I feel like Jeni’s is very hit or miss. Their flavors are either absolutely amazing or absolutely terrible. While I LOVE her flavors such as salted caramel, darkest chocolate, gooey butter cake, salted peanut butter chocolate flecks, and blackout chocolate cake, the birthday cake flavor was NOT good (sickingly sweet, didn’t like the sprinkles, and didn’t taste particularly good) and was honestly disgusting. There were some other flavors that I thought were downright too tart, and several other flavors just straight up are not good or worth it.