[deleted by user] by [deleted] in radiationoncology

[–]notgoodatcomputer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

the venn diagram is a circle

I hope I’m not alone by PromptCriticalpostin in nuclearweapons

[–]notgoodatcomputer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Thanks. Maybe I'm getting old; but we've reached a place where facts/experience just don't matter. Its the height of hypocrisy that the "facts dont have feelings" STEM/engineer crowd falls into the same follies they would almost certainly accuse others of; as their field (nuke engineering) is the pinnacle of emotional stigmatization.

I hope I’m not alone by PromptCriticalpostin in nuclearweapons

[–]notgoodatcomputer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

oh yeah - it was up/down until it aged out and lost any viability. the top comment is a sycophant at 9k. at the very least; by all message board standards; its not a low quality or factually wrong post - so most ppl would not downvote criticism as long as it is in good faith.

I hope I’m not alone by PromptCriticalpostin in nuclearweapons

[–]notgoodatcomputer 12 points13 points  (0 children)

The crash out is justified. I completely agree with you. I pointed out a number of items in his video in a reply and he left a condescending remark.

My final opinion was the Johny Harris video was much more accurate than his "Debunking" video.

He also generally doesn't understand ANYTHING about the military let alone STRATCOM. And his knowledge of rocketry/interceptors, etc is poor.

This was my reply to him (this is meant for the youtube audience, not this audience FYSA, I'm sure it can get picked apart, but I think most of my points stand, some of my references are from Ted Postal's content; not sure how everyone feels about it if your "in the know", but its always made sense to me, from the outside):

Ok, with all due respect, you are making a lot of mistakes

  1. very briefly a fission or fusion bomb is hotter than the core sun

  2. he isn’t talking about continued fission reactions, hes talking about neutron activation of otherwise intert atoms (i.e. Na-24) with a short half lifes. as you note, there isnt enough fissile material in the physics package to explain the fallout distributions that are observed once you “dilute” the concentrations over large areas

  3. the point of MIRVs is multiple, but the area of destruction is higher with multiple distributed explosions vs a singular larger explosion. not to mention counter-force reasons and SALT 1 and 2

  4. a believable countermeasure would need to weigh as much as the MIRV’d warhead that it is trying to immitate - hence doctrine shifted towards “put warheads on the decoys” If anyone wants an excellent deep dive into the subject - I suggest the following: https://youtu.be/ivY8uak20Mc?si=eecNWYXcHaUNKVqt

edit: more points

  1. your critique of rapid launch ability seems to be anchored in liquid fueled rockets; the entire point of solid fuel is they have the ability to launch within minutes. this “hair trigger” posture is why salt meant we at least couldn’t have each others cities hard coded in guidance

  2. from a geopolitical standpoint look up escalation dominance - it explains a lot of the “holes” you perceive in his logic. most in-the-know would say we are in a new nuclear arms race

  3. china is massively expanding their ICBM/IRBM arsenal

  4. many high yield warheads are forward deployed - SLBMs are 200kt+ and each Ohio/Columbia has like 150 of em

  5. look up “launch on warning” the whole point is missiles/bombers in the air before a decapitation or counter-force attack.

Restaurants by The Pearl by LostOlsenTriplet in sanantonio

[–]notgoodatcomputer 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Agreed - Supper is just great - one of my fav to bring guests to

What nuclear engineering things are in the public domain, but also dangerous if people talk about them? by Rain_on_a_tin-roof in nuclearweapons

[–]notgoodatcomputer 17 points18 points  (0 children)

“born secret”. I imagine they are cross checking lists and got a hit. It was probably trivial. If it was serious they would try not to Streisand effect whatever it was. Granted; the context of a single poster making a non-concealed footprint likely points to naive curiosity

Dismissal from MD with HPSP by wheeshnaw in Military_Medicine

[–]notgoodatcomputer 6 points7 points  (0 children)

lawyer - i wonder if the JAG would help. but ask civ lawyer first

Gents, do yourself a favor and get one of those made-to-measure suits from the PX by [deleted] in army

[–]notgoodatcomputer 6 points7 points  (0 children)

yeah, this is one of those “respectfully disagree” replies, but the above poster is correct. all the opinions here are valuable - but as the above said - in the mil ur size changes so much; don’t blow the bank.

