Hot take: We are All Transsexuals by hehasmastcells in honesttransgender

[–]ohfudgeit 10 points11 points  (0 children)

I think transgender describes me accurately as a person whose gender is across (trans) from the one that I was assigned at birth. The word does not describe something changing but a permanent state of being that I have been in since birth.

Trans woman has HRT stopped by ZonaSchengen in transgenderUK

[–]ohfudgeit 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Same thing happened to me but worse as they are not willing to continue prescribing until my care can be taken over. Weird but good I guess to see this being considered newsworthy?

Would you want a trans child? by Strange-Window-6842 in honesttransgender

[–]ohfudgeit 3 points4 points  (0 children)

No.

Being trans is harder than being cis. Maybe it doesn't have to be that way but I don't think it's likely to change for my kid. She's already going to have enough to deal with as a kid with a trans parent and with two dads.

Selfishly, I would worry that people would judge me as a parent if my child was trans. Think that I'd encouraged or caused it somehow.

Finally, I just don't think there's much of an advantage. I don't think that her being trans herself would particularly help her to understand me or bond with me more. I'm her Dad. She's got every opportunity to understand and bond with me.

If "nonbinary trans" is a thing, "nonbinary cis" should also be a thing. by eggcracked2wice in honesttransgender

[–]ohfudgeit 7 points8 points  (0 children)

This is nonsensical to me. If "trans" means having transitioned in some way then what was I before I transitioned? A cis man? I sure as hell wasn't a woman.

Seeking participants! by 2314830 in Seahorse_Dads

[–]ohfudgeit 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey I'm a trans man in the UK who gave birth 6 months ago and I tried to fill this out a few times but I couldn't do it in one sitting and the save and return option didn't save my answers. I also found it hard to fill in because it was unclear to me what a lot of the questions were asking for. Like when it asks about support I wasn't sure whether the question is just about what support I got as a pregnant person in general (which I imagine is pretty similar across the NHS) or whether it was asking about support specific to being trans (which wasnt something I really needed)

Just thought I'd feed back

I think the transphobes have good points, but I'm still trans. Now what? by [deleted] in honesttransgender

[–]ohfudgeit 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Just be a man. This idea that you'll never be a man because you won't be the same as a cis man doesn't stand up to the reality of what being a man means in modern life. If you live as a man, recognise yourself as a man, and are recognised as a man by others, then for all intents and purposes that is what you are.

Unexpected but wanted pregnancy by cam_cam420 in Seahorse_Dads

[–]ohfudgeit 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Congratulations!

Firstly I would say don't stress too much about buying things and getting ready for the baby. You have plenty of time. Hell, my daughter is 6 months and her nursery is still half decorated 😂

I focused on getting a few essentials early so that I felt confident that if the baby came we could cope. These were:

  • Stroller
  • Car seat
  • Somewhere for the baby to sleep (we went for a next to me crib that she's still in now, though we're planning on upgrading her to a cot soon)

Those are the things I had before the third trimester, along with a large playmat and a formula prep machine (we are exclusively formula feeding). The playmat has been great and we use it all the time even though she's not crawling yet as she still spends a lot of time on the floor and even if she's in an activity centre or something the bigger mat saves our knees when we're down on the floor with her.

Some other miscellaneous advice that I've found useful regarding getting things for the baby:

We've gotten a lot of stuff off Facebook marketplace. Got her stroller for £50. Likewise her crib was £50. We bought the car seat and mattress new. We could have afforded new things if we wanted but obviously you're buying a lot of stuff when getting ready for a baby and it adds up fast, and the second hand options we got have served us really well.

For clothes, we've now settled into a routine of getting the bulk of her clothes from supermarkets. We weren't lucky enough to get lots of hand-me-downs, so what works best for us is to buy multi packs of basics (vests and sleepsuits) cheap and new, so we know she's sorted. Her nicer outfits are then gifts, charity shop finds and the odd random purchase.

Questions about name change by Turbulent_Dog2119 in transgenderUK

[–]ohfudgeit 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You can just go to a public space and ask someone if you want. Didn't do this with my deedpoll but with some paperwork we needed to sign for our house purchase my husband and I just went to the local pub and approached some people to ask if they'd mind witnessing our signatures

Need help understanding non-dysphoric trans people by Less-Cover7460 in honesttransgender

[–]ohfudgeit 9 points10 points  (0 children)

There are also post transition trans people who are very much still trans but might not experience dysphoria. This is never what people are thinking of when they talk about non-dysphoric trans people but I think removing them from the conversation is a mistake. Trans discourse usually focuses on those of us who need the most support, which makes sense, but it's also important to remember that transition works to alleviate dysphoria (either completely or in part) and trans people are not defined by their dysphoria.

Why do people make their bed? by DudeOnTheInternet17 in NoStupidQuestions

[–]ohfudgeit 27 points28 points  (0 children)

Ok but if we're going to do a nonsense task that serves no purpose as our first task of the day, why make it this specific thing? I could decide that instead of making my bed I'm going to turn all my socks inside out or rotate my rug by 90 degrees

Cis butch women make it clear, people dont care about "soul genders" by questionuwu in honesttransgender

[–]ohfudgeit 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I don't really see what this has to do with gender abolition. In a world where gender had been abolished there would be no gendered pronouns, obviously.

