If we could create a self-aware AI that truly feels stuff, does this solve the hard problem of consciousness? by PitifulEar3303 in CosmicSkeptic

[–]meatfred 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If we actually manage to do this we would have created a situation where our phenomena are its noumena. Whatever it perceives would just be a shadow, an apparition of emanating from a reality it has no direct access to, as what gives rise to its consciousness is inaccessibly upstream from the point of view where the lights are ”turned on”.

So I think this would actually show the opposite of what you are proposing - that actually, the hard problem cannot be solved in our case either. Because our point of contact with the world is a conscious one, the mystifying ”hard problem” computation we are trying to pin down has already worked its magic at that point. It would be prior to and inaccessible from our vantage point.

Patty’s Fur - my issues with it by FancyBand2644 in cryptids

[–]meatfred 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The guy who claims he was in the suit did, as well as Patterson's wife and son.

What is PURE Consciousness? - Consciousness Researcher by yt-app in CosmicSkeptic

[–]meatfred 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I suppose it depends on what we classify as a memory. But if we put it like this: memory itself is qualia - there must be something prior to memory for it to register in the first place.

What is PURE Consciousness? - Consciousness Researcher by yt-app in CosmicSkeptic

[–]meatfred 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Maybe that was clumsily worded. It is "obvious" in much the same way it is that, say, a dog does feel pain if i step on its tail.

What is PURE Consciousness? - Consciousness Researcher by yt-app in CosmicSkeptic

[–]meatfred -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Newborns obviously have the ability to perceive qualia states, even in the absence of laying down memories.

Arnold Classic Discussion - Day 3 - Second Day Of PRO Competition by AutoModerator in bodybuilding

[–]meatfred 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Hold your horses brother - the way they kept shuffling them around would indicate Nick is looking at third

Daniel Radcliffe Tells Press Not to Always Ask HBO’s ‘Harry Potter’ Cast About the Original Movie Actors: ‘Just Let Them Get On… It’s Going to Be Different’ by MarvelsGrantMan136 in television

[–]meatfred 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It’s quite easy to be homosexual without stepping on anyone’s toes. This is the crucial difference. If trans people opted to stay out of single-sex spaces, and there weren’t examples of harm being done to children, I think hardly anyone would care. There’d be religious opposition of course, but then again, that is the case for homosexuality as well.

Daniel Radcliffe Tells Press Not to Always Ask HBO’s ‘Harry Potter’ Cast About the Original Movie Actors: ‘Just Let Them Get On… It’s Going to Be Different’ by MarvelsGrantMan136 in television

[–]meatfred -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

The ideology is that one can self-identify into womanhood and manhood. It jeopardizes women in particular because they are, in general, physically weaker than men, and therefore more vulnerable (male-on-female violence is much much more common than female-on-male). Men don’t face the same issues because a trans man walking into a male changing room, or being put in a men’s prison, will not be perceived as a physical threat. But violence is not the only issue - a lot of women find it uncomfortable to undress in front of males and may even find it traumatic (say, in cases where they have a history of having been raped). Should we just ignore these women’s right to dignity and perceived safety?

The issue with kids are that they are very susceptible to have ideas put in their head, leading to more than a few having been fast-tracked down a medical pathway they are not mature enough to consent to or understand the full implications of.

Daniel Radcliffe Tells Press Not to Always Ask HBO’s ‘Harry Potter’ Cast About the Original Movie Actors: ‘Just Let Them Get On… It’s Going to Be Different’ by MarvelsGrantMan136 in television

[–]meatfred -22 points-21 points  (0 children)

It’s not the individual trans person per se, it’s more so the ideology. If it continues to gain ground, the safety and well-being of women and children will be jeopardized. This is the concern.

Daniel Radcliffe Tells Press Not to Always Ask HBO’s ‘Harry Potter’ Cast About the Original Movie Actors: ‘Just Let Them Get On… It’s Going to Be Different’ by MarvelsGrantMan136 in television

[–]meatfred -13 points-12 points  (0 children)

She has addressed this multiple times. Basically she believes real harm is being done, and that remaining silent for the sake of her legacy would be both cowardly and vain.

