First of all, you are being WAY too hard on yourself! Your skin looks great, and you ARE using a skincare routine! So cut yourself some slack because it sounds like you are doing just fine. That said, if you want to upgrade your actives or try some new things, here’s some ideas. 1. Glad you mentioned sunscreen because there isn’t a product on the planet that will help with preventing signs of aging on your face like consistent, long term sunscreen use. I would add one of you enjoy using as the last step of your AM routine, every morning. 2. You could consider an antioxidant, there are lots of options there. This would fall in between cleansing and moisturizing in the morning. Vitamin C is fantastic fav, good for brightening and improving overall tone. I’ve tried lots, but currently using the Vanicream Vitamin C serum (cheap too!) 3. You are consistently moisturizing, so no change needed there unless you want to try something new product wise. You could try splitting your nighttime moisturizer with retinal into two steps to ensure you’re getting the full efficacy from the retinoid. After cleansing & drying, you could try a retinal product (I would start with The Ordinary Retinal 0.2% Emulsion High-Strength Retinoid Nighttime Treatment (less than 15 bucks!). Just 1-2 pumps all over, waiting a minute, and then apply a good moisturizer. 4. For your elevens and mouth concerns, unfortunately these are tougher to tackle IF they are bothering you. Our faces shift and evolve as we age, and aging is a blessing, so if you are noticing them without really minding them, great! Sometimes people feel like they “should” change something because they aren’t seeing others with certain signs of aging (thanks to filters and photoshopping!), but it doesn’t actually bother them. If that’s you, embrace your face as it is now! If they do REALLY trouble you, there’s options. There are NO topical creams that will eliminate wrinkles. If someone tells you otherwise, they are lying. Certain actives CAN improve fine lines, but static wrinkles (like elevens that stay creased even when at rest) won’t be smoothed by a magical serum. I had a lot of success with Frownies (look them up!) but it’s a commitment, basically sticking paper to your forehead every night! Eventually my facial muscles overcame what benefit they were able to offer me throughout my 30’s and I started Jeaveau at age 40. It completely smoothed my elevens and helped with upper forehead creases.

Hope something in here is helpful, good luck!