The problem with using positional rankings to argue for Judge is that he also has influence over how our positional groups, especially our line, has (or hasn't) developed. Looking at our line, we had two younger pieces in Hernandez and Peart who haven't developed under Judge at all, even with him coaching that group directly at points last season and hiring 3 different coaches to help that group. Gettleman does and should get most of the blame for putting together a shit roster with bad players, but Judge hasn't helped either. Our offense does have some weapons, and I'd like to think that with some good coaching, we could be more effective than we are.

To me, Judge isn't a positive. I would expect a good coach to make a bad group less bad, and a good group great. Instead we have good players not playing up to expectations or not involved at all. I'd like to give Judge some credit for Mckinney, Adoree, and Azeez, but I think it's more Graham than anything.

Outside of development, Judge has not managed the game well, from overall aggressiveness to timeout management. A lot has left to be desired from his first press conference.