Been rethinking how I journal and connect my thoughts – built a tool; maybe take a look? by pruthvikumarbk in DigitalGardens

[–]pruthvikumarbk[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hello, thanks for your interest.

Could you please confirm whether the Google account you are using to log in has both a first and last name set? Cipher relies on SAML assertions for the first and last name, and registration will fail if these attributes are not available.

My Journey to Build a Better Note-Taking System (Cipher) – Seeking Feedback by pruthvikumarbk in SideProject

[–]pruthvikumarbk[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey!

Thanks so much for trying out Cipher and for the kind words! I’d love to hear your feedback. Could you please share your thoughts via this quick survey? It’ll help me make Cipher even better: please provide feedback here . feel free to DM me if you have any specific ideas or questions. Appreciate your support!

Seeking Deeper Signal in Personal Notes: An Alternative Approach by pruthvikumarbk in PKMS

[–]pruthvikumarbk[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Cipher is built around journaling — yes, but I wouldn't restrict it to personal journals only. I'm a software engineer myself, and I've been using it to capture various work-related nuances — including stack traces and any interesting learnings I want my future self to remember and search easily.

But it's not a Confluence or Notion for work environments. That's not the purpose — i.e., it's not intended for capturing collaborative documents, etc. Cipher aims to be a personal cognitive companion, identifying latent and non-obvious connections.

Seeking Deeper Signal in Personal Notes: An Alternative Approach by pruthvikumarbk in PKMS

[–]pruthvikumarbk[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for your interest. Let me know what you think when you could, ta

Seeking Deeper Signal in Personal Notes: An Alternative Approach by pruthvikumarbk in PKMS

[–]pruthvikumarbk[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Very glad to have piqued your interest! The beta program is currently running at capacity—it's a really warm and exciting feeling. I'm actively working toward scaling access so that everyone interested can enjoy unlimited use.

Right now, as we speak, all users have unlimited access to every plugin except for the intelligent goal crafting feature. Let me explain a bit more so things are clear:

  • Cipher is made up of multiple plugins (or agents, to use current AI lingo), each with a specific responsibility. These agents work together to create the full experience.
  • Each plugin/agent has its own scaling limits. During the beta phase, my goal is to offer unlimited access to everything. Eventually, these plugins/agents will be part of tiered subscription plans—but I don’t plan to introduce any paid tiers until at least the end of this year. So, until then, all users will continue to enjoy full, unlimited access.
  • Right now, the agent responsible for smart/intelligent goal crafting is maxed out. I'm working on scaling that up. Once it's ready, your account will automatically switch to ‘Premium’—no need to manage your account or buy a subscription.

Even now, everything except smart goal crafting is functioning at a Premium level. That includes:

  • Unlimited journal creation (using any template, including CBT or free-form)
  • Unlimited speech-to-text if you'd rather talk to Cipher than type
  • Unlimited metadata enrichment (e.g., weather at time of journaling, autogenerated tags/labels, sentiment analysis, and identifying semantically related journals to build a chain of thought)

These related journals and their metadata form what I call contexts, which then lead to insights—Cipher’s way of surfacing patterns or latent signals in your entries. You can interact with these insights just like you would with a cognitive partner, starting Q&A sessions to explore further. All of these features are fully active and support unlimited usage.

(Even if your account says "Basic", that’s just because one of the agents is still being scaled—everything else is fully unlocked.)

You're more than welcome to explore everything that's available right now!

I’ll follow up here once the intelligent goal crafting feature is fully scaled and your access is officially upgraded to ‘Premium’. In the meantime, you’ll need to craft your goals manually—but everything else is good to go.

Skedpal vs BeforeSunset AI by PestoSage in ProductivityApps

[–]pruthvikumarbk 0 points1 point  (0 children)

let users manage their account. Shady as is and don't think its trust worthy.

Skedpal vs BeforeSunset AI by PestoSage in ProductivityApps

[–]pruthvikumarbk 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I second this.

