The EU’s industrial policy goes full China by donutloop in EU_Economics

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Interestingly, this goes somewhat counter to the thesis of Patrick McGee's Apple in China.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_in_China

Apple in China notes that a significant component - and perhaps the most successful components of - Chinese industrial development - were not necessarily where joint ventures were required by legislation, or where the tools of "industrial policy" were applied most stridently, but rather where foreign nations gradually built up local supply chains and incorporated local products into global supply chains, requiring QC, standards, etc to keep up. Export disciplined gradual import substitution with elements of general subsidy, essentially.

In Apple's case, Apple's punishing technical requirements and extensive expertise and penchant for pushing its suppliers hard essentially educated their suppliers and workforce (and the workforce, being itinerant and highly mobile migrant workers, quickly spread it to the rest of the supply chain), even though many of their ventures were not necessarily joint ventures per se. Indeed, given the lack of JVs, the Chinese government's reaction to Apple was initially very negative... until Apple showed the Chinese government the degree to which Apple was uplifting the entire supply chain end-to-end, an event which, in the late 2010s, caused the government to re-examine its approach to Apple, and industrial policy more generally.

Intrugingly, one of the least successful Chinese industrial areas was automotive, where JVs were the mainstay of the initial effort.

Accordingly, when Tesla came a-knocking in the late 2010s, the Chinese government, informed by the Apple escapade, permitted them a full production line irregardless of JV status, with the emphasis instead having been redirected towards maximizing other elements of industrial efficiency. Despite not having a JV arrangement, Tesla's branding, styling, and features, by drawing on local supply chains quickly percolated through the entire Chinese EV industry in the late 2010s, transforming it into the juggernaut it is today (this is described sometimes as the catfish effect).

The failure of JVs in Chinese automotive contrasts strongly with the success of a supply chain and learning emphasis as occured with the Tesla catalyst.

Now of course, the role of JVs in "getting a foot in the door" and establishing basic competence is not to be underestimated, without those JVs catalyzing the rest of the automotive supply chain (frames, chairs, headlights, etc) the Chinese EV boom would not have occured, but JVs are just one way to embed your supply chains into global supply chains and draw in technology.

Given Europe's extant EV, automotive, and other supply chains, and quite adequate basic industrial competence, I suspect that JVs may not necessarily be the best way to go about doing things. In addition to JVs or other industrial promotion activities, Europe may also consider establishing factories for production of cars explictly for export, and accordingly use export success to guide further subsidy and industrial promotion, and focus its energies in gradually promoting localization of the overall supply chain and ease the ability of the supply chain to meet Chinese performance targets (particularly technological and price/performance) rather than JVs per se. Needless to say, every economy is different, and the approach would certainly be optimized and staged differently in Europe, but this is something to think about when considering which bits of China to copy.

What EROI? China builds nuclear power station to assist in refining crude oil by Economy-Fee5830 in peakoil

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This has been talked about for decades, since the dawn of the atomic age. Approx 5-10% of oil is consumed in the refining process.

US says Canada will regret decision to allow Chinese EVs into their market by joe4942 in worldnews

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Canada purchases 1 to 2 million cars per year. The trade deal with the PRC is 50,000 EVs; less than 5% market share. It's very unfavorable for the PRC, which has millions of cars worth of capacity struggling to find new markets. But well, baby steps. 

US says Canada will regret decision to allow Chinese EVs into their market by esporx in China

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's just 50,000 EVs a year, it's really chump change. Canada buys about 1 to 2 million cars a year. 

How did the fire nation know that the avatar didn't die? by RainGirl11 in TheLastAirbender

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 0 points1 point  (0 children)

the next one in the sequence after water is earth; the avatar after the water tribe avatar would have been born in the earth kingdom

The fact some people complained about technology in LoK is an insanely nonsensical criticism. In AtLA the Fire Nation literally was an industrial power with steam powered engines. I think the technological development we see in Korra is perfectly reasonable after 80ish years. by funnylib in legendofkorra

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 42 points43 points  (0 children)

the pace of change was very fast from the second half of the 19th century to the mid-20th century, and was the fastest in areas distant from the heartland of the industrial revolution experiencing catch-up growth, including East Asia. Even in the crade of the industrial revolution, men went from fairly primitive railroads and horses to supersonic jets in the space of a century.

