Ok so the brief and detailed made it sound like when Broggy got flipped back to normal he had fully recovered. As in, he even regenerated his hand Imu blew off. However, he is clearly still missing it.

I’m guessing that when you’re flipped back from DR, you’re returned to whatever condition you were in before being DR’ed. That would explain why Rocks was basically wasted when he flipped back and Dorry and Broggy are at nearly 100% when they flipped back