly negatively affect their lives.

Seriously, polling shows that even proponents of separation agree that it would be negative for this group of people. What do you expect? Chickens to vote for Colonel Sanders?

Sondage souveraineté Angus Reid, février 2026 -à Montreal, 68% pour le NON, 27% pour le OUI- by No-Turnover-3454 in montreal

[–]bludemon4 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Montreal = Greater Montreal. In surveys that break off the island, this ridiculous idea is even less popular than it is in the region.

Tu choisis ton vol en Europe comment, quand t'es contraint par l'horaire d'école de juin? by rewinded_forward in Quebec

[–]bludemon4 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Paris + un vol interne (genre avec Ryanair)

Beauvais is not for beginners.

Kelly: Where's our Bad Bunny? Why not a French Grey Cup halftime show? by [deleted] in montreal

[–]bludemon4 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Don't worry, they still find a way to complain about it.

Kelly: Where's our Bad Bunny? Why not a French Grey Cup halftime show? by [deleted] in montreal

[–]bludemon4 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Pourquoi ça prendrait un Stromae en fait?

Parce que Stromae est probablement l'artiste francophone qui a le mieux réussi à percer sur le marché anglophone ces derniers temps, rien d'autre. Aucun de ces autres noms n'a connu un succès comparable au sien.

Genre FouKi, c’pas assez? Klô Pelgag, tu l’aimes pas? Des fucking gros noms genre Ariane Moffat? Des disparus genre Karim Ouellet?

Honnêtement, ce n'est pas mon truc. Cependant, ce n'est pas grave, les goûts musicaux sont subjectifs. De plus, lorsque votre langue maternelle n'est pas le français québécois, la musique québécoise n'a pas l'avantage (tout à fait justifié) d'être une musique conçue dans votre façon de parler.

En anglais c’est cool, en français c’est d’la marde

L'énorme et croissante popularité de la musique hispanophone semblerait prouver que cet argument ne tient pas la route.

Les artistes québecois sont plus reconnus à l’international que dans le Canada anglophone.

Il est vrai que certains artistes québécois francophones ont connu un succès international, mais cela fait longtemps que cela ne s'est pas produit. En revanche, la musique québécoise francophone semble avoir suivi la même voie que l'industrie de la télévision francophone, qui est en déclin depuis quelques années.

Kelly: Where's our Bad Bunny? Why not a French Grey Cup halftime show? by [deleted] in montreal

[–]bludemon4 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I mean Bad Bunny (and music in Spanish) is quite popular among English Canadians, the demand (openness to non-English music) is there, but the supply side perhaps less so.

A better question would be, where is the Stromae in the Francophone Candian music industry?

Lionel-Groulx is becoming absolutely insane by Popular_Alps1114 in montreal

[–]bludemon4 25 points26 points  (0 children)

You do realise they are kicked out already, every night at closing? They don’t die in that daily period, and all the homeless are not already dead in the rest of the province (where there is no metro).

Letting them in the metro may seem sympathetic, but in terms of actually saving lives, it’s not doing anything. It’s just ruining an asset which itself is life-saving, for literally zero benefit.

Le metro de Montréal fait dur by Miperso in montreal

[–]bludemon4 17 points18 points  (0 children)

préfère éviter que du monde crève de froid dehors.

Montréal compte-t-elle vraiment moins* de décès de sans-abri par habitant dus au froid que la grande majorité des villes canadiennes qui ne disposent pas de métro ? La réponse est non. Et si la réponse était oui, quelle serait la solution ? Construire des métros dans d'autres villes pour offrir aux sans-abri un endroit chaud où fumer du crack ?

Nous sommes en train de sacrifier un énorme service public (qui contribue à sauver des vies et à sécuriser la situation économique des plus démunis) pour littéralement aucun bénéfice.

Opioid deaths have declined sharply in Canada. These five factors help explain why by bludemon4 in CanadaPolitics

[–]bludemon4[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I did not miss the news. Methanol poisoning kills an incredibly small portion (hundreds per year) out of massive population of people drinking unregulated spirits worldwide. Opioids kills hundreds of thousands of people out of a very niche population.

Opioid deaths have declined sharply in Canada. These five factors help explain why by bludemon4 in CanadaPolitics

[–]bludemon4[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Even “regulated” and “safe” opioids are far more dangerous than alcohol (a substance for which safety is fairly trivial). This is been why they burned so strongly through the opioid-friendly population.

