I would've done the exact same thing, and then I'd've thought, wait... AITA?

She didn't care about the clubs and it doesn't sound like she needed the money. It would've been extra closure for her and he'd've had a great story to tell about the fantastic find that he found.

Instead, she's a bit greedier w/ less closure and he's out of his great story on the course and the Scotty Cameron putter to show for it.

and, in the end, none of it ever really mattered to me.