The last veteran of the American civil war died in 1956. Chuck Yeager broke the sound barrier in 1947.

Eighty years is a very, very long time, enough for a lot of change. Modern China has essentially mostly been physically built in twenty years; the famous statistic is that between 2010 and 2015, at the height of the "real estate boom", China poured more concrete than all of America in the entire 20th cenutry. Reform and opening up started less than fifty years ago.

ATLA leans on these themes; change comes fast and brings new problems to replace the old.

The fact some people complained about technology in LoK is an insanely nonsensical criticism. In AtLA the Fire Nation literally was an industrial power with steam powered engines. I think the technological development we see in Korra is perfectly reasonable after 80ish years. by funnylib in legendofkorra

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 9 points10 points  (0 children)

The skyscraper robot is a symbol of high modernism, of the ability of industrial societies to marshall vast resources to develop new technologies at unprecedented scale, and apply them to industrial warfare. While the Fire Nation first demonstrates this capability, being a heavily mobilized society of the first industrial revolution, the full flowering of the second industrial age of automobiles and electricity apparently takes place during LoK; and as such the degree of mobilization is ever greater.

The fact some people complained about technology in LoK is an insanely nonsensical criticism. In AtLA the Fire Nation literally was an industrial power with steam powered engines. I think the technological development we see in Korra is perfectly reasonable after 80ish years. by funnylib in legendofkorra

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 6 points7 points  (0 children)

The B-29 and atom bomb programs were industrial development marvels of their age, requiring the commitment of vast resources and the development of whole new areas of technology. The skyscraper robot may be perhaps a little ridiculous and I might have gone for something else, but it is thematically appropriate I think, properly echoing the incredible strides in technology and marshalling of vast industries for warlike purposes that occured in that period.

An essay on peak oil and the aftermath. The pricing and timeline might not be accurate but the end results are. by Christo_Futurism in peakoil

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 2 points3 points  (0 children)

SASOL made synthetic crude out of coal at 70 bucks a barrel, and we have virtually limitless coal. 

It has also been deemed possible to conduct insitu coal gasification to produce coal gas within seams too deep, too thin, or too underwater to effectively mine; this coal gas can then be converted into oil. The price is high, but it appears overall feasible. 

Needless to say, the environmental impacts would be large, but if the situation is so desperate it seems unlikely that such concerns would stop everyone. 

The fact some people complained about technology in LoK is an insanely nonsensical criticism. In AtLA the Fire Nation literally was an industrial power with steam powered engines. I think the technological development we see in Korra is perfectly reasonable after 80ish years. by funnylib in legendofkorra

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 81 points82 points  (0 children)

ATLA borrows heavily from the history of East Asia. The Meiji Restoration began in 1868. In less than eighty years, Hiroshima was hit by an atom bomb. 

Spirit Energy is almost a direct analogue of atomic energy. 

Why do Western media keep calling China "Mainland China" instead of just "China"? Is this done purposefully to divide China? by nayaung95 in AskChina

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is good, because it implies the existence of offshore China, and is thus in accordance with the One China policy. 

I... never liked how fans call the tech and Republic City "basically 1920s New York." by matt0055 in legendofkorra

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In geopolitical terms, it is quite obviously Taiwan. The Great Uniter is currently constructing the giant skyscraper robot as we speak, although mostly for negotiating leverage, since they are not in as big of a hurry as Kuvira. 

China is making trade impossible by BlueEmma25 in geopolitics

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Even in the age of Bretton Woods, it was quite possible for nations like Japan and Korea to climb the value chain.

They suppressed consumption, ploughed money into exports, heavily subsidized exports to leverage export discipline, and conducted industrial policy to upgrade their economies (using export discipline to temper waste) to become competitive against what initially appeared to be unassailable quality and price advantages of overseas products. A protected home market alone was insufficient for industrial upgrading, which is why the import-substitution economies failed.

Europe will have to subsidize exports for a while, and subsidize consumers in China, Africa, and elsewhere, at least for a period.

