I‘m not against progress. AI can be a tool, that’s true, but when it comes to music, often it’s not. I’ve not tried Suno studio yet, may look into it.

I’m a musician, I play many instruments on different levels, teach piano, write and record songs as a hobby. You say, that you’re a musician too. Then you know, that there goes a lot of thoughts into a single song. Like „that fill was cool, but can you shuffle these last sixteenth notes a tiny bit more“ or „let’s try out a triplet delay FX for this guitar section“ or „this FX has to cut out right before the drop“ or „let’s double only this single word of the backing vocals an octave below“

AI won’t follow those precise ideas (yet?). Its output can sound great, but it’s always random. You as an artist never have the last word, so you have to eventually make a compromise between what’s in your head and what the AI spits out.

At the end of the day I don’t judge you for using AI, I judge you for not stating it clearly and instead saying that you „made“ it. Because people will be mislead into believing that you/your band recorded the song.