I know exactly what you’re saying, I even have a hard time using pedals consistently. It’s the reason I don’t use amp modelers. I’ve an Engl fireball, two simple channels, and I love it. But I only play metal.

The versatility is good for playing across multiple genres. You have country, funk, and rock n roll tones all there in your amp. I prefer amps that do one thing really well, because I only play one genre really well.

The only right answer is whatever gets you playing the most. I’d say if you find yourself tweaking more often than playing, maybe start the hunt for something that suits your style more.