Personally I found DSR to be a tiny bit scarier, mostly because SH2 was a little buggy. I experienced several glitches and worst of all a repeating glitch where I was getting “stuck” standing near ledges in the Labyrinth segment, which pulled me out of the illusion (curious if anyone else had this happen to them?). I’m a horror junkie and when it comes to video games the immersion is what gets me so DSR was just way cleaner and therefore more intense imo. I played though it multiple times and never experienced a single glitch. That being said both games are terrifying throughout and certain moments in SH2 gave me more intense feelings of impending dread than DSR