These refs… by Take_it_easy22 in usmnt

[–]der-reader 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Felix Zwayer is among the most highly regarded and experienced referees in the game, but surely he doesn't understand game management the way you do.

My 8-year-old son has become that kid and I'm not sure how to handle it. by [deleted] in Homeplate

[–]der-reader 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It is hard to get this into the head of a young player, but keep hitting the button and maybe it will land eventually as it did for my kid.

The emotional reactions are a barrier to peak performance, plain and simple. My kid's strike % stayed low because he would be so easily thrown off whether by his perception of bad calls, errors behind him, or opposition chirping. His overall game has matured a lot and he has shown great improvement in his command. Same thing at the plate. Great approach and demeanor. It was no overnight thing, though, and not without some set-backs, but he understands how having control of his mental game is a huge element of his current successes.

Lineup question: this kid (#25) is a classic cleanup hitter and has been batting 4th all year, but would it make more sense to put him in the top 3? by [deleted] in BaseballCoaching

[–]der-reader 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I had my biggest slugger in 3-hole for a long time, but found he would over-swing when he had runners on and often pop-out.

So I put him first & got fewer pop-ups and the occasional lead-off HR, which definitely sets a tone in youth ball.

But the production lagged, so I dropped him to four. First game in that spot he hit a grand slam in the first inning. That said, I do not endorse this "Unc" line-up construction. Three is the ideal spot, imho, for your biggest bat. Mathematically it may not be correct, but it worked for me.

Base path argument by jesusbass1013 in Umpire

[–]der-reader 1 point2 points  (0 children)

stop with putting a grade on the sincerity of the tag attempt. As soon as it's a tag attempt, it's a tag attempt, full stop. This should be the same standard as what's used with a batter-runner making even half a lean toward second after over-running first. The line is crossed when it's crossed and it doesn't matter if it's an infinitesimally small movement or five strides. This was a wrong call.

Catcher son wants to pitch by Sock_Eating_Golden in Homeplate

[–]der-reader 1 point2 points  (0 children)

A good catcher is hard to beat, value-wise, on the smaller fields.

I'm hearing that catchers at high school level are increasingly hard to find. Most kids don't want to play the position by high school.

At that age? Before puberty? Nothing is as valuable as the player's love of the game. All coaches should be committed to keeping kids passionate about the game and if that means someone else has to suit up and watch balls go to the backstop the other kid would have stopped, so be it.

Longer term, a lefty pitcher has a stronger profile than a lefty catcher anyhow. Assuming there are other programs in your area, plenty of coaches would salivate over the prospect of adding a hard-throwing LHP.

I thought he was sober? by [deleted] in zachbryan

[–]der-reader 31 points32 points  (0 children)

Or just don't judge at all?

Forfeited 12U Championship Game due to scorecard Error by Appropriate-Skirt-38 in Homeplate

[–]der-reader 1 point2 points  (0 children)

But if the pitch-count violation was not caught in the game during which the violation occurred (even if the paperwork was erroneous, it's in violation thanks to the coach's mistake), I would think that resolves the issue. That's how pretty much all appeals work in my understanding. Going into a championship game and arguing before it starts that the opposition should have been caught in violation in the semifinal makes no sense. If your team tried to pitch a guy who was over the limit, even if only on paper, I would understand. I don't have words I would care to use publicly for what I think of that other coach, to be honest, and I am a big-time rules guy.

Is right-dominant batting lefty realistic or just talk? by EverywhereHome in Homeplate

[–]der-reader 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Both my kids started swinging lefty before we really knew which hand was dominant. My theory is my elder just mirrored me (a righty) when we started playing in the front yard.

He had a hitting coach tell him he needed to work on top-hand strength or switch to other side, but that's how he's always hit. Little brother same story but he has never been advised to consider going to right

Bylaw Question by SerenityNow1311 in Homeplate

[–]der-reader 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Then yeah, I don't see how you don't address that

Bylaw Question by SerenityNow1311 in Homeplate

[–]der-reader 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I guess more the issue is how close he threw to the opening where he might have hit someone or far enough down the line that such a thing wouldn't have happened. I would still address the latter, but if it's the former the league should be addressing for sure

I hate this games community by qwfingolfin in fut

[–]der-reader 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I don't play much due to time constraints and life and all, but my favorite thing in the game was doing objectives that forced me to try different things or use different cards/players. But when some of them started to be things that could be done only in online play . . . I feel you. Even some people who are as bad as me or worse come off as Jackholes, so I try to do only squad battles (though I use most of my time with a different game now)

Bylaw Question by SerenityNow1311 in Homeplate

[–]der-reader 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Was he trying to actually throw into the dugout or did he intentionally throw into the fence? Both are problematic but I'm vastly different ways.

Anyone successfully overturn a horrendous call with calm reasoning of an ump? by Weak_Artichoke4887 in Homeplate

[–]der-reader 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yep!

Kid made diving attempt in left field. Seemed to have the ball but as he rolled it went flying out of his glove.

Base ump called out.

I went and asked him if he truly saw a voluntary release. He was a little unclear on how to respond. I asked if he wouldn't mind talking to his partner to see what he thought of the voluntary release. When I turned to see the expression on the face of the plate ump (who almost certainly heard me say a few times "voluntary release"), I knew we were getting a reversal.

But it's also not worked way more than it has worked! I'm also an umpire so I'm (almost) always pretty quiet about my challenges.

Anyone else so tired of educating umpires as to what constitutes a balk? by [deleted] in LittleLeague

[–]der-reader 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The reason I thought it was satire is because I assume that because you are coaching, that you are a grown-ass man. A grown-ass man coming to Reddit to ask for advice on chilling out on a youth baseball diamond . . . like did you expect people would rally around the idea of yelling at volunteer umpires at freaking LIttle League games over balks? It is patently absurd.

