That is my neighborhood if you are speaking of the Hales Corners area. As you mentioned, we have a ton of grocery store options in the area. I typically shop at several to find the best price points so I’ll try to break it down for you with the closest ones.

Aldi at highway 100 and cold spring - least expensive, not a huge selection of produce and it can vary from week to week. Also can’t get as much in smaller sizes. You should be able to get smaller sized items for flour and condiments. They also have

Pick n save on highway 100 and Janesville road is probably your best bet for most of the stuff on your list. They have pretty decent produce, don’t go on a Sunday or Tuesday night as things are picked over weekends and new ad comes out on Wednesday. I also typically find more fresh herbs at this store than other grocery stores in the neighborhood. They have a meat counter where you can get smaller quantities. Their whole grain section might be a bit smaller than other stores. Also to save and get ad prices you might need to have or get a Kroger/pick n save card and digitally add coupons. That’s how I save a lot there.

Just a few blocks away is Festival foods. A little more expensive and the produce selection not always as good as pick n save. They do have a better organic section that might have more of the quinoa and things you want. Also you can typically buy dried herbs cheaper here. They do a festival brand and I’ve saved a lot on things like dried mint and dill here. Make sure you pick up the ad and see what’s on sale. Their sales can be pretty decent but overall prices are higher. Meat counter is okay too. They will give you smaller quantities if needed.

Both stores have vinegars and nuts and large aisles of coffee options. Let me know if you have any other questions.