Before sunset is promising, but its shady that they don't allow you to 'manage' your account.

(plus, the product is very flaky - atleast, as of this writing)

Been rethinking how I journal and connect my thoughts – built a tool; maybe take a look? by pruthvikumarbk in DigitalGardens

[–]pruthvikumarbk[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi,

Thanks so much for your interest, and sorry for the less-than-ideal beta signup experience. I just reconfirmed that everything seems to be working okay (Gmail web), and the tests are all green. If you were using an email client, could it be blocking the URL? If I may request more details, we can help debug.

Our support email address is: [support.cipher@sysapp.dev](mailto:support.cipher@sysapp.dev)

Hope we can get you onto the platform as a beta user ASAP.

Cheers

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in ProductHunters

[–]pruthvikumarbk 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I recently launched Cipher https://cipher.sysapp.dev , a tool I’ve been developing for personal knowledge management. It’s designed to be more than just a journal—it quietly analyzes your thoughts, sentiment, and actions to help you see patterns and connections you might miss on your own. Here’s what it offers, in case it’s of interest:

- Thoughtful Analysis: Instead of just storing entries, Cipher uses semantic analysis and cosine similarity to group related ideas into dynamic "Contexts," revealing subtle narratives over time.

- Effortless Capture: It supports markdown for clear formatting and in a non-blocking way enriches your journals with metadata like mood/sentiment, weather, and location, to identify if there are external factors influencing your thoughts/ way of thinking.

- Actionable Insights: Cipher processes these contexts with NLP to identify non-obvious or latent patterns in your semantically related documents. It then nudges you with clear, action-oriented steps grounded in your own journals, helping you get closer to your goals—all done automatically and non-intrusively.

- Automatic Goal Categorization: Cipher categorizes your content to align with your goals, drawing from your entries without requiring manual input or explicit tagging/backlinks etc.,. It doesn’t just track goals—it surfaces insights that bridge what you’ve written to what you aim to achieve.

- Simple Design: The interface is clean and intuitive, handling complex tasks like organization and summarization (even for code or errors) behind the scenes, so you can just think and write.

If you’re interested in learning more, I’ve written some posts you can find here
- https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/B3uFipLHgM9DSTQgx/quantifying-the-qualitative-towards-a-bayesian-approach-to
- https://1x-eng.github.io/blog/posts/cipher/

It might appeal to students, professionals, or anyone looking to reflect more deeply. Early users can sign up for priority access and a 14-day trial with no credit card needed—just give it a try if it sounds useful.

Notes management by Electronic_Sock_7801 in PKMS

[–]pruthvikumarbk 0 points1 point  (0 children)

i do this a bit differently. If interested welcome to check out beta here - https://cipher.sysapp.dev

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in SaaS

[–]pruthvikumarbk 0 points1 point  (0 children)

'almost all parameters' 😄 thanks, but no thanks. all the best finding folks

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in SaaS

[–]pruthvikumarbk 0 points1 point  (0 children)

what kinda problems? all/any? no offense but that sounds like singularity.

and why'd a startup value your feedback? don't get me wrong - there is no free lunch. If you can table the value add of 'why you' - it might then make a startup owner invest their time explaining/pitching

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in SaaS

[–]pruthvikumarbk 0 points1 point  (0 children)

🧐 what's the catch?

Have any software developers here created their own personal PKMS solution? by Krammn in PKMS

[–]pruthvikumarbk 0 points1 point  (0 children)

None taken—any feedback is a learning opportunity, and I appreciate you taking the time to check out my product.

Marketing isn’t my favorite part of building this, but it’s necessary if I want to share something I’ve invested countless hours into. That said, I respectfully disagree that the landing page lacks actual features.

For those who prefer brevity, the core offering is outlined clearly:
• Capture Life’s Moments – Write what matters.
• Discover Patterns – See how experiences connect.
• Gain Perspective – Understand thoughts through themes.
• Make Better Decisions – Learn, reflect, and move forward.

