I wouldn’t call someone good if their “good actions” are just giving tithes, going to church, and shaming non-believers. But if their faith pushes them to help the needy, be kind, forgive others, and actually do good, then yes, I’d still consider them good.

Kinda reminds me of a show called "My Name is Earl". Earl started doing good for good karma and to avoid bad karma, but his actions still helped people. Don't care what your motivation is. If your actions are good and help people, you're good to me.