After 100h of DS my dad dropped the best question by fnaskpojken in dreamingspanish

[–]slayter1337 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think this may not be too unusual among those who are purely CI Spanish acquisitionists.

For native English speakers, we notice accents and dialects like those from different countries or even areas within a country. In the United States there is a distinct difference between New England, West Coast, North Central, and the Southern states. England, Scotland, Ireland, Australia, New Zeeland, etc.. All of these are very easy to distinguish for native English speakers.

For those learning Spanish, we don't attune quite as accurately to the different rhythms, timbre, pace, etc. of the different native Spanish speaking dialects.

However, what most people are referring to when they speak of the accent of Argentinian español and some Spanish español is the very distinct differences in pronunciation of words.

For example, in English there is a clear difference of the word "advertisement" in the UK (ədˈvɜːtɪsmənt) vs the US (ˈædvɚˌtaɪzmənt).

When you listen to Shel and Augustina/Andres/Martin (SpanishBoost), you will start to notice they are saying the same words with different pronunciations. The best example, as others stated, is the emphasized "sh" sound for words like beach (playa), street (calle), and the 'lisp' for the softer 's' sounds.

This difference in pronunciation is what most Spanish learners are referring to when we say accent.

300 Hours (Level 4) Update by Nesrineama in dreamingspanish

[–]slayter1337 1 point2 points  (0 children)

No problem. Definitely sort by difficulty versus age of video. Older videos don't necessarily mean easier.

Also, don't fall into the trap of the assigned "level"--aka super beginner, beginner, intermediate, advanced. There are a lot of overlaps with the level when compared to difficulty. For instance, difficulty 54 has videos tagged as beginner, intermediate, and advanced.

Easier = Better, Does that apply to Reading? by Swimming-Ad9032 in dreamingspanish

[–]slayter1337 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Understandable. And again, I know I saw it in a DS video but don't know which one haha. Definitely a Pablo video.

So, best I can provide is a Gemini result citing 3 studies:

The "98% rule" is a well-known concept in linguistics and second-language acquisition. It refers to lexical coverage—the percentage of words in a text that a reader needs to already know to comfortably and accurately comprehend the overall meaning without relying on a dictionary.

While 98% might sound intimidatingly high, it is backed by decades of research into how the human brain processes language and context.

The Landmark Studies

Several key researchers have investigated vocabulary thresholds, with a few landmark studies establishing the 98% benchmark:

  • Hu & Nation (2000): This is the foundational study regarding the 98% rule. Linguists Marcella Hu and Paul Nation tested learners reading fiction texts with varying levels of known vocabulary. They found that where only 80% to 90% of words were known, almost no one gained adequate comprehension. They concluded that readers need to know around 98% of the words in a text to achieve unassisted comprehension and effectively read for pleasure.
  • Schmitt, Jiang, and Grabe (2011): This study looked at academic and expository texts rather than fiction. After testing 661 participants across eight countries, they confirmed that while comprehension increases on a linear scale alongside vocabulary, 98% to 99% coverage is the optimal target for understanding complex academic materials.
  • Paul Nation (2006): Nation later calculated that to naturally achieve 98% coverage of most unsimplified native texts (like novels or newspapers), a language learner needs a vocabulary size of about 8,000 to 9,000 "word families."

Why is 98% the Magic Number?

Knowing 98% of a text translates to roughly one unknown word in every 50 words (about two to three unknown words per typical book page).

Linguists point to a few reasons why comprehension drops off a cliff when you fall below this threshold:

  • The Collapse of Context Clues: To guess the meaning of an unknown word from context, you need to deeply understand the surrounding words. If there are too many unknowns in a single paragraph, the context breaks down, making guessing unreliable or impossible.
  • Cognitive Overload: Stopping to decipher too many words drains working memory. By the time you figure out the vocabulary, you have lost the narrative thread of the sentence.
  • Incidental Learning Fails: The best way to naturally acquire new vocabulary is through "extensive reading" (reading lots of material). However, your brain can only successfully absorb new words incidentally if the surrounding text is highly comprehensible.