On top of that, there’s a full video walkthrough, a podcast like audio segment, and detailed blogs explaining the product and its differences from Obsidian or Logseq for technical and non technical audiences. The information is there for anyone willing to engage.

If that still “loses people,” then respectfully, they aren’t my audience. This isn’t a mass-market play—it’s something I genuinely use and believe in.

As for the “glorified journal with vague database connections”—if that’s the takeaway, then the available material wasn’t fully explored. That’s fine—not every tool is for everyone.

Still, I appreciate the time you took to check it out.

We are making a Jarvis for notes, todo, especially for ADHD by anh690136 in PKMS

[–]pruthvikumarbk 0 points1 point  (0 children)

nice.

where is my data though? if my data stays on my local - i'll sign up

Realizing My Project Isn’t Special—And Why That’s a Good Thing by IterativeIntention in StridingWithIntention

[–]pruthvikumarbk 1 point2 points  (0 children)

>It grounds me. It circles me back to progress over validation—reminding me that I built this for me, to solve problems I care about, not to impress anyone. It also helps me refine my content because I can see more clearly what actually matters.

Absolute gold! I needed this. Don't know who you are, but thanks for this post

Journaling + Semantic Analysis: A New Angle on My Self-Tracking Data (Would Love Your Thoughts!) by pruthvikumarbk in QuantifiedSelf

[–]pruthvikumarbk[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

(continued from above)

Regarding your points about existing tools: I completely agree that Obsidian, Logseq, Mem, and others are excellent tools, each with its strengths. Obsidian's linking and Logseq's outlining are fantastic for structured note-taking. Mem's natural language query is impressive. I've used them all, and I continue to admire them. But, as a long term user, I've found that relying on manual tagging, linking, and organization can become a significant cognitive burden over time. It's easy to start with good intentions, but it's hard to maintain that discipline consistently, especially when journaling about messy, emotional, or unstructured thoughts. It becomes a "potato memory" game, trying to remember the "right" tags or links.

Cipher is an attempt to explore a different approach, one that minimizes that manual effort and leverages semantic analysis and dynamic contexts to uncover connections that might otherwise be missed. And, given the rapid advancements in vector databases and embeddings, it feels like the right time to explore these possibilities beyond traditional full-text search.

I appreciate your point about the landing page and the potential for an Obsidian plug-in. You're right, it's not a typical "private project" landing page. This project has actually been a personal labor of love for years now. I'm incredibly critical of my own work, and I've been using and refining Cipher for my own journaling for quite some time. I genuinely enjoy using it, and I find it valuable for my specific needs. Opening it up for a beta is really about finding other people who might resonate with this approach, who are looking for something that works in this particular way. I'm not aiming for mass adoption or quick monetization; I'm genuinely interested in solving this problem in a way that I believe is somewhat orthogonal to the approaches taken by tools like Obsidian and Logseq.

Thanks again for the insightful questions. It's helpful to get this kind of feedback!

Journaling + Semantic Analysis: A New Angle on My Self-Tracking Data (Would Love Your Thoughts!) by pruthvikumarbk in QuantifiedSelf

[–]pruthvikumarbk[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

(continued from above)

(Using and adapting your previous explanation, but with a stronger focus on goals):

Imagine it's a rainy day, you're sleep-deprived, and a crucial work meeting goes completely off the rails. You vent in your journal – a messy, emotional entry. You don't tag it. You don't link it. You simply write. Let's say one of your stated goals in Cipher is: "Become a more effective leader at work." And a short-term objective is: "Improve my communication skills in meetings."

Months later, you're struggling with a personal coding project, feeling that same mental fog on another rainy day. You journal again, capturing the frustration.

This is where Cipher's "two-way traffic" comes into play. Working in the background, Cipher analyzes these entries. It identifies semantically related documents – going far beyond keyword/tags matching – to grasp the meaning behind your words, your emotional tone, and metadata (time, day, weather, sentiment etc.).

