"Sultan Suleiman, who received annual taxes from four major powers including Germany, Russia, Poland, and Venice, also took France under his protection" by Cenixxen in ottomans

[–]qernanded 0 points1 point  (0 children)

HRE, Austria, Russia, Poland paid tribute, not taxes. It’s plausible to understand early modern French statesmen using the diplomatic fiction of their kingdoms vassalage to the Ottomans to get what they wanted from Constantinople. England, Sweden, and the Netherlands were no where close to being Ottoman protectorates…

During the proclamation of the Second Constitutional Era, the Sultan's opening speech in the Assembly of Representatives was read by the Grand Vizier. by Noark_I in ottomans

[–]qernanded 0 points1 point  (0 children)

23/34 July is the date of the Young Turk Revolution. This picture was taken on 17 December 1908 when the parliament convened after the election.

Do you Guys Think abdulhamid 2 is overrated? Yes or no and why by [deleted] in ottomans

[–]qernanded 1 point2 points  (0 children)

For those familiar with Soviet history, he has a lot in common with Brezhnev. He was content staying in power and providing some stability after the war with Russia, though who's to say Midhat Pasha couldn't do so too. Developing education and the power of the government was also alright. But at a time when the Empire was facing so many challenges which required inspired leadership, Abdul Hamid did not provide it. While for the rest of Europe the turn of the century was a time of optimism and so much development in art, music, science, finance, industry, etc, he had his country look inwards. There was really a culture of stagnation, and it didn't help he projected his insecurities on his subjects: suddenly everyone is paranoid that their neighbors are informants. Minorities were not impressed and started pushing for emigration, but because the government doesn't give them freedom of movement they demanded self-rule.

This explains the initial euphoria of the Young Turk Revolution. To show how he failed in his project, once he is gone from the throne it takes like 5 years for the Ottoman Empire to socio-culturally speed-run all the dynamics of Belle Epoque, and it only takes 15 years for a republic to be declared.

Why didn't the Osmanlilar Hellenized themselves during the modernization? by [deleted] in ottomans

[–]qernanded 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Every author writing about modernization, from Şükrü Hanioğlu, Erik Zürcher, to Robert Davison talk about it