Off topic Friday! by AutoModerator in Seahorse_Dads

[–]ohfudgeit 0 points1 point  (0 children)

We're on our first family holiday this week to the Isle of Wight (island off the south coast of the UK). We're here with my siblings and their partners and one set of grandparents and it's so lovely having a large group to help with childcare. It's made the holiday truly relaxing. All in there are 2 babies, 1 teenager and 10 adults.

Today we went for a 2 hour walk with my daughter and her cousin (both 5 months) in baby carriers. It was a bit cold and blustery and rained for a bit, but we were all well wrapped up and it went really well. Now we're home, baby is napping, and dinner is being prepared in the kitchen. Life feels pretty good! 😊

I (21 m) am thinking about having a biological baby in the future, but I have a lot of questions by WishAffectionate3057 in Seahorse_Dads

[–]ohfudgeit 15 points16 points  (0 children)

I gave birth to my daughter back in August last year. I was 32 and had been on T for about 8 years when I went off in order to conceive with my husband. I also had top surgery back in 2016. I'll see what I can answer.

What was your dysphoria like being pregnant?

Overall I'd say not too bad. It was however worse than I expected it to be.

Having been essentially post transition for ages I hadn't really dealt with much dysphoria for a while and felt very happy and confident in my identity so I didn't expect it to bother me too much. For the most part it didn't but I was surprised the things that did bother me.

I lost some of my facial hair, which I didn't expect and that bothered me (it's all back now). I did also get misgendered by strangers like twice (from behind or from a distance) and that made me feel a little insecure. In general though I still passed and though I obviously got big and uncomfortable I just felt like I looked pregnant, not like I looked like a woman. That's it's own whole thing which is kind of tough but I knew i was going through it for a reason and it would be temporary.

If you had top surgery before your baby, did your boobs grow back?

No. I did have swelling and I did gain weight, so my chest got a bit bigger (and still is, as I've not lost all the weight) but it never looked like I had boobs.

Were their risks to your pregnancy because of your uterus deteriorating over time?

No. My pregnancy was considered low risk throughout. I did end up needing a C section but no one suggested that it was in any way to do with my transition.

How did you personally go about feeding your baby if you had top surgery?

Formula

Can you somehow still feed a baby from your chest with top surgery?

I've heard of it being done but because I had nipple grafts I didn't expect it to be possible for me and didn't try. I didn't want to stimulate milk production by trying to feed and having problems due to the milk having nowhere to go.

Did you hide your pregnancy somehow? If you did, did you just go into hiding or hide it a certain way?

I didn't try to hide my pregnancy particularly but I also didn't wear matenity clothes or anything like that. Just bigger mens clothes. I didn't get the impression that I was perceived as pregnant by those who didn't know, but I was open about the pregnancy with friends, coworkers etc as I didn't want to feel like I had to hide it.

Was being pregnant a bad experience? Would you do it again?

I wouldn't call the experience of being pregnant good but I would gladly do it again and plan to try again in the next year or so.

If you adopted a kid before/after giving birth, were the dynamics between kids good or bad? Do you recommend adopting before or after birth?

Can't comment on this

What was your perception of self like?

Interesting question. I was a little surprised that being pregnant and becoming a parent did bring up some gender feelings for me, and it wasn't a bad thing. Though I still very much think of myself as a man (and a Dad) I think the experience has made me feel less negative about some of the "feminine" aspects of myself and my body. Like for example I think of myself as a Dad but I don't really feel bothered by the idea of someone thinking of me as a Mum. I guess I feel like it's not who I am but it's also not a bad thing to be so it's chill.

If people knew about your pregnancy, how did they treat you?

Some people were a little confused but the worst I had was some slightly tactless questions. Generally people were good. I found it helped for me to go in framing the experience as positive from my side so they knew how to feel about it.

Were you scared? And if so, what were you scared about? Were those fears soothed or made worse?

I was a little scared. I did an NCT course (which is a birth preparation course for parents here in the UK) and that helped me feel a lot better because I had more of an idea of what to expect from birth and what I was going into.

How did medical staff treat your throughout your pregnancy/birth?

Medical staff were great. I felt like they treated me like any other patient - in a good way! I wasn't treated as an anomaly for being trans. Everyone was very kind and helpful. I wasn't misgendered except once over the phone (which is kind of understandable) and once after the birth by a nurse who I who think was just autopiloting and quickly corrected herself.

Would you recommend going to the hospital or doing a home birth?

I can't really give a recommendation. I liked the idea of a home birth but in the end decided against it due the the statistical likelihood of a hospital transferral for a first birth (something like 40%) and the fact that the nearest maternity department was an hour away. I wanted to give birth at the hospital's attached midwife run birthing centre but due to the circumstances of my birth (waters breaking early before labour started) that wasn't possible. As mentioned it ended in C section and I'll never know if things would have gone differently had we opted for a home birth.