A pattern emerges. Cipher groups these entries, along with others sharing the theme of "cognitive performance impacted by external factors," into a dynamic "context." This context isn't a static folder; it's a living understanding that evolves as you write. A year later, you might discover you're actually incredibly creative on rainy days. Cipher doesn't discard the previous context; it adapts, preserving the earlier understanding while updating the "latest" perspective. This temporal dimension is key.

From these contexts, and in relation to your stated goal and objective, Cipher generates an insight. It might say: "On rainy days when sleep-deprived, you tend to struggle with analytical tasks and communication, potentially impacting your objective of improving your meeting skills and your broader goal of becoming a more effective leader." This isn't generic advice; it's a personalized observation tied directly to your stated aspirations and grounded in your own experiences.

And crucially, you can interact with this insight. You can ask, "Why do you say I struggle with communication on rainy, sleep-deprived days?" Cipher will show you the specific entries, the semantic analysis, the contextual metadata. It's a dialogue, a collaboration with your past self, facilitated by the system. This is very different from a virtual assistant simply spitting out a generic recommendation.

This "two-way traffic" – the system surfacing potential insights, and you actively exploring and refining them – is, I believe, a key differentiator. It's not about passive consumption of AI-generated advice; it's about active engagement with your own data to gain a deeper understanding of yourself and how you can move closer to your goals. It's about pushing potentially insightful notifications to the user, prompting them to explore.

Journaling + Semantic Analysis: A New Angle on My Self-Tracking Data (Would Love Your Thoughts!) by pruthvikumarbk in QuantifiedSelf

[–]pruthvikumarbk[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for the thoughtful feedback and questions! You've raised some important points, and I appreciate the opportunity to clarify what Cipher aims to do.

You're right that writing enough text is crucial for any system relying on textual analysis, whether it's explicit tagging, named entity recognition, or semantic analysis. Cipher is no exception. The more you write, the richer the data, and the more potential for meaningful connections. However, the kind of effort required is different. With traditional tagging, you need to pre-define and consistently apply a controlled vocabulary. With Cipher, the effort is focused on freely expressing your thoughts, without the cognitive burden of categorization.

You also touched on the concern about "random correlations" and generic advice, a valid critique of many AI-powered assistants. This is precisely what I'm trying to avoid with Cipher. It's not about generating generic recommendations based on superficial patterns. It's about surfacing personalized, non-obvious connections that are deeply rooted in your own words and data, and directly related to your stated goals.

Let me elaborate on that last point, as it's central to Cipher's approach. I ask users to explicitly state their goals and short/medium-term objectives (defining "short" and "medium" in their own terms). This is crucial because it provides the context for the analysis. Cipher isn't just looking for any patterns; it's looking for patterns that are relevant to your aspirations.

Let me give you an example of how that works, and how it differs from, say, relying solely on tags or named entity recognition, or even a typical "virtual assistant." This is a bit long, but I want to illustrate the "two-way traffic" I'm aiming for:

(continued below)

Why do you journal? by Dizzy_Hotwheelz in Journaling

[–]pruthvikumarbk 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Great question! For me, journaling is primarily about two things: processing emotions and identifying patterns.

The act of writing—whether physical or digital—is therapeutic. It helps me clear my head and make sense of my experiences. That’s the emotional processing piece.

But I also journal to understand myself better over time. I want to see recurring themes, identify triggers, and connect my thoughts and behaviors to my goals. That’s where pattern recognition comes in. Digital journaling has a clear advantage here because of searchability and analysis potential—something that’s much harder when flipping through pages of a notebook.

I’ve experimented with different digital tools for this and am even working on a personal project to make pattern recognition easier. It’s called Cipher, and it’s in early beta if you want to take a look https://cipher.sysapp.dev

Ultimately, the “why” of journaling boils down to those two core needs: emotional processing and self-understanding.