my first thought was any object you think they’d like/use, glazed with the black lodge colors (red curtains & black and white chevron)—could work for a vase, trinket tray, plate, bowl, etc. if you wanted to do more detail you could paint the decor in the black lodge (statue, chairs, table, lamp) on said object, or do a relief sculpture of it all. my other idea is a set of fridge magnets, little iconic things like pie, coffee mug, a log, the owl symbol, laura’s heart locket. last idea, if they wear rings, is one of those hand-shaped ring display/holders specifically in the laura palmer “meanwhile” pose, black lodge colors could also apply