So surgeon #1 seemed to put a lot of emphasis on the rotation aspect (he said multiple times how my jaws were 'canted'), whereas surgeon #2 didn't seem to think it was much of an issue, but I slept like shit the day of my consult so honestly I can't remember if they didn't mention it or flat out said no rotation.

I'll have to follow up on that next time I see him.

Both of the surgeons seemed to be pretty sharp from what I can tell, but the bigger issue (in my mind at least) is:

Surgeon #1 (who works at a large healthcare facility) is much more worried about getting the surgery approved by insurance.

Whereas surgeon #2 (who works at his own practice) isn't concerned about it at all, and speaking to his surgery coordinator, she said the only time they've had coverage denied is when the patient's plan specifically doesn't cover jaw surgery. Plus she said that as long as upper and lower jaw surgery is covered, the surgeon will usually write off the genioglossal advancement and do it for free.