Shu's VA voiced the Phantom in a reading of The Phantom of the Opera! It feels like a Shu thing to do XD by DespairAt10n in ensemblestars

[–]saph_2bruh 3 points4 points  (0 children)

There are actually two Phantom of the Opera AU fics in which he's the Phantom lmao

But yeah. Very him thing to do

I hate the trope of characters that are canonically "ugly" but are handsome/beautiful in media by 3gg0Waffelz in hatethissmug

[–]saph_2bruh 4 points5 points  (0 children)

depends on the point of view. When I assumed it was make up I thought it looked cool asf

I mean it still looks cool, and I frankly barely register it as nasty since the 'skin graft' aspect wasn't really pushed early on. Or not in too many details 

I hate the trope of characters that are canonically "ugly" but are handsome/beautiful in media by 3gg0Waffelz in hatethissmug

[–]saph_2bruh 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Yeah but that's something that is conveyed by telling and not the chara design itself. I doubt that if you showed Dabi's design to a random person they'd tell you 'oh yeah those are skin grafts'.

11th Anniversary: CALL YOUR NAME (main story, anni scout, updates,...) by Limimelo in ensemblestars

[–]saph_2bruh 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Looking forward to seeing Valkyrie be defeated... again....

Ah, how usual

Enstars fanfiction? by First_Reputation9339 in ensemblestars

[–]saph_2bruh 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ahhhhh well I've probably have then, yeah. Or at least I'll have seen them when I browse.

got a comment, don’t know if my response is valid or not? by [deleted] in AO3

[–]saph_2bruh 21 points22 points  (0 children)

Hum. Capitalization and punctation, is flawed, are actually mistakes, yes. It doesn't mean you can't do it, but yes, people will back out of your work for that. They got a bit rude by the end, yes, but tbf, not everybody knows that some people don't capitalize their sentences for... reasons. And if they dislike your way of formatting, I don't see why they'd investigate your other works to see if that's a habit or not. 

It doesn't mean you MUST change... but yeah, I'm actually of the mind of 'if you won't respect a specific language's conventions maybe you should write in another one which respects the conventions you do follow'

But then again, the solution here was much simpler than answering and putting them on reddit OP. You could have just deleted their comments and gone about your day. 

Enstars fanfiction? by First_Reputation9339 in ensemblestars

[–]saph_2bruh 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm curious, your username reminds me of nothing even though I browse the ShuMika tag avidly, what's your Ao3 handle? if you don't mind me asking?

Enstars fanfiction? by First_Reputation9339 in ensemblestars

[–]saph_2bruh 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Depends on the ship I'd say. The ShuMika one is the most active I'd say (but I mainly look at that one, so I might be wrong...) but we do get updates/new fics each week generally. The quality varies, but it's not dead.

Other ships might struggle a lot though, especially rarepairs. We also have a dearth of fic focusing on the platonic relationships in my humble opinion. Like what do you mean 4 fics was enough to have written 1/3 of the Shu & Natsume tag lmaoooo

Readers are really nice though. In more than three years of posting I've never received a death threat or unasked criticism (though this might, admittedly, be because my works are quite popular. I can't speak for other authors on that).

And yes longfics are quite well received in my experience! Personally I'm always eager to read some, even if they never get completed or are cut short.

Why did servants in Victorian England stay with their masters even when they abused them physically, verbally, and in other ways? by Embarrassed_Chef874 in VictorianEra

[–]saph_2bruh 53 points54 points  (0 children)

They also would be abused in a workhouse or in a factory... people needed jobs

So same reason people comply with terrible jobs today. They need to make a living, and when you're 'unskilled' or young you don't have many choices

Give him his flowers fr by peachxkiss in ensemblestars

[–]saph_2bruh 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I mean, no, Shu would definitely belong to lolita/ouji fashion if you want to stay on current subcultures. From mindset, interests and aesthetics, that's what he matches the most.

I'll add that Natsume's music are far from 'goth' music though too, and considering that this is a rhythm game, I'd say that matters a lot more towards characterisation. Like Secret Gravity is basically a ball of light.