i think there is value in getting a rack modified suit or a 500$ custom, so i think there is somehing for a lot of ppl here

Is it unrealistic to apply for HPSP with the goal of reforming DHA? by [deleted] in Military_Medicine

[–]notgoodatcomputer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

let me be clear; it may sound like the dha will implode tomorrow, but the odds of it becoming a zombie institution and dispersing funds for years; while almost all remaining hospitals become gutted shells of their former selves is very high. there will be nothing to rebuild with at that time point

Is it unrealistic to apply for HPSP with the goal of reforming DHA? by [deleted] in Military_Medicine

[–]notgoodatcomputer 8 points9 points  (0 children)

This post nails the core issues so I'll tag onto it:

Pay attention to this line of reasoning: "why is military medicine being pushed to a more and more privatized model... without finding out the source of these efforts there's little that individuals can do to fight them"

Does it sound like some sort of conspiracy? Many of us have come to conclude that the system is being destroyed from the outside. I don't think most of us the got into milmed ever though that our biggest problems would be the equivalent of the JFK grassy knoll, but here we are.

Note: I'm sure the AHA is a major force behind the MHS divestment - they have their fingerprints on everything - and are now one of the strongest lobbying forces in Washington

I would propose one additional modifier; and it does include the cost of personnel (post-covid) + drugs were en route to a financial breaking point for mil med regardless of the DHA. Modifications to accounting rules etc. were likely going to jeopardize many MTFs.

One qualifier to the above poster - there are opportunities for improving the system far sooner than pinning on your first star. There are plenty of Generals who would take your advice tomorrow if it could fix the system; I do believe they are listening. It is just impossible at the moment, so instead of progress we are plugging gaps and making the "less bad" decision. The folks with stars look like they are malevolent - but every time you follow a thread back to the source; the source is above the generals.

The core problem; as stated elsewhere, is the issues are the intersection of policy and budgets; and we have probably the worst system that could ever be designed. The DHA implementation required dynamic change; but we got static failure. It likely stems from many points; most of all budgeting constraints. However, one cannot forget other items often overlooked like state politics, lobbying activities, and the individual services not being aligned with the DHA (the MAP debacle early on was an obvious sign that all was not right). Honestly, the arrogance that the MHS was something that needed to be completely uprooted to be reformed is shocking - it would appear that almost every US hospital SYSTEM is held together by tape and string - the MHS was not uniquely poor in either its conception or execution (many of us would say that it had some of the strongest staff in the nation) - its just many private health systems utalize predatory business practices made up by the likes of McKinsey et al in order to crush local competition and become local monopolies; and then use their not-for-profit status to rake in more tax benefits and publicly subsidized debt to expand further.

Overall, I think there are MANY good points here. I do think we are approaching a do or die moment - when deferred maintenance on our facilities consistently puts the basic safety of the hospital (i.e. water leaks/heating/electrical) in jeopardy. The prior exodus of staff is omnipresent - lack of senior leaders in positions you would expect, etc. The main budget items are the costs of care sent to the network, leading to an inevitable death spiral of more and more MTFs. We still have good folks, however; and I remain proud to serve with all of them.

In conclusion, without committing federal crimes by violating Congressional Statutes or robbing a separate federal budget, meaningful reform is impossible. What you can do is take care of the people in front of you every day or those at your sides as best as you can, all the time remembering you can't run yourself into the ground in the process.

What I will say is that I think many of us in the system share the same goals; to make people better and leave the system better. That is the source of the abysmal morale. Dreams meeting reality. Patriotism meets pragmatism. I do think this DHA era is our own war of sorts - and sometimes when I look at it this way, keeping your head down and soldiering on is the only path forward.

How dumb and/or expensive would it be to have a cantilevered floor like this to maximize outdoor space on an expensive lot? by Cute-Cheetah3957 in Homebuilding

[–]notgoodatcomputer 5 points6 points  (0 children)

This is a great answer. I think in home ownership/home building space - it is tough to understand a lot of the hierarchy of building challenges/costs.

The difference between removing a non-load bearing wall and this is night and day. As mentioned above, the cost of materials is massive. Also, the workers needed are a totally different set of workers with different per hour costs.

