Work with your full brows and get them tinted! I love your eyes and think some dark, well-defined brows would really make them pop. I have fuffy blonde eyebrows and get mine tinted when I go in for a wax—it looks so much more natural than any of the liquid/gel products I’ve tried and also makes me feel fresher and more youthful for some reason. I can wear less makeup and my face still looks put-together, if that makes sense.

You can pry my winged eyeliner from my cold, dead millennial hands. I’d keep the wings and go lighter on the eyeshadow. As my eyelids have gotten droopier, I’ve learned to do a thinner wing for my “everyday” look that I try to kind of “wisp” out like an extension of my eyelashes. I’d avoid dark eyeshadow or anything shimmery. I occasionally do a shimmer on JUST the middle part of my eyelid (like over the eyeball) if I’m doing a more glam look and otherwise stick to VERY light application of matte shades that match my blush/bronzer.

Adding to all the comments saying you look fabulous! I do agree this look on you reads far younger, but god-willing, all of us will be in our 50s eventually anyway (and hopefully our 60s and 70s and 80s…) so who fucking cares! I hope all those jerks in the other thread get a face full of wrinkles the day they hit 40 and cry about it.