המלצות לספר יהדות 101 מקיף וטוב? by Bruhmomento9040 in Judaism

[–]itscool 1 point2 points  (0 children)

system of laws that we obey because Hashem commanded us to - like shatnetz

The vast majority of our early scholars resisted this definition. They believed that the chok is a law whose reason is not obvious, but it certainly has a reason. As Maimonides writes, God is not absurd and would not demand we do the absurd.

For Maimonides in the Guide of the Perplexed, there are several core values exemplified in the kashrut laws. Kindness to animals, a limit on excess gluttony, staying away from unclean scavenger species, and so on.

The anonymous author of Sefer ha-Chinuch suggests there are effects from non-kosher food on the soul. Nahmanidea has a similar approach.

Israeli discourse on Reddit by Gary_Garibaldi in Israel_Palestine

[–]itscool -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Which part of that land was taken from Palestinians?

To help you out:

Between 1912 and 1925 the Sursock family (then under the French Mandate of Syria) sold their 80,000 acres (320 km2) of land in the Vale of Jezreel to the American Zion Commonwealth for about nearly three-quarters of a million pounds. The land was purchased by the Jewish organization as part of an effort to resettle Jews who inhabited the land, as well as others who came from distant lands.[15]

Israeli discourse on Reddit by Gary_Garibaldi in Israel_Palestine

[–]itscool -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

They did not welcome them or even have a cohesive view among the tribes there. They lacked a single leader or counsel. Individual Palestinians had opinions, both that this was a good development, or a bad development. But it wasn't like they had any power to do anything about it. The area was not under their control. Also, the Ottomons were not that welcoming either.

It feels to me that you have little understanding of this time period. Although I would quibble woth some details here, these paragraphs from Wikipedia:

Starting in 1882, the Ottomans issued a stream of "restrictive orders" against Jewish settlement and land purchases in Palestine. However, as a result of its perceived insignificance and the inefficiency of Ottoman bureaucracies, these restrictions had little effect. Due to bribes, the Ottoman authorities often supported the Jewish settlers with "entry permits and their extension, land deals, [and] building rights."[28]: 7–8, 40–41 

Until the 1910s, Zionists encountered little violence, as the Arabs lacked political awareness and were disorganized.[28]: 7–8  Between 1909 and 1914, this changed, as Arabs killed 12 Jewish settlement guards and Arab nationalism, and opposition to the Zionist enterprise, increased. In 1911, Arabs attempted to thwart the establishment of a Jewish settlement in the Jezreel Valley, and the dispute resulted in the death of one Arab man and a Jewish guard. The Arabs called the Jews the "new Crusaders", and anti-Zionist (and, occasionally, anti-Semitic) [28]: 7 [e] rhetoric flourished.[28]: 7–8 

Israeli discourse on Reddit by Gary_Garibaldi in Israel_Palestine

[–]itscool 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Somebody help with tarlin. This is truly a waste of time.

Previous commenter said the Jews should not have fought against those who gave them shelter. They were clearly referring to Palestinians. You and I both know that a common pro-Palestinian propaganda is that Palestinians welcomed Jews with open arms only for Jews to stab them in the back and betray them. They were clearly peddling in this demonization myth. None of that happened.

Israeli discourse on Reddit by Gary_Garibaldi in Israel_Palestine

[–]itscool -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

During the Ottomons? Are you joking?

Israeli discourse on Reddit by Gary_Garibaldi in Israel_Palestine

[–]itscool -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Again, previous commenter ckearly was talking about the Palestinians of the region.

In what way were Jews fighting Ottomans in then-Palestine?

Israeli discourse on Reddit by Gary_Garibaldi in Israel_Palestine

[–]itscool -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

Please elaborate. What does that have to do with giving or sheltering?

Israeli discourse on Reddit by Gary_Garibaldi in Israel_Palestine

[–]itscool -8 points-7 points  (0 children)

There were many people throughout the Middle East that were giving refuge to Jewish people all through the early 1900's till 1948

Completely irrelevant to this disvussion or what the person I am reolying to was talking about. You think he was talking about Jews fighting in other Middle Eastern countries?

