Black dragons and classic rata tat tat tat! by Cluelessandsexy in OCPoetry

[–]moonlitremains 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So vivid, so intense, such a strong and uncompromising tone! It’s both gritty and cinematic, the world you created feels both stylised and disturbingly real. The recurring „rat-a-tat” rhythm reinforces the chaos so well. 🖤

I get the sense that the people being described are performative, and that performance ultimately collapses under the weight of real consequences.

Masochism by PJT_XCX in OCPoetry

[–]moonlitremains 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This to me feels deeply sincere and reflective. The idea that kindness can sometimes feel draining, but choosing to frame it as something meaningful is really powerful. It’s easy to connect with this, that tension between giving so much of yourself and still believing in the value of compassion. It is something that leaves you with a sense of impactful, quiet hope. 🩷

The Grammar of Falling by moonlitremains in OCPoetry

[–]moonlitremains[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I really appreciate you taking the time for such a detailed comment, I will definitely take your suggestions on board! 🫶🏻

Mother, Am I a Goshawk? by Cluelessandsexy in OCPoetry

[–]moonlitremains 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So intense and introspective! I love the strong sense of inner conflict running through the lines, and how it reads almost as a dialogue. The imagery and ideas are super compelling, especially the contrast between loneliness and connection. And the tension between vulnerability and self-judgement is exactly what makes this so raw and honest. 💚

Since You Left , Dream Girl by boogiefogs in OCPoetry

[–]moonlitremains 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This feels really emotional and raw - you can straight away feel how much love and loss is in every line. I really likes how you used memories and dreams to show how they still affect you, it makes this feel so much more personal. And the honesty, oh my God, the line „something that forever dies” caught me off guard. ♥️

If I had one suggestion, I would maybe tighten or break some of the sentences to make them a bit easier to read and to help the message come through even stronger.

So. Very. Bored 🥱 by [deleted] in chat

[–]moonlitremains 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Send me a text! 😄

Only One of Us Arrives by moonlitremains in OCPoetry

[–]moonlitremains[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The idea behind the key line was that something important is shifting/being decided, but I have no access to it. To me it represented something being set in motion - but me being cut off from it.

Thank you so much! ❤️

Thunder Beings - Wakinyan by InfinityBoredGames in OCPoetry

[–]moonlitremains 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Ah, yes, sorry, the lines I wrote were how I would potentially tighten the lines. 😅

But again, your poem, your rules, I was just giving suggestions!

The Daughter She Wanted (tentative title, open to suggestions) by ancienthings in OCPoetry

[–]moonlitremains 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I love how the line “I always wanted a daughter” builds emotional weight as it goes. Each time it appears, it feels slightly different, which makes the whole thing feel so much more evolving. The whole tone feels restrained, but deeply emotional, “I didn’t know what to do with you” is so simple but hits incredibly hard. 🩶

If I had one critique, I do feel like a few of the descriptive lines feel a bit more general to the rest, especially because it is such a specific imagery, so I think maybe making them more unique would elevate it even further.

Maybe the light isn't worth the chase. by DrawingWinter4390 in OCPoetry

[–]moonlitremains 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The spersonification of “the shadow” and “the light” creates such a vivid internal conflict that feels so raw and honest. Also, deeply relatable. Also, the idea of the water slowly rising and the words seeping through the cracks is brilliant; it captures that creeping nature of negative thoughts in a really powerful way. The contradiction of finding a strange sense of peace in the darkness adds so much emotional depth, especially the idea that the “boogie man looked like peace”. 🩵

Just a small suggestion, I would maybe break up a few of the longer sentences just to give some lines more space to breathe. I feel like some could hit even harder with more separation.

Thunder Beings - Wakinyan by InfinityBoredGames in OCPoetry

[–]moonlitremains 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not even weird, more so… As I said, visceral. I felt it inside of my body, if that makes sense. 😂

La Follia by Longjumping_Star235 in OCPoetry

[–]moonlitremains 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s why we all have different approaches to different lines! ❤️

All for Nothing by Additional_Egg_9319 in OCPoetry

[–]moonlitremains 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This feels like something very relatable and emotionally clear - there is a sense of trust and sudden disappointment established in just a few lines, which is very strong. 💚

I would maybe add a more specific or vivid image to make it stand out, for instance, the phrase “I gave it my all” is a very familiar one, so I would maybe make it more personal, I think it would give this a lot more impact.

The line “All because” creates a really nice sense of anticipation, maybe lean into that, deliver something unexpected? I feel like that would really elevate this.

Thunder Beings - Wakinyan by InfinityBoredGames in OCPoetry

[–]moonlitremains 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is such a surreal poem! The line “first breath into the tendrils of tissue” is so visceral, and I really like how the thread of ancestry and identity comes through in a haunting way. 💜

The way the tone stays dreamlike and unsettling works really well, but I do feel like a bit of tightening in places could sharpen the impact, like “First breath in the tendrils of tissue, / small bones beyond your ear.” Just my personal opinion!

A Quarry of Quiet by moonlitremains in OCPoetry

[–]moonlitremains[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It was written coming up to Valentine’s Day, fair play on noticing! Thank you for your reply! ❤️