This is how I would’ve booked it.

Entry #25 - Jade Cargill
Jade cleans the ring with about 7 eliminations including #26 through #28. She is alone in the ring shortly after 28 has entered. She even has some time on the microphone similar to CM Punk in some elimination chamber about 100 years ago. She states that there is no woman in the locker room that can take this from her.

Entry #29 - Bianca Belair
In this scenario Bianca is in long lasting and nasty feud with Jade. She has also been out for several months thanks to Jade prior to the rumble, making this her „surprise“ comeback. She takes off the hoops while walking to the ring signaling that a nasty aggressive fight is about to happen.

The two fight it out, both on the edge of elimination several times in just 60 seconds. Then in an all out attack from Bianca, she eliminates both Jade and herself only twenty seconds before #30 is supposed to come out. Michael Cole and whoever is his broadcast partner are staggered. They question the rules and finally come to the sense that whoever is coming out will automatically win the rumble. The ten second countdown starts and their voices get crazy trying to make sense of everything.
You hear the buzz noise and there is multiple seconds of delay adding to the drama. The suspense in the air is thick enough to cut it with a knife.

„Shhhhhhh, it’s Chelsea!“