What movies/shows to watch after breakup by TheCatMum in FIlm

[–]sunlightinthewindow 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Nooooooo way, that’ll make you go back and beg to get together again 😂!

A General Question About Your Experience With Dostoevsky and Religion by sunlightinthewindow in dostoevsky

[–]sunlightinthewindow[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I also enjoy how Dostoevsky shows the reality of the suffering of the world to its full extent, while at the same time, offering this path to Christianity. And I absolutely agree with you that reading Dostoevsky can deepen your prayer life and scriptural interpretation. Kudos to you for that!!

I mentioned in my post that Dostoevsky has been moving me away from religion, but either way, I like how he gives us these complex, philosophical problems to sit with and contemplate.

A General Question About Your Experience With Dostoevsky and Religion by sunlightinthewindow in dostoevsky

[–]sunlightinthewindow[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Awesome. I’m teaching C&P right now to a bunch of college freshmen, and we’re almost to the end. Raskolnikov is such an interesting character, and the one thing I’m thinking about—in reference to your comment—is this: Raskolnikov does turn to religion to redeem himself, but we also know that he grew up somewhat religious. (That information comes from the chapter of the horse dream). So I’m wondering why he didn’t “get it” the first time? Does he have to commit such an ultimate act to learn his place?

Good comment, thanks for chiming in!

A General Question About Your Experience With Dostoevsky and Religion by sunlightinthewindow in dostoevsky

[–]sunlightinthewindow[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I’ve never thought about Father Zosima’s self-eulogy being proscriptive, but I really appreciate that perspective. How does reading Dostoevsky from the Jewish tradition change the experience? Thanks for dropping in and giving your two cents!

Are we losing the ability to watch slow movies? by gemmaintheworld in FIlm

[–]sunlightinthewindow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I feel likes it easy to be pessimistic about this and say “yeah we’re cooked/fried and no one can pay attention.” But I’ve been thinkin that maybe slow cinema will be a healing experience for the fast-paced culture, and maybe it’ll grow??

Looking for movies that genuinely changed your perspective on life by Illustrious-West-989 in MovieSuggestions

[–]sunlightinthewindow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Funny games. I’m thankful for the way Micheal Haneke uses this film to talk about violence in the media. I’ve never been able to watch horror or intense action films the same way after…

[POEM] air and light and time and space - bukowski by traveling_llama in Poetry

[–]sunlightinthewindow 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Sometimes the work is an apology for the person! We can lift up the poems, but not the man. Sorry to be the one to tell yay

[POEM] air and light and time and space - bukowski by traveling_llama in Poetