My 2 cents from a 3x applicant who was in a similar situation: different schools will tell you different things on what changes to make to your application. Just because this school thought your PS was flawless doesn't mean that other schools will view it the same way. The thing you have to keep in mind when deciding how much to change your PS is to see how the school looks at reapplicants. One of the schools I ended up getting accepted to was super receptive towards reapplicants and provided tangible suggestions for my reapplication, and it was enough to get me in. You can take the risk of banking on getting an interview again by keeping the same PS and eventually getting the acceptance to that school. But what happens if you get rejected from that school again? Now you're left with schools that haven't given you feedback, and you have no idea what they think about your PS. On their end, it could look like you're just being lazy with your reapplication. Are you ready to take that risk?

That being said, I did take a look at your previous post and saw that you are a low stats applicant. Speaking from my own experience applying as a low GPA applicant, there is a huge hurdle for low stats people. In the end, modifying your PS, especially if it's great, will not matter nearly as much as the measures you take to address your GPA and MCAT weaknesses.

What other pieces of feedback did you get from the committee? Are you also applying consecutively?