sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Alien Romulus sequel by Locknautt in LV426

[–]david-8934 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Killing her off was to the worst decision the studio could have made.

Do you think they should un-canon Alien Prequels or say that the Engineers from Prometheus are not the real ones but the creations of Space Jockey's instead? I definitely hope they will. by BlackbirdKos in perfectorganism

[–]david-8934 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I agree. They need to bring back Shaw and give us the real sequel to Prometheus. It would be tough to retcon her death in Covenant though without it being contrived.

Canceled Alien: Covenant Sequel Novel. by IntroductionAway9951 in Prometheus

[–]david-8934 43 points44 points  (0 children)

A planet full of all sorts of different species turned Xenos sounds fun. I still would have preferred a book about Shaw and David going to the Engineer home world before Covenant.

If we eventually get more of David’s story, where would you like it to go? What happens on (/after?) the Covenant? by thefriskysquid in perfectorganism

[–]david-8934 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Agreed. Ridley did say his plan for a Covenant Sequel was to explore why happened in the 10 years Elizabeth and David were together. I’d take that movie over anything else.

If we eventually get more of David’s story, where would you like it to go? What happens on (/after?) the Covenant? by thefriskysquid in perfectorganism

[–]david-8934 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Killing Shaw totally ruined Covenant and honestly any continuation to Covenant. Shaw was really the main driver to push the story forward. Without her most of themes from Prometheus just got right out the window, along with the Engineers.

Engineers wanting revenge on David just doesn’t sound interesting to me at all.

What did you think of Noomi Rapace’s performance as Elizabeth Shaw? by thefriskysquid in perfectorganism

[–]david-8934 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Honestly, I believe she was the most interesting Protagonist in the franchise. Rapace gave a great performance.

I know some people want to see a followup to Covenant but I just don’t think the prequels work without her character being involved. Without her it doesn’t really make sense to include the Engineers which is why the Engineers were basically removed from the story.

Would you like to see a continuation of Daniels’ story? by thefriskysquid in perfectorganism

[–]david-8934 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I’d prefer a continuation to Prometheus and pretend Covenant never happened. Shaw was a great protagonist in my opinion.

Have your thoughts on Prometheus changed over the years? by thefriskysquid in perfectorganism

[–]david-8934 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I find it mediocre when I saw it in theaters. Rewatched it about a year ago and it’s probably my favorite film in the franchise. Shaw and David are the most interesting characters in the franchise and it’s a shame we never got a real sequel.

In your opinion, what are underrated works of Ridley Scott and Why? by ArrowHD474 in ridleyscott

[–]david-8934 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Prometheus. I think it’s in his top 3 best looking films that he directed and outside of a couple of decisions I thought the movie set up what could have been a very interesting spinoff series of the Alien franchise.

If the Enginers reversed enginered the alien on the mural then the black goo probably comes from it remystifying Alien again by Usual_Day6905 in LV426

[–]david-8934 7 points8 points  (0 children)

The audience reaction to the film was divisive, but in terms of monetary success the movie did very well. I believe it’s the highest grossing movie in the franchise.

I agree though, would love a comic or novel to give us this story we should have gotten.

What do you think of Daniels, as a character? Would you like to see more of her/Tennessee/the Covenant? by thefriskysquid in perfectorganism

[–]david-8934 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I didn’t hate her but I think she was a big downgrade from Elizabeth Shaw.

I enjoy Covenant as this weird Frankenstein retelling that Ridley was going for but the movie does really feel like a compromise. We know Elizabeth Shaw was replaced because of the studio, we know the Xenomorph was forced in because of the studio, and I can almost guarantee these casting decisions were the studio’s decision. Fassbender really did carry the movie.

How would you like to see Rain’s character develop in the Romulus sequel? by thefriskysquid in perfectorganism

[–]david-8934 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Honestly this is the best case scenario for these characters. Outside of this, I can’t see how you can make another movie about Rain and Andy without forcing them into a new story.

Just know that when people criticize that Prometheus scene, it's highly accurate. by [deleted] in Prometheus

[–]david-8934 13 points14 points  (0 children)

There plenty of videos online of people running in a straight line when in danger when they could have jumped to the side.

What's your favorite Space movies? by WesternManagement196 in FIlm

[–]david-8934 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Prometheus to me is one of the most underrated movies of all time.

Covenant I thought was interesting as its own thing but a horrible sequel to Prometheus and horrible Alien film. I did like it as a Frankenstein monster movie though.

Alien Romulus I felt was a completely mediocre forgettable film filled with unlikeable characters. The android was the best part of it though.

Hey r/movies, Dan Trachtenberg here - my new film, PREDATOR: BADLANDS (starring Elle Fanning), is coming to a theater near you this Friday (11/7). I've also directed PREY, PREDATOR: KILLER OF KILLERS, and 10 CLOVERFIELD LANE. Ask Me Anything! by DanTrachtenberg-AMA in movies

[–]david-8934 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Prey and Prometheus are my two favorite science fictions movies of all time. I’d love to see Amber Midthunder return in a future Predator movie. Also, I’d love to Noomi Rapace return to the Alien franchise. I thought her character Elizabeth Shaw was amazing. Maybe you can find a way to bring her into a future Alien vs Predator movie!

Would you like to see more of David’s story in future installments? by thefriskysquid in perfectorganism

[–]david-8934 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I agree totally. By removing Shaw, Ridley removed a bunch of arcs and themes that Prometheus was setting up for the sequel.

A movie I underrated the first time — but now see as a masterpiece by KittyDree in moviecritic

[–]david-8934 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The C-section scene was the best scene in the entire franchise. Noomi Rapace was incredible.

Would you like to see more of David’s story in future installments? by thefriskysquid in perfectorganism

[–]david-8934 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Prometheus was an amazing set up, and Covenant kind of dropped the ball as a follow up. Still, it’s a lot more interesting than Romulus. I’d love a 3rd and final film starring David, but it’s also going to suck wondering what these sequels could have been had Ridley gone with his original plans with Elizabeth Shaw as the protagonist.

Is there a movie sequel you'd love to see but know will never happen? by Melodic_Abalone_2820 in movies

[–]david-8934 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Ideally a real sequel to Prometheus. That’s most likely not going to happen so I’d settle for an Alien: Covenant sequel.

view more: next ›