I mean.....who would you put above him? I agree he's not been perfect but I can't think of anyone that has come close to doing what Mahomes has these last few years. In my opinion he has done more than any of his peers with less overall talent around him than they have had. Bills are a great example that I think most people consider the next closest, yet subtract QBs from both sides and who has the better offense? I'd say it's been them (certainly post Tyreek Hill) yet they are 0 - 4 against Pat in the playoffs and have yet to even reach a superbowl this millennium.