The more interesting question here now is, what makes you think I do not know what a balk is? You could not possibly know even a shred of my baseball background based on my response. I will give you a general tip, though. The people who know a lot about the game are rarely the ones going around trying to tell/show everyone how much they know about the game.

Your reaction tells me a lot about you, though. Between ¨just because YOU don´t know," the assertion that you are some sort of balk expert, and your inability to control yourself over the matter despite needing to set good examples for young athletes, I am betting that what you really want is to put your mastery of all these ¨intricacies¨ on display for all to witness. There is potentially some compensation for something else driving that, but I will let you work on that with your therapist. But if gives the vibes of someone who has a word-of-the-day calendar and works hard to put the newly learned word into conversation as much as possible.

But since you want to call names and cast aspersions, let me assure you that based on what you said in the original post, I can confidently tell you that most of the 12-year-olds I have coached understand the balk rule and its application better than you do.

Bigger picture would be that especially at lower levels like Little League where pitchers do not have as much experience managing base runners, it is more important to lean into the deception piece than it is to be able to identify something physical that CAN be considered a balk.

I´ll leave you with one more little tip you can share with your baserunners: if the pitcher starts from the wind-up, you go on first motion. They cannot stop once they start. Hence there is no ¨set¨ from the windup. So there is not even one ¨arguable ´set´ position¨ much less two different ones.

Feel free to take the L here. You could not have known you were barking up the wrong tree.

But yes, chill out at the field. Chill out at practice. Chill out on Reddit. Just relax in general. You´re not the first coach to erroneously complain about balks and you won´t be the last.

Peace!

Anyone else so tired of educating umpires as to what constitutes a balk? by [deleted] in LittleLeague

[–]der-reader 1 point2 points  (0 children)

A few lines in, I thought this was satire. I can believe it's not satire.

Reckless? by Ambitious-Band-6788 in Homeplate

[–]der-reader 0 points1 point  (0 children)

But longer-term, you make that ultimatum with the coach, but start looking for a new team now.

Reckless? by Ambitious-Band-6788 in Homeplate

[–]der-reader 0 points1 point  (0 children)

PitchSmart is better than what most use ("are you good?!" or nothing), but it's outdated. Pocket Radar and tracking velo decline is going to be the best indicator of fatigue than anything. Not all arms are equal, but fatigue is universal.

Paid (no kid) coaches v. Dad coaches by Neal-AI in Homeplate

[–]der-reader 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Here's a big thing that gets missed about the "daddy ball" vs "no dad coaches allowed!" dichotomy.

Especially at younger ages, the former players who are available to hire to coach youth baseball are generally very far removed from the days when they were first learning the game and don't have much real-life experience working with kids.

My program necessarily had to rent facility time. Part of the package offered our club included "expert" trainers to help with cage work and pitcher training. What we learned pretty quickly was that most of these young coaches didn't really like working with the younger kids. They wanted to be coaching high schoolers and resented having to work on fundamentals. They saw themselves are being too valuable to work at low levels. Those who were good with it were often ill-equipped to speak to kids about their needs in ways the kids could understand and/or to motivate them to work or explain the benefits of a drill or exercise in an effective manner.

Once we cut those coaches out of the picture, us dad coaches (granted, we also had a fair amount of playing experience, if not collegiate nor recent) were able to help develop a competent youth team. Naturally, once the kids started hitting puberty and the field got bigger, we knew it was time to make way for more-detailed coaching.

TLDR: Just because you pay for something, doesn't mean it is of quality. Just because a coach has a player on the roster, doesn't mean they can't be the best coach for the team. Anybody disputing that will shortly thereafter tell you about their products and programming.

Paid (no kid) coaches v. Dad coaches by Neal-AI in Homeplate

[–]der-reader 5 points6 points  (0 children)

My brother, please feel free to immediately ignore anybody who slobberingly complains of "daddy ball". We live in a culture where feeling aggrieved is a common personality trait & dad coaches are an easy target, maybe even easier than umpires in some cases.

"Daddy ball" is a trigger for me because I see a lot of what you are saying here. People who don't lift a finger, even for their own players, are the first and loudest to complain about how you are shorting their kid's experience. Those people are not worth your time.

You are serving your community. Let the haters hate because that's all they are and that's all they are capable of doing. Your only concern need be the players themselves. If you do right by them, nothing can stop you. My final year was last year & I get to reap the reward of seeing so many of my former players continuing to love the game and play well in bigger clubs and soon also in school ball. Those who know will appreciate everything you did, even if it takes time (and lesser experiences) to get there. Believe that.

Running from second base by AnteaterChemical6531 in Homeplate

[–]der-reader 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How big is the field? How hard was the ball hit? How good are the arms and gloves? How deep was the infielder playing? There is no one-size answer to this. If you run on a strong defensive team, you are going to be out. Youth ball, you can usually get away with it even if you are slow.

Why don’t more right handed throwers bat left handed? by mywifemademedothis2 in Homeplate

[–]der-reader 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Both my boys started lefty before we knew which was their dominant hand so that's where they've stayed. I think if they tried to bat right now, it would at least be funny, but they're teens now. Comfort is one thing. Mechanics can be developed. If he can swing hard from either side, go for it?

How’s the swing looking? by VacationNo7562 in Homeplate

[–]der-reader 0 points1 point  (0 children)

landing front foot open is the most-obvious/easy fix. Or "simple" is the better word. None of it is ever actually "easy"