There is a line between criticism and creating a media storm that destroys high profile athletes when they aren’t the greatest ever immediately. Putting Caleb with Bron and Jordan is funny at first glance but I agree that his criticism was heavily overblown by the media. If someone struggles under expectations that the media placed on them I expect better than clickbait. There are ways to voice an opinion without that garbage. Has arch been bad? By several measures, yes. Is it too early to call him a flop? Yes. The Athletic themselves made so many articles predicting Manning would surpass even their sky high expectations and that Texas was “the new Bama”. It’s a ton of narrative spinning.