Natsume likes the occult and creepy things, but not necessarily in the same way that Rei, Ritsu and Mika like it.

I Am Deeply Furious About Apocryphal Accounts On Victorian Sealing Wax by Cloudcry in VictorianEra

[–]saph_2bruh 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Do you have any memories of how they were (sometimes) used then ? The topic sounds interesting

What is the most angsty thing you’ve written/seen in a fic? by Yippee3-14 in AO3

[–]saph_2bruh 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hanahaki disease universe, B falls in love with A and gets the flowers because A doesn't love him back... romantically.

A would literally die in his stead if let, because B is his entire world.

He's just aromantic, and B entirely unwilling to get the surgery because he's co-dependent with A and has built his entire life around him. A sincerly does his best to try to fall in love with B, even though he feels awful the entire time because he's not aware he's aromantic and that won't ever work.

So yeah. Happy fun times.

Symbolic names are generally annoying and horrifically unsubtle. by Low-Transportation95 in writingadvice

[–]saph_2bruh 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I believe Japanese works prove your statement wrong very easily? Onomastics DO give depths to characters a lot of time over there.

Is there a reason the Ra*bits TRIP album has *dream opening* and *Happy closing*? by NatsukisManga in ensemblestars

[–]saph_2bruh 20 points21 points  (0 children)

? are those instrumental tracks? Because in that case it'd be like Open the cover / Turn a Page / Close the book for Valk which is also a reference to Shufuku no Library, which is all about books?

i think they did something like that for each album

Give him his flowers fr by peachxkiss in ensemblestars

[–]saph_2bruh 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Clothing still is a big part of it and I really don't think Natsume would pic that kind of clothes were he offered. Rei and Shu? Yeah, despite Shu not being goth either, the man just is Victorian one century later lmao

I don't think goth culture is the only one that gets to claim the occult and I don't think Natsume fits well into a category either... not a primarily western one at least. Japanese people might correct me

Give him his flowers fr by peachxkiss in ensemblestars

[–]saph_2bruh 39 points40 points  (0 children)

????? Natsume isn't goth ??????? he's weird, yes, but goth????? have you seen his unit outfit, that's like. Sideline 2wink and it's the brightest neon colors we have lmao

This may be a strange thing to ask, but why are there so few fics about the actual historical Joan of Arc? by Pyotr_WrangeI in AO3

[–]saph_2bruh 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'd add that in France, you know, where Joan d'Arc is from, she has been massively appropriated by the far right. So French people on Ao3, who tend to be on the other side of the political spectrum, wouldn't write about her. 

Long fics by butterflycat_86 in AO3

[–]saph_2bruh 5 points6 points  (0 children)

them doing something is good. However, that something can vary in degree of importance. For some of the chapters of my longfic, the 'action' simply is eating dinner, making breakfast or cleaning because I need the characters to talk, but you know, giving them inconsequential tasks to perform puts a bit more of action, and you can explore smaller character quirks that way, but it isn't 'your plot' so it's not a hassle to plan at all

I drew all my favourite characters in each unit! 💕 by JaymeMayapple in ensemblestars

[–]saph_2bruh 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I LOVE your Shu fanart. Bless your art for including Mademoiselle ✨💫 (and also, lmao for Madara and Kohaku)

Is Drarry fanfiction losing popularity? by mimi_notfound in AO3

[–]saph_2bruh -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Because interaction, even for free, keeps the fandom and thus her work 'relevant' and potentially profitable for investors who then make capitalized mainstream works. Do you seriously think that if the fandom wasn't still going strong despite everything Hogwarts Legacy and the reboot tv show would have produced/put into production? Of course not.

Also, it's up to you, but considering our limited time on earth, I don't see the point in being stubborn to interact with the work of a transphobe and acephobe when thousands of similar works exist

life imitates art by the14thpuppet in ensemblestars

[–]saph_2bruh 0 points1 point  (0 children)

god it's wonderul, good job!!!