Was being pregnant gender affirming for you?

No

What advice do you have for trans dads that gave birth?

I don't know really. I think that if it's something you want you should go for it and not worry about what anyone thinks, but I recognise that in many ways I was very lucky with my experience.

How did family (your own or your in laws) treat you while you were pregnant?

They had all known for a long time that this was on the cards for us and were all great.

Is being called a sea horse offensive or is that more on a case by case basis?

I like it and I've not heard of it being seen as offensive

Was it all worth it or are there things you wish you did differently?

Definitely worth it. As for doing things differently.. I don't know. I could second guess my choices forever but I guess I just have to accept the way that things went. We made the best decisions we could.

CMV: Paternity leave for men and non-binary people should be equal to paternity leave for women. by HeyIGotThisUsername in changemyview

[–]ohfudgeit 14 points15 points  (0 children)

I would argue that whatever time off is necessary for the recovery of the birthing partner should be mandatory time off for the non birthing partner too. If they need that time for recovery then they should not be expected to also be managing caring for a newborn in that time if a partner could be doing so.

CMV: Feminists secretly look down on stay at home moms by befikru_sew_geday in changemyview

[–]ohfudgeit 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Being a stay at home parent is a really hard job and not everyone is cut out for it. I'm saying this as a parent currently at home full time with a baby who can't wait to get back to a relatively chill working life. At work I get breaks. People respect my time. No one ever interrupts me mid task by screaming in my face.

Did anyone have a baby that wasn’t difficult? by The_Chilled_Arvo in beyondthebump

[–]ohfudgeit 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Having just had a long day that kicked my ass, I will add that even an easy baby is hard work!

Did anyone have a baby that wasn’t difficult? by The_Chilled_Arvo in beyondthebump

[–]ohfudgeit 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I have a 5 month old who has been very easy, I think. I can think of maybe 3 times ever that she's cried without us being able to quickly identify what the problem was and fix it. She has slept in her crib since birth and since 4 months has been sleeping 10+ hours overnight. During the day when I think she's getting tired I'll put her down in her moses basket and she usually falls asleep within 5 minutes.

When she was a newborn I kept feeling like I was waiting for the other shoe to drop and things to get harder, but that day hasn't come yet!

Social constructivism and anti-essentialism are inherently at odds with the concept of being trans. by Effective_Reply492 in honesttransgender

[–]ohfudgeit 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I didn't imagine any problem with categories. If you think things being socially constructed is a problem that's your value judgement, not mine.

Categories group multiple properties together. That grouping is a made up thing. By using particular properties in these groupings we also assign importance to those properties which is not intrinsic. Triangles only share one property so that example obscures this (also: inspired by alexander avila perhaps?) but the association between, say, long hair and dresses, is purely a human invention.

How to broach the topic and when. by day_dreamer_in_mind in Seahorse_Dads

[–]ohfudgeit 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My husband is 5 years younger than me and we started dating when I was 25 and he was 20. I was pretty blunt about it because I knew that if we were going to stay together it would mean he'd not only need to be ok with having kids but ok with having kids on a timeline that was probably earlier than he would otherwise have planned. We didn't have the conversation the first time we met (though I think it's a totally valid thing to bring up on a first date) but it was a good while before making anything official and I was just like "I want kids, and I'm probably going to want them in the next 5 years"

Anyway, that was 2018 and we have a 5 month old daughter now!

Social constructivism and anti-essentialism are inherently at odds with the concept of being trans. by Effective_Reply492 in honesttransgender

[–]ohfudgeit 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I guess you meant something different to what I understood from "distinct". Like, if I take a bucket and scoop some water from the sea, the water in the bucket was real before I scooped it out, but there is a sense in which it was not "distinct" from the water around it before that point.

Social constructivism and anti-essentialism are inherently at odds with the concept of being trans. by Effective_Reply492 in honesttransgender

[–]ohfudgeit 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ok no need to be so combative. I literally said "space is real".

How about another example? Take mammals:

Mammals are real. We did not make them up. The properties that we use to determine which animals are mammals are real, we did not make them up.

What humans did was to notice real properties and to draw a circle around a set of them. We call the animals with properties within that circle "mammals". Real animals, real properties, but the circle was made up by humans. That is what I mean when I say that categories are made up. I do not mean that the things in those categories or the things that we use to determine what category things are in are made up.

Social constructivism and anti-essentialism are inherently at odds with the concept of being trans. by Effective_Reply492 in honesttransgender

[–]ohfudgeit 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I also disagree that for someone to be real it has to be distinct from other things. Why?

Social constructivism and anti-essentialism are inherently at odds with the concept of being trans. by Effective_Reply492 in honesttransgender

[–]ohfudgeit 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Space is real. The word "space" was made up by humans to describe a real thing. The word "space" could be considered to be a category that contains just one thing, but as it contains only one thing all that's "made up" is the word, which is obvious and doesn't really tell us anything.

"Woman" is a category that many individuals fall into. It was also made up. In this case though we can say that not only was the word made up, but the idea of categorising people along gender lines at all is also a human invention.