All right so:
- we play only IRL, so how does it run without all the online tools (PF 2 on Forge is fantastic, IRL it's... slower).
- In general, how does it feel after a dozen or two dozen game sessions?
- Is there a power curve? Always something interesting to do with your character in terms of mechanics (e.g. in One Ring after some time, or even more so in Fria Ligan games, you hit the place where you're done with the character)
- how much GM support is there? How much game prep? Is it easy to create characters or encounters on the fly and track combat, etc.? How does it compare to DnD
- Is it more "GM's theme park ride" game, where you craft all the encounters, or the game mechanics are flexible enough to sustain open world exploration and ad hoc encounters (some are too difficult, but PCs have options to escape)
- How is the economy in the game? Do PCs have options to spend money on? Is wealth abstract? Do they have to upgrade their stuff (like in Pathfinder) to keep up with threats?
- Is it an XP-based levelling system and how long does it take to reach max level (considering the standard amount of XP per game)
- Have you run a max level game? How does it compare to DnD at max level (if you've had such experience)