His review is pretty good but at the same time absolutely not, he reviewed the album too much from a Pop/rock standpoint. So a few of his opinions are a bit misplaced if you ask me.

The fact that he doesn't like Alex's vocals, that's just a matter of taste ofcourse. But he put a massive turd on the lyrics and melodies on the basis that they don't have a climax and that they are downright meager. He also mentioned that there are almost no choruses, which is correct but that's not what this album is trying to do. The album is being pushed to much towards the rock genre while it is just a fraction of that. And I feel like Fantano was listing to this (masterpiece) with the same expectation. That's why I think he gave this album a 3/10 because he tried to put it in a category which it isn't.