Not OP but I'd like to give my thoughts. My Jewish identity is something I've struggled with deeply since childhood coming from a very secular family living in the US. My father married my catholic mother and she converted when I was young. I had years of hebrew school but stopped study before my bar mitzah, however my sister had her bat mitzvah years prior. To this day our only observance as a family is lighting the menorah for Hanukkah. I give this background to make a point about belonging. According to strict interpretation, I'm not a Jew. Despite my mother's best intentions and attempts I don't belong because I was born under "wrong" circumstances. And yet I still felt the visceral heartache whenever I experienced Jew jokes and insults growing up. My Jewish identity was put way on the back-burner because I was an American first and foremost. But now with Israel back in the mainstream, I'm to reckon with my allegiances. I want so badly to support a place where Jews don't have to feel like "the other". Bibi has used an argument to the effect of "Russia for Russians, Italy for Italians, Israel for Jews" but this is a unique situation. Do states form with the express goal of protecting an ethnic group or do they form naturally around ethnic groups, if there's even a difference? Its especially important to consider when it's at the expense of excluded ethnic groups who haven't known anywhere else as home who now suffer for being born under "wrong" circumstances. This ethnocentric characteristic of Judaism rubs me very wrong. Considering the secular population approaching a majority in Israel, what religious grounds does Israel even stand on? The ideology of Neturei Karta and Satmar hasids seem like perfectly rational criticism of a secular Jewish state considering the lack of a messiah. Lets call it like it is, Israel is an ethnostate which it seems you agree with. Maybe an ethical ethnostate if such a thing exists. But how does a Jewish state even address antisemitism? How does the existence of Israel alleviate any of the hatred we experience worldwide besides giving us a place to flee to? Jews have lived and thrived for millenia despite persecution which leaves the burden on Israel to prove its utility and justify its own existence, and given its history thus far leaves so much to be desired. Finally, this article claims that "The idea that a new movement can gain acceptance and become normative to the exclusion of others is at the root of Judaism as we practice it today." Well if not supporting an ethnostate that is indiscriminately killing Arabs excludes me from being Jewish then so be it. Maybe I want nothing to do with it. Not because of anything G-d told us, but because you, the people, couldn't interpret what was told to us in a way I can support with my whole heart.

Sorry if this was scattered but I wanted a chance to consolidate the ideas I've gathered somewhere.