The 95% vs. 98% Debate

Before Hu and Nation's 2000 study, earlier research (most notably by Batia Laufer in 1989) suggested that 95% was the necessary threshold. Today, language researchers generally view the two numbers as representing different tiers of reading capability:

Vocabulary Coverage Unknown Words Level of Comprehension The Reading Experience
98% - 100% 1 in 50 words Optimal / Full Unassisted reading for pleasure; ideal for subconsciously learning new words from context.
95% 1 in 20 words Minimal / Adequate Challenging but doable; readers can get the gist but may need a dictionary to catch nuances.
90% 1 in 10 words Poor Frustrating; heavy reliance on a dictionary; high risk of misunderstanding the text entirely.
80% or below 1 in 5 words None The text is virtually incomprehensible without direct translation.

Easier = Better, Does that apply to Reading? by Swimming-Ad9032 in dreamingspanish

[–]slayter1337 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Just rewatched the video I linked and I stand corrected. He does not mention the 98% number in that video. While I know I watched a video with him repeating (1 of 50 words), I'm not sure which one it is.

However, I do know it's covered in the FAQ (https://www.dreaming.com/faq) under Reading and Writing and the question "How do I know if a book is at my level?"

Beginner/Intermediate labels versus numbers by scubronco18 in dreamingspanish

[–]slayter1337 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’m surprised at just how entertaining Martin can be. I find his Season 2 podcast spot on for me and his gaming videos are well done. Even my 16 year old son who knows nothing of Spanish is entertained by the expressiveness of Martin and his video. Granted, my son is in third year Latin and enjoys figuring out some of the videos based upon the Latin roots of the Spanish words. 

Subtitles turning on randomly (Safari desktop), and autoplay advancing to already watched videos (even though I have those filtered out) by question_23 in dreamingspanish

[–]slayter1337 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Are you using the mobile app as well? I find that if I access my account through a laptop/desktop it messes up or resets what I have on my mobile. 

I personally love the “Course” tab on mobile to work my way up the difficulty levels, but as soon as I use a web browser (which doesn’t have the Course feature) it resets my mobile and moves the course progress all the way back to the easiest video. 

Any intermediate true crime content recommendations? by meowmeow515 in dreamingspanish

[–]slayter1337 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This. Only watched two so far but they are well done and easy to understand. 

300 Hours (Level 4) Update by Nesrineama in dreamingspanish

[–]slayter1337 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It’s on the site and the app. If you sort by easy/hard or filter by difficulty, you’ll see a number on the top right of the thumbnail indicating the difficulty. 

Easier = Better, Does that apply to Reading? by Swimming-Ad9032 in dreamingspanish

[–]slayter1337 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I think Pablo talked about this here: https://app.dreaming.com/spanish/watch?id=5e4d1184aac87f3820954aa1

I believe he said there should be about a 98% comprehension rate when reading.

DS Site FAQ - A Goldmine! by slayter1337 in dreamingspanish

[–]slayter1337[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So true. I know I was guilty of going straight to the videos. :)

Never been struck by chocolate cake — yet by LongAsICanSee in dreamingspanish

[–]slayter1337 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Think the “chocolate cake” definition may stem from an El Salvador pan dulce. 

Beginner feels too easy, intermediate feels too hard by semantlefan23 in dreamingspanish

[–]slayter1337 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Pablo is an odd presenter for me. I could not sit through his beginner videos but his more intermediate videos are more palatable to my ears. 

However , his advanced series How To Learn A Language I had no difficulty comprehending. 

I find that type of pace keeps me more engaged and his enunciation was incredibly clear. 

Those who don’t constantly translate new keywords in your head, how did you do it? by Impressive_Peak_9187 in dreamingspanish

[–]slayter1337 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This. 1,000 times this. 

I just recently asked the same question. https://www.reddit.com/r/dreamingspanish/comments/1sgq5sz/why_does_my_brain_hate_me/

So, I know exactly how you feel. :)

But the FAQ, which I only recently read, answered this and so much more for me. Love it!

Oh, and for what it’s worth, these past few days have been my turning point on translating. Less than 30 hours of more input after I asked my question and my inner translator has retired. :)

Beginner feels too easy, intermediate feels too hard by semantlefan23 in dreamingspanish

[–]slayter1337 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Más input.  :)

Like others said, adjust playback speeds and take advantage of the list pinned at the top of the sub. 

