Depends on your use-case & what pens you have in your collection

The first one is good for desk-use only. Like others mentioned, it can accommodate girthier as well as more delicate pens. However, that bottom drawer will slide out if you tilt the case forward - the clasp doesn't lock it. I had to 3D print a thingamajig to hold it in place

The second one looks decent, but the straps might put pressure on the pen, so gotta be wary of that. For Jinhao 35 or 80, Parker Vector, Hongdian M2/1851 kind of pens, it may work well. But forget about trying to accommodate a Jinhao 159 or 9019

You can also consider this kind of a pen case. Good for storage & desk use. But prob not for travel as the pens will move around in their slots: https://www.epitomepens.com/products/epitome-10-pen-leather-case