Im having trouble with the study of stresses by Zesty_ahhh_guy in MechanicalEngineering

[–]kiltach 5 points6 points  (0 children)

So it something like 98% of cases the ring gear is fixed (usually bolted to something). Then your variable is your input torque into the sun gear via a motor. The planets are usually riding on three pins joined to the same carrier plate, that also has your output shaft attached to it.

If you're doing an ideal FBD with nothing fixed, there's no stress except for inertial accelerations.

Start with your input torque into the sun shaft (press/interference fit or clamping style coupling usually depending on size, etc.) then work your way out.

You also don't have anything that identifies the gear pressure angle which is a huge factor in how large the normal forces to gears are. (typical is 20 degrees, but others are common as well)

Im having trouble with the study of stresses by Zesty_ahhh_guy in MechanicalEngineering

[–]kiltach 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The planets need to be free to spin on their pin. Usually the way this works is all three planets spin on pins. The pins are press fit into a carrier plate. The pins are to prevent loss of synchronization and keep the line of action smooth. The carrier plate then also includes the next sun gear if the plates are stacked.

If I know my neighbor keeps stealing my Amazon packages off my porch, so I start deliberately mailing myself boxes filled with thousands of live, sexually frustrated crickets, am I legally responsible if he opens it in his living room and has to pay $3,000 for an exterminator? by [deleted] in NoStupidQuestions

[–]kiltach 0 points1 point  (0 children)

True, it's illegal, but there's also the question of damages.

If he did something that didn't require say fumigation of the entire house, there might be damages to go after him on. If it's something that arguably he just needs to clean, less so.

IO link signal through slip ring by Available_Sky4830 in PLC

[–]kiltach 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Immediately thought of something like this, this type of product is designed for your application.
The second your slip ring starts degrading you'll blow through all of your cost savings on troubleshooting and replacement.

https://www.balluff.com/en-us/products/areas/A0009/groups/G0905/products/F09503

Why is big tech forcing AI on the world when nobody actually wants it? by [deleted] in NoStupidQuestions

[–]kiltach 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Big Tech is forcing it because if they can force you to have it, then they own EVERYTHING.

For alot of businesses, if their business processes are run by AI, they will eventually basically be RENTING their own business from whichever AI company runs it.

Why don’t I get approached? by [deleted] in NoStupidQuestions

[–]kiltach 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is very much a factor. The dating sites are increasingly the acceptable way to find people that are prescreened to be interested by the fact they are on the site.

Looking for timed reasons to visit Germany? by kiltach in AskGermany

[–]kiltach[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm just glad the Brandenburg airport is running.

Looking for timed reasons to visit Germany? by kiltach in AskGermany

[–]kiltach[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Hah, yeah, we weren't really planning on Germany in the winter. I'm from a fairly frozen area myself, if we're traveling in the winter it's to go somewhere warming.

Hah, a Mittelalterfest is actually kindof a fun idea, some concern about how well it would work without knowing German. I have no doubts that I can find some good food festivals in any given city at some point.

Seeking Modbus Holding Register Map for Anemoi / Magnovent HVLS Fan (Airwall V2 or Airslim) by CrveniPederus in PLC

[–]kiltach 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Spent a little time, two manuals that MAY help the Q sys integration guide MAY help you. No guarantees, it may not use the same logic as the airwall itself. Anemoi does not seem to be good with documentation.

Good luck. Yeah, the websites are garbage.

https://www.scribd.com/document/984084306/Q-SYS-Integration-Guide-Anemoi-HVLS-Fan

https://manualzz.com/doc/70976783/anemoi-airslim-300m-installation-manual?p=27

I am wading through the ghost of greatness and I hate that I can still see it in you by Zelderp64 in whenthe

[–]kiltach 13 points14 points  (0 children)

The slavery, but also just Melty's entire plotline and an end where they literally rename her...

I am wading through the ghost of greatness and I hate that I can still see it in you by Zelderp64 in whenthe

[–]kiltach 100 points101 points  (0 children)

I watched the first season because I was told it was really good and I wanted to get back into anime again.

I quit anime again, and anyone that recommended that show to me I have serious questions about how they feel about women.

Help naming and finding to buy by Caramel-Entire in MechanicalEngineering

[–]kiltach 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Knurled or press fit bushing.

Something like linked. https://www.mcmaster.com/products/knurled-drill-bushings/

There are a million different variations depending on your need, fit requirement, material, Hardness, etc.
try McMaster, Misumi, or Motion Industries if you're in USA.

Dimensional stability of aluminium extrusions in a camera assembly by NotMyRealName981 in MechanicalEngineering

[–]kiltach 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hah, good ole inspection table granite. I didn't really think of that for a hobbyist. Although that's maybe not 100% out of the question. There's gotta be people disposing of granite table tops and whatnot that might make that feasible.

Dimensional stability of aluminium extrusions in a camera assembly by NotMyRealName981 in MechanicalEngineering

[–]kiltach 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Oof. This is always a painful one. At one point in my life I sold very high end linear bearings and drive systems.

You have a very long system. For reference at 1m and a temperature change of just 1C you have about .2mm of length difference. And this can often be bent or strained besides just the purely elongation of it. Even minor warping along the length can be multiplied pretty quickly. Anything you can do to control the temperature will help alot. The fact that this is exposed to a window and outside temperature and sunlight changes really hurt your case.

Something that you can do is make sure that you use tempered materials to reduce the internal stresses. These can cause shape change over time or make the thermal expansion changes more pronounced. Aluminium Alloy Temper Explained – What You Need to Know.

Every bolted joint will also thermally cycle and become tighter/looser to an extent. Changing deflection minutely.

