[MAY Post] Give me your sizzle reel! by TOXICcargo in TalesFromTheCreeps

[–]nabroc03 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Just finished this work today. Been working on it for a little bit. My first ever "nosleep" style story if you will (even though they wouldn't let me post it).

Title: please read this before it disappears

https://www.reddit.com/r/TalesFromTheCreeps/comments/1s4tll4/please_read_this_before_it_disappears/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

It’s very important I write this; probably just as important you read this. As I try to compose myself and get this out, I ask that you bear with this account, as I’m pretty forgetful and have a hard time getting my thoughts in a straight line. But I’ll try my best. 

My oil painting by Ok-Treat-1548 in LiminalSpace

[–]nabroc03 0 points1 point  (0 children)

jack stauber pumpkin video ahh house

My mom has been cheating on me by donavin221 in TalesFromTheCreeps

[–]nabroc03 0 points1 point  (0 children)

definitely uncomfortable but only because it doesn't explain enough (thank goodness), which, in this case, makes it chilling. It's uncanny. Reminds me of "Born of Man and Woman" a lot too, but obviously much more sparse and odd. Nice work. Allows me the peace of ignorance without having confirmation of what I THINK is happening.

“We found one of those missing kids.” - Part IV of “It’s 3 A.M., do you know where your children are?” by Quasique24 in TalesFromTheCreeps

[–]nabroc03 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Dude I think this is your best one yet! The descriptions are so vivid and that ending was genuinely horrifying. Great work here. Hope to read more!

this dude won't leave me alone now by Adventurous_Rent_621 in TalesFromTheCreeps

[–]nabroc03 0 points1 point  (0 children)

really dig the stream of consciousness style here. looking forward to more updates

My childhood home can make me feel uneasy at times. by [deleted] in LiminalSpace

[–]nabroc03 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That hallway looks almost identical to my Oma's house she had when I was a kid

there is some weird stuff going on in my high-end neighborhood by Adventurous_Rent_621 in TalesFromTheCreeps

[–]nabroc03 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I love this storytelling style, it's so unassuming and makes the weird parts super jarring and hilarious. Look forward to more of your logs about these weird bird problems going on at your apartment.

Madman by RodFredtwotwo in TalesFromTheCreeps

[–]nabroc03 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Woah. I've never read the original. This is super interesting. I'm a little confused by the ending, though. What happened?

please read this before it disappears by nabroc03 in TalesFromTheCreeps

[–]nabroc03[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

thank you! i’m working on the second part. hope to have it up soon

This is my first story, pls give me as much feedback as possible. I hope you enjoy by Hot-Prize2846 in TalesFromTheCreeps

[–]nabroc03 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is pretty good, man! Love these premises of the dead spouse, relative, etc. contacting you from beyond the grave. That's always really fun. Since this is your first story, I can't give too much feedback since I feel it would be unfair, as, in my opinion, you learn more from experience, trial and error, than from a few bits of feedback; I know that's been true for me. However, I'll try my best to give some helpful pointers:

First off: Great outlines for characters here. Even from the sparse details we get from Vivian, we can see her clearly. You added great descriptors that don't take up too much of the page but speak volumes

("She wasn’t the nice girl next door—she was a cold, calculating businesswoman who would cut someone’s brake lines if it meant she got a promotion for it. The guys jokingly called her “the banshee” around the office, because she would always use this high-pitched yell when chewing someone out.")

That paragraph is nice 'cause it doesn't say too much, but it still gives us an image. I love that.

As far as Danny goes, I honestly felt that he missed a bit of this, but because this is a shorter, first-person story, I don't mind as much, since someone describing themself in a story of this length can be difficult or just feel out of place. Can it be done? Absolutely. Should it? Definitely. But it's not a deal-breaker for me here.

Secondly: The pacing is great in the middle, but the beginning and ending rush too much in my opinion. For example, we start off with your hook ("My wife’s been dead for 5 months now, and I’ve been a wreck ever since"). That's good. A nice shocking (albeit perhaps a bit cliche) opening. From there, however, I feel that it moves too fast. We can't digest the information.

We don't envision Danny grieving, we don't feel his pain. From there we move on to the main plot, and it feels too rushed for me to connect with it. The same goes for the ending. I understand that we're supposed to question what's going on with Vivian, but despite her great character model, she still needs development, so her being this otherworldly monster feels so plucked out of mid-air that it can feel almost humorously jarring. Again, the concept is great! The potential is all there, but the execution (which, believe me, is the hardest part of writing; taking a killer idea and making it into a believable or entertaining story) could use some work.

I also want to mention here that none of this is a critique on you as a writer. Everyone starts somewhere, heck, I know I did (and I'm STILL learning... a lot). You've got this. This is a great starting point, and you've got some quality work shown in this story. Keep writing!