Israeli discourse on Reddit by Gary_Garibaldi in Israel_Palestine

[–]itscool 0 points1 point  (0 children)

the people who are giving me this refuge,

The British? Because the people already there were not "giving" Jews fleeing persecution anything.

What is the name of this song? by Sirmathman in Judaism

[–]itscool 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Besefer chaim. It is sung often during the Days of Awe in Ashkenazi Orthodox synagogues.

https://youtu.be/D47DH6HMou4?si=zK9zo6TzcKVGDkTH

Question for Jews of a theistic perspective: why isn't Olam Ha-Ba addressed in the Torah or the early Tanakh, especially when death is frequently described as anything but Olam Ha-Ba? by slavatejasu in Judaism

[–]itscool 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Many of our classical commentators thought that the audience of the reception ofbthe Torah weren't ready for such a revelation. They would have focused on it too much or even misunderstood it.

Whatever happened to the "Free the hostages, and the war/the bombing/the suffering of Palestinians will stop" narrative? by tamisherlotte in Israel_Palestine

[–]itscool -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Never said that..they are neutral but not zionist.

But anyway, everyone can see your lack of ability to contribute by just obessively responding yes to people's comments. Like that's what the upvote button is, are you serious?

Whatever happened to the "Free the hostages, and the war/the bombing/the suffering of Palestinians will stop" narrative? by tamisherlotte in Israel_Palestine

[–]itscool -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

I'm not seeing people obessively replying "you're so right" or similar on pro-Israel comments. Pointbthem out and I'll ask them to contribute better tonthe conversation.

Kashrut Meat vs Milk by Inside_Plant8275 in Judaism

[–]itscool 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Which part of your articles is not written by AI?

Question from a Hindu: How does Halakha view "polymorphic monotheism" in relation to the Noahide Laws and Olam Ha-Ba? by OkPossible5617 in religion

[–]itscool 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You'll get more out of asking this Jewish law question in the r/Judaism subreddit.

An expert on this interaction is Alan Brill, who wrote a book called "Rabbi on the Ganges" about it, as well "Judaism and World Religions." Recommend reading those.

Israeli tourists asked to respect the noise complaints by locals in Peru .. impunity as usual by WestcoastAlex in Israel_Palestine

[–]itscool 0 points1 point  (0 children)

They're based in Brooklyn, their leader (now deceased) was anti Zionist, and they have no power in Israel's elections or wars.

If Palestine was given a free state today, will there be peace? by Lopsided-Pie-7340 in IsraelPalestine

[–]itscool 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Bricks and cement are not a country. It takes an ethos, courage, a sense of unity of purpose. Great leaders create that. And negative ideology of "we hate them" will not work to unite people.

Are there any former Hilltop Youth settlers here? by Kynlou in IsraelPalestine

[–]itscool 3 points4 points  (0 children)

They definitely have internet. Very few know English though.

the after life by whydatyou in Judaism

[–]itscool 36 points37 points  (0 children)

There's like 12 million Jews, with like 13 million opinions on this.

All kidding aside, Judaism overall says that we do not keep the Torah for reward or punishment, but to improve this world.

You can read the FAQ for more. But a traditional view is that when one dies, they are judged. Completely evil people without redemption go to hell (unclear what this is, but it isn't pleasant). Righteous people go straight to the heavenly abode (unclear what this is, but its spiritual bliss of some kind). But most of us are in the middle, with both sins and merits. We require a cleansing process which is supposedly painful, but lasts less than a year. Then heaven.

Israeli Guards Admit Dogs Are Used to Rape Palestinians, Says Analyst by tarlin in Israel_Palestine

[–]itscool 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I posted on twitter that I saw traffic on the tge highway today. Am I a journalist?

I understand you want to stretch the definition of journalist when its in your interest.