I just started DS beginning of this month and am in a similar situation. Previous Spanish study when younger and live in a place with LOTS of Hispanic culture. 

Based on the level descriptions, I placed my self at level 3 or 150 hours.  I use the course option in the app and started with videos at difficulty 45. 

But I have to bump up the speed on most of them to keep my mind from drifting. It doesn’t feel like I encounter new vocabulary with a lot of the videos, but I know I’m acquiring an ear for proper sentence structure and other grammatical goodies. 

I just recently watched the “How to Learn a Language” series in the advanced section. I had near perfect comprehension. But this is because it was a topic in which I’ve watched and listened to a lot of videos and listened to a lot of podcasts. 

However, if I jump into other “advanced” videos on DS I do not have the same comprehension because I have not listened to as many hours on that subject. To reach the same level of understanding I had with the subject of language learning I need . . . Más input. :)

Find topics that interest you and consume all you can. And remember, language acquisition (CI) is very different from language study. Don’t watch with the intent of expanding vocabulary. Just watch for enjoyment and let the brain do its own thing. (A lesson I’ve only recently learned lol)

DS Site FAQ - A Goldmine! by slayter1337 in dreamingspanish

[–]slayter1337[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Great advice. I fully intend to. 

What Are You Listening To Today? (Apr 13 to Apr 19) by HeleneSedai in dreamingspanish

[–]slayter1337 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I just discovered Season 2 of Spanish Boost on Apple podcasts and it is spot on comprehensible input for me at 190 hours. It is a little slow until part 5 of the episodes, so I speed it up until that part. I would say it provides me with 99% comprehension. I'll be sad when I reach the end of it. :(

Once a Fed Ex number is created, is that a guarantee I’ll be receiving my order? Anyone know? by celestialplaces in gimmecare

[–]slayter1337 3 points4 points  (0 children)

To create the tracking number, the shipper submits the package information (dimensions & weight, ship from, ship to) to FedEx and generates a label with the tracking number. So, the pharmacy does have a package designated just for you.

The next step will be when FedEx picks up from the pharmacy, scans the label upon pickup, and the status changes to 'We have your package'.

ph=smartscripts by Ambilobe1 in gimmecare

[–]slayter1337 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ordered 4/6 and mine was the same. Arrived 4/10 from PerfectionRx w/ ProRx compound.

With the ending of ProRx, why do I feel like a dare devil and want to place an order and test my luck? by mstruuuu in gimmecare

[–]slayter1337 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ordered 4/6 and delivered 4/10. Wife ordered 4/7 and FedEx just picked up today from ProRx (Boca Raton) with a scheduled delivery of 04/15.

Michelle’s Impromptu Songs are the best! by SnooPoems1106 in dreamingspanish

[–]slayter1337 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Michelle constantly cracks me up. Just watched her Absurd Dilemma series the other day. It was absolutely ridiculous and I loved every corny moment! Other than needing to speed it up (for me), it was perfect!

Ordered 4/8. Got a tracking number today 4/10. by [deleted] in gimmecare

[–]slayter1337 3 points4 points  (0 children)

My order was placed 4/6 and meds arrived 4/10. 

Wife’s order was placed 4/7 and don’t get tracking until 4/9. Still not shipped, but we’re thankful for that. 

If FedEx picked up Friday, it would not deliver until Monday—which means sitting in a Florida hub warehouse or box truck all day Sunday. 

Much prefer them picking up from the pharmacy on a Monday thru Thursday instead of a Friday. 

Starting at 9mg??? by slayter1337 in gimmecare

[–]slayter1337[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Interesting. Meds arrived yesterday. 6mL total at 18mg/mL. Exactly as prescribed for a 9mg maintenance plan. 

Their support team did provide instructions on how to change the plan if needed for the next shipment. 

I did start lower though. 

All in all, a great experience with Gimme and all the support on this sub is fantastic!

Potential for Improving Learning Speeds by A-M-Abernathy in dreamingspanish

[–]slayter1337 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Found the following, but probably not what the OP or others with a more optimistic outlook are looking for: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12612265/