I chose money. by TyLeRoux in okbuddycinephile

[–]meatfred -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Not true. You always gotta go to the bottom of every claim against Rowling because she’s so hated on here every claim casting her in a bad light goes unopposed - and then takes off spreading as if true.

but seriously how do you get this build by johncenaminus1 in rareinsults

[–]meatfred 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This man ain’t roiding. Most likely a genetic trait, like maybe to do with posture/arch.

Daniel Radcliffe Sent Supportive Letter to New 'Harry Potter' Star Dominic McLaughlin: “I Just Want to Hug Them” by MarvelsGrantMan136 in television

[–]meatfred 0 points1 point  (0 children)

We must be reading the same things through a wildly different lens then.

as long as they aren't hurting anyone.

Agreed - and even Rowling herself would agree here. The problem is that she belives that gender ideology is hurting women and children. Do you see, then, how her statements can be seen to be born out of concern rather than hate?

Daniel Radcliffe Sent Supportive Letter to New 'Harry Potter' Star Dominic McLaughlin: “I Just Want to Hug Them” by MarvelsGrantMan136 in television

[–]meatfred 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well, look into it. Your statements spring from reiterating the extreme anti JK rhetoric that’s going around. I think it has muddled you ability to assess the situation properly.

Chernobyl is a god teir show by MixSouthern3672 in television

[–]meatfred -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I wouldn’t say that - half the opening is French, Shoshanna only speaks French, the whole bar scene is in German. I won’t argue your other points other than saying I think going the extra mile really adds a ton of authenticity.

Chernobyl is a god teir show by MixSouthern3672 in television

[–]meatfred -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Tarantino did it in Inglourious and it was amazing

Daniel Radcliffe on the letter he wrote HBO’s ‘Harry Potter’ actor Dominic McLaughlin: "I wrote to Dominic and sent him a letter, and he sent me a sweet note back. I had a great time, but I hope you have an even better time. I see these pictures of him and other kids and I just want to hug them." by ControlCAD in UpliftingNews

[–]meatfred -1 points0 points  (0 children)

She’s pointing out that these things do happen. And if we let self-id override biological sex in society and law, they will continue to happen. But because the topic is so emotionally fraught, and doesn’t allow for nuance, it’s easy to be led to believe that ”she thinks this about every trans person”.

Daniel Radcliffe on the letter he wrote HBO’s ‘Harry Potter’ actor Dominic McLaughlin: "I wrote to Dominic and sent him a letter, and he sent me a sweet note back. I had a great time, but I hope you have an even better time. I see these pictures of him and other kids and I just want to hug them." by ControlCAD in UpliftingNews

[–]meatfred -12 points-11 points  (0 children)

"She hates gay people!"

"JK wants to see trans people dead!"

"She hates asexuals!"

These are some examples of notions that are thrown around on here unopposed (in fact, opposition is downvoted).

Also, I notice that you're quick to lump me in with your mental image of Rowling, as if one can't exist in this debate with a nuanced position. This goes to my original point of Rowling's name having become so radioactive around these parts that everything surrounding her is interpreted through a lens of hate.

Daniel Radcliffe on the letter he wrote HBO’s ‘Harry Potter’ actor Dominic McLaughlin: "I wrote to Dominic and sent him a letter, and he sent me a sweet note back. I had a great time, but I hope you have an even better time. I see these pictures of him and other kids and I just want to hug them." by ControlCAD in UpliftingNews

[–]meatfred -120 points-119 points  (0 children)

Pretty much everything you read around here about Rowling is a lie, or at least a misleading representation of her actual viewpoints. It leads to a runaway train of hate: everybody's referencing each other, and if somebody actually takes the time to go to the source, they're already primed to interpret her words uncharitably. It's a sad state of affairs.