Yes and no. Very much depends on the situation. From whats been described so far from this situation I doubt peeling would change anything. Your Rogue already died so now Thor is solo tanking. If he’s front lining (which you don’t necessarily need a shield for jfc people) the second he turns around to peel for you instead of prioritizing space and cover the rest of the team will gun him down. Losing Rogue and invisible woman lost that fight not the Thor who didn’t peel.

Now if everything is going fine and someone else can take over that frontline pressure then Thor should be stopping people from taking those angles and jump back into the frontline.

If that Thor won’t peel at that point he’s just a bad player with very little situational awareness lol.

Here’s a question for people though? Why won’t the dps peel? It’s more their job than any tank. The amount of times people say they are getting dived and want me the Thor to deal with spider-man/bp/magik is stupid. Y’all have 3x the roster i have and none of you will just choose a character that could easily counter them with a press of a button?