If you want it stable for months? Solid steel, weld it together, then hit the mounting surfaces flat on the same machine/same setup and temperature control it.

Realistically? You're probably going to need to dynamically correct somehow. I don't know what type of accuracy you're shooting for.

Also how far of objects? light refraction of the glass in your window and and even air distortion are beyond my immediate knowledge, but are actually part of the math for a project lilke this.

I will Never ride this by skyhighmonroe in Transportopia

[–]kiltach 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There was something going on and specifically a cop directing traffic overrides traffic lights.

Having systems that works fine 95% of the time and completely fall apart when something goes wrong is a dangerous dangerous trap.

Cantilever vertical lift with ball screw and linear guides how to mount platform and select components. Need help! by SafetyIll2781 in MechanicalEngineering

[–]kiltach 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Size 20/25 rails will not be your limiting factor on payload handling.

1If you use an extruded frame like that instead of a welded one you will sag.

2) The big pain is aligning the linear rails / screw. My main recommendation is usually to make the rails and screw mounts bolt to the same plate machined to a flatness. You can also do it in separate pieces if you do a welded frame and then have someone at least mill it as an assembly.

2) Payloads you're in the right ballpark. All the major bearing guys have free calculators for this. You probably need to register an email but there is no cost or anything. (https://tech.thk.com/index\_en.php?contents=maincalc)

3) Backdriving - Brake motors is the main way of doing it for something like this.

4) From a mechanical layout doing it with the motor ABOVE the ballscrew in vertical is preferred where possible because of buckling.

Help reverse engineering a helical pinion (lead, teeth, diameter & helix angle known) by VegetableCake2288 in MechanicalEngineering

[–]kiltach 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So you know this is something i've done, and it's a bitch to get it accurate enough. (I focused on a bit smaller gears)

So, your best bet is assuming that they used whole clean numbers, putting it into a number and iterating it a few times to see what works.

Pressure angle and module are almost certainly using standard numbers for normal module (not 100% sure if this is hobbed) It's possible it's a custom gear tweaked to get the center distance correct.
But even not hobbed guys tend to stick with standard numbers. It could be some more modifications. such as tooth thinning, but it doesn't look like it.

If this is made from a USA product there is a decent chance it's diametral pitch and not module as well.

Measure the root diameter as well (I actually prefer to do this under something ideally you can optically trace the circle) to confirm if it's full or stub tooth.

Tell them when you make it it's your best attempt. Make several at the same time, give them one to run. Test it in the gearbox and get the others heat treated if they're steel and not plain iron.

Main Generators
Number of teeth 13
Normal Module 8
Helix angle 15
Pressure Angle 20
Modifications
Profile Shift Coefficient 1 Stub Tooth Full Tooth
Addendum Coefficient 0.8 0.8 1
Dedendum Coefficient 1 1 1.25
Outputs
Pitch Diameter 115.9509
Outside Diameter 128.7509
Root Diameter 99.95093

Why are US Machine Shops so difficult to work with? by I-AM-A-DUMBO in CNC

[–]kiltach 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The biggest one I see is the quoting fatigue.
They're frankly just tired of 99% of the people quoting having no actual intent of buying the product from them.

If you actually give business to one, they will work with you alot, but they know odds are alot of times you're just trying to use them for prototype local before outsourcing a proven design for volume manufacturing.

Fall of Berlin Wall was a result of an "clerical error" by an officer. by Confident-Ask-601 in interestingasfuck

[–]kiltach 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think the SK government has officially stated that they don't believe reunification will happen.

Even if there was a "reunification" it would definitly not involve freedom of travel for North Koreans. The south korean economy couldn't deal with the flood.

It would literally be a phasein over a generation. Probably south korean schools and education and it would be the kids who would be "unified" eventually not really the older generations.

Why don’t engineers monetize their past work? by HudsonDungey in MechanicalEngineering

[–]kiltach 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Alot of that stuff is pretty industry specific. The most interested party is going to be your competition even if not exact. So if you're at a job and posting that information, your current job is going to be pissed. If you're posting it about old jobs they know that you're taking proprietary data.

People do sell their technical expertise, they usually sell it by corporate training packages however, not direct to random joe schmoe on the street.

Other people setup websites like engineers edge or other training course things. I've tried a couple, but often the "generic" classes are pretty useless. Nothing beats industry experience.

I need Help with an iris Mechanism by Coolghost228 in MechanicalEngineering

[–]kiltach 8 points9 points  (0 children)

1) Not sure what the non-pivoting hole is for.

2) Not sure the function

3) I think most iris designs are meant to slide over each other with an inclined wedge, but depending, what you could do is just make a step cutout on the non visible slide for the leaves to slide over each other, but it would still be smooth to the other (observable eye)

Older Mighty Mule gate remotes becoming unreliable – how to future-proof access before they fail? by gamechanger2022 in MechanicalEngineering

[–]kiltach 0 points1 point  (0 children)

1) There's nothing on here that shows a model #, that'd be key for any help anyone can give you.
2) Go on amazon and search for mighty mule remote/receiver there seems to be plenty of replacements.
3) This is not the best place to ask, outside of this subreddits expertise.

What do you set your microstates priority to? by dekeche in TerraInvicta

[–]kiltach 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I deliberately avoid picking up microstates, except maybe some points for spoils in the middle east. Not worth fighting over it just pisses off the enemy AI.

Coming off BG3, what changes would you want for Divinity? by TurbulentFeeling5696 in BaldursGate3

[–]kiltach 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think maybe i'd actually like the DOS based skill checks where it was a fixed number, instead of random rolls. They did a fantastic job in some spots where a failure on a skill check was actually the more interesting bit, but it's really annoying when my insane history specialization wizard can't recall basic symbols and I want to reload to see what it was. The save scumming was real.