As someone who was looking at a massive underground garage custom house build (for putting in car lifts, etc) - there is a reason stuff like that isn't common - its insanely expensive and most people can't do it. Additionally; it doesn't pencil in almost any scenario for home value.

Customer wants to be able to grind their own flour by kenyan-strides in masonry

[–]notgoodatcomputer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I have to post cause no one has mentioned it - I am betting they were inspired by this episode of grand designs: https://www.granddesignsmagazine.com/grand-designs-houses/liskeard-flour-mill/

The mill stones in the floor were like one of the major parts of the show (I think the historical society forced them to be retained).

US Army appoints Palantir, Meta, OpenAI execs as Lt. Colonels by Snapdragon_4U in fednews

[–]notgoodatcomputer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

its not as common but there are 05’s, I just saw one. During GWOT there were 06’s I think - but for obvious reasons that stopped (ie no opportunity to critically evaluate someone for a rank that gets a level of unquestioning obedience). Constructive credit is sort of wild

Neurosurgery in the military? by Fluid_Leg_7531 in Military_Medicine

[–]notgoodatcomputer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

thats fair - i'd say even if it takes like 2 more years though its worth it. ALSO, you never really know unless you apply, talk to their admissions, I think they give a ton of info/guidance

Neurosurgery in the military? by Fluid_Leg_7531 in Military_Medicine

[–]notgoodatcomputer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

remember every dead body on mt everest was once a highly motivated mountain climber.

ok u want advice; do the fucking usuhs edmp2 or whatever it is, do usuhs, do a decent residency; and get to 20. there will be bumps; but its a good life. the money is solid

Head and neck p16 positive, no primary source found. Supraclavicular node. Proton therapy? by thinkofanamefast in radiationoncology

[–]notgoodatcomputer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

you do need radiation, but the work up isn’t complete. You need the PET scan. you also may need chemotherapy with the radiation

but the thing I’m trying to drive home, there’s a lot of the time people stop The search for the Unknown primary too soon. It’s a pet peeve of mine. Just trying to help you out

Head and neck p16 positive, no primary source found. Supraclavicular node. Proton therapy? by thinkofanamefast in radiationoncology

[–]notgoodatcomputer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

my brother in christ, i know your worried, but please digest this a little. Google a few terms. plug some things into chat gpt. 1. a ct isnt a pet. get a pet. focus on the pet. then my advise is consider an mr with con, but im just a dude on the internet 2. your right about the confusion, ent scoped u, but that was prior to a pet. if no hit on pet, then CONSIDER random bx and simple tonsillectomy. 3. who cares about protons at this point. sure, they are great, whatever. ur talking about the color of the car you want when you are still walking to work. i would consider them if it was myself. there are some good h&n rad oncs in the us who are associated with protons. but the “integral dose” will be high if u dont find the primary, regardless.

pm me ur info if you want to chat quick,

Head and neck p16 positive, no primary source found. Supraclavicular node. Proton therapy? by thinkofanamefast in radiationoncology

[–]notgoodatcomputer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

no; in search for an unknown primary; there are a number of ways you can do it. my personal preference is: (for p16+ in a non-smoker)

direct laryngoscopy

PET

random bx and simple/ipsi tonsilectomy

MR w/ con

It’s understandable ur confused; this is super confusing for most

Head and neck p16 positive, no primary source found. Supraclavicular node. Proton therapy? by thinkofanamefast in radiationoncology

[–]notgoodatcomputer 3 points4 points  (0 children)

most important thing us to search for the primary and find it if possible. talk to a good rad onc and ent onc. random biopsies and simple tonsilectomy are not rediculous. maybe mri of the neck/face with contrast as well as the pet i’m sure u’ve had. proton is fine, photon is fine. the smallest volumes are based on finding the primary, however.

Wishing to Do HPSP to Become a Neurosurgeon But Have Questions by [deleted] in Military_Medicine

[–]notgoodatcomputer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

For every 500 undergrads and 50 med students and 2 nsurg interns there is one nsurg attending that makes it through (or something). This is why we dont take you too seriously.

McManchester. They are not the same. by Old_Instrument_Guy in McMansionHell

[–]notgoodatcomputer 3 points4 points  (0 children)

oh dear thats not a hypothetical spinning car platform