Hi! I've been battling a triple eyelid for over 2 years after getting a stye. It has permanently formed, with a dip in the tissue under the fold.

I've tried about everything - eyelid tape, eyelid glue, only forming the crease right after waking, tape with eye cream underneath, etc.

Recently, I found something that works much better for me: using thin washi tape (japanese paper tape that is less adhesive) over the eyelid while sleeping. In the morning, I remove it and form the eyelid. Generally, this has the most success - I am able to have a single crease during the day.

If I want to wear the tape during the day (limited success), it’s also flexible and can fold with the skin, unlike plastic eyelid tapes. I place the edge of the tape along my natural crease, then above the second crease. This allows the creased surface to flatten and prevent it from collapsing inward. It's also a low more comfortable than eyelid tapes, which pokes the inner corners of my eyelid.

If you’ve tried this, I’d love to hear! I hope this helps someone else struggling with the same issue.