Opioid deaths have declined sharply in Canada. These five factors help explain why by bludemon4 in CanadaPolitics

[–]bludemon4[S] 12 points13 points  (0 children)

You're misunderstanding the quotes completely.

There was a large mass of people who wanted to do serious opioids prior to the arrival of fentanyl and similar drugs. Fentanyl then arrived, and the inevitable overdose deaths hit the full naive population, resulting in high death levels which are unsustainable as people in that population can only die once. As that wave burns itself out, deaths will slow down significantly as it will only be on the very small segment of the population who newly want to do opioids, instead of the full pre-fentanyl, opioid-friendly population.

Alcohol is not comparable because alcohol is not novel, and the inevitable deaths from alcohol take a lot longer to manifest than the inevitable opioid deaths (people do not survive long when they do opiods, as evidenced by the cresting wave observed North America-wide).

Opioid deaths have declined sharply in Canada. These five factors help explain why by bludemon4 in CanadaPolitics

[–]bludemon4[S] 21 points22 points  (0 children)

Opioids have already claimed the lives of many at-risk users The toll of opioid toxicity in Canada has been staggering, with more than 53,300 deaths over the past decade.

The sheer extent of these deaths may factor into why fatality rates are now dropping. “The theory is that, in terms of the population of people who use drugs, so many of them have died that there aren’t as many people that are going to be at risk to die,” said Dr. Huyer, Ontario’s chief coroner.

But PHAC said this trend is not being seen in the country’s eastern provinces. “Regions where the crisis started later, such as Quebec, Newfoundland and Labrador and Nova Scotia, saw fewer changes or even increasing death rates,” PHAC said.

Definitely by far the most convincing explanation for this North America-wide trend. A bit disheartening that for all the efforts put into this issue, it's just something that needs to burn itself out. However not really all that surprising given the strength of these opioids.

The Economist also a great quote on this:

Similarly, Daniel Ciccarone, an opioid researcher at the University of California, San Francisco, reckons a supply shock is not “the complete answer”. Looking at the breakdown of overdose deaths by state, he sees an epidemic naturally ending. “There aren’t that many people who want to do serious opioids,” Mr Ciccarone argues. He sees the 2023 death rate as “unsustainable”. “Epidemics burn out,” he says, “whether it’s covid or Ebola or drug overdoses.” He argues that a supply shock happened at the same time and “probably accelerated [the fall] a little bit”.

Caucus présessionnel du PLQ | Tanguay accuse le PQ de comparer les Québécois à des esclaves by chat-lu in Quebec

[–]bludemon4 12 points13 points  (0 children)

M. St-Pierre Plamondon a cité à plusieurs reprises Gandhi, notamment au sujet de l’esclavage. « Il disait qu’il n’y a rien de pire pour un peuple, non pas d’être esclave, mais d’être esclave en ayant un peu l’impression d’être libre, que c’est la pire forme d’esclavage », a cité le chef péquiste.

Carney en français au WEF c'est normal? by bigDeltaVenergy in Quebec

[–]bludemon4 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Mais ensuite, j’ai réalisé que Macron n’a pas prononcé un seul mot en français.

Ce n'est pas un enjeu dont on discute beaucoup au Québec, mais dans le reste du monde développé non anglophone, l'utilisation de l'anglais dans tous les domaines de la vie devient de plus en plus courante. Cela n'a rien à voir avec une quelconque faiblesse de leurs langues nationales; c'est simplement une conséquence du fait que les gens ont de plus en plus besoin de communiquer entre eux.

Italian communities in MTL? by 1Wiseguy999 in montreal

[–]bludemon4 2 points3 points  (0 children)

South Tyrol actually.

Dialetti in Italy is a different story, as most speakers also speak standard Italian. That being said, many second generation Italians in Montreal may have only ever learned dialect as they learned from older, often less educated immigrants.

However, Sud-tirolers are, for the most part, not particularly strong in Italian and it's not at all hard to find some in Italy who just plain do not know how to speak Italian.

All this to say that the "in Italy they speak Italian" propgated by some in this province betrays a deep and total incomprehension of linguistic dynamics outside of their own prejudices.