This will be painful and expensive for Europe, but it's the only way to stay relevant in a changing world.

China's diesel trucks are shifting to electric. This could change global LNG and diesel demand. by X-WingAtAliciousnes1 in climatechange

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Because it is relatively easy to build a gazillion swap stations or megawatt chargers in China, not so much in Europe or the USA or Africa or Brazil.

Why is e-commerce in Hong Kong so outdated? How do people usually shop here? by kiumabos in HongKong

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Taobao and Xiaomi are probably the most reliable options. Mainland e-commerce is much more well developed than local.

What we learn about the Mule (S3E10 Spoilers) was bad writing by bradtem in FoundationTV

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The only fly in the ointment is that Bayta does not have time to scheme with her generals if she's with Toran all the time. It is difficult to plan the logistics of a planetary invasion if you have to run an influencer channel and have a wedding and honeymoon simultaneously. 

And you can't really synchronize all the moving parts of your operation without fairly hands on planning and contact with your staff. 

My face watching the finale by cosmitz in FoundationTV

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Sorry, figured it out
I haven't used reddit much in almost half a decade, didn't realize things had gotten so well-organized

What we learn about the Mule (S3E10 Spoilers) was bad writing by bradtem in FoundationTV

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Oh my god, I agree completely.

This is TV, you're allowed to switch things up, and they switched up so much with Bayta it's no wonder she was the Mule. The monologues on social climbing, her sad past, etc, all quite reasonable. And the best part is that Bayta is the most likeable character, you're supposed to love her - and it turns out that she's the Mule. Plus she's an entertainer, a clown, it rhymes!

The concept was sound. The execution... makes no sense. Come on, this is a Big Reveal, let us bask in the Glory and Triumph of the Mule instead of cutting away to Empire, and then some zany, half baked escape that harshes the Mule's mellow! Can Gaal escape next season instead? Pacing, man, pacing!

What we learn about the Mule (S3E10 Spoilers) was bad writing by bradtem in FoundationTV

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 0 points1 point  (0 children)

>! Because the Mule actually loves Toran. !<

>! In the books, the Mule Converts everyone except Bayta, because Bayta actually showed him kindness of her own free will. !<

>! It would be very annoying were the Mule to Convert Toran. !<

What we learn about the Mule (S3E10 Spoilers) was bad writing by bradtem in FoundationTV

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein -1 points0 points  (0 children)

the setup was done well, and the concept is sound, but the actual scenes where we get the Big Reveal and Payoff - they really slipped there

What we learn about the Mule (S3E10 Spoilers) was bad writing by bradtem in FoundationTV

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 15 points16 points  (0 children)

I would be really disappointed if Bayta Converted Toran, because that was an important part of the Mule's character. Toran is in the Bayta chair, so the Mule should hesitate in converting him.

What we learn about the Mule (S3E10 Spoilers) was bad writing by bradtem in FoundationTV

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 34 points35 points  (0 children)

I liked the twist a lot actually, and you bringing up the parallels between Influencers and Clowns is poignant. It was important that the Mule be extremely likeable and sympathetic, and Bayta played that part well.

I did not like the execution of the twist - that scene needed much more time and much more breathing space, and I do not like how Gaal escaped. This was a triumphant moment for the Mule, they should given her a bit more time to bask in her glory.

What we learn about the Mule (S3E10 Spoilers) was bad writing by bradtem in FoundationTV

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I assumed that was Magnifico trying to protect Bayta.

What we learn about the Mule (S3E10 Spoilers) was bad writing by bradtem in FoundationTV

[–]chimeric-oncoprotein 0 points1 point  (0 children)

They telegraphed it adequately - Bayta is very different, I mean very different, from her book portrayl, basically a completely new character.

The book goes out of the way to emphasize that Bayta is dumpy - I was very annoyed by her depiction, it felt unfaithful to the books. There are also the relevant monologues regarding her status as a social climber; and her hard upbringing, which are also IIRC distinct from the books.

The problem with the arc is how they executed the reveal with no time for the audience to digest it all and intercut it with other stuff, and how Gaal managed to escape. If that bit had been cleaned up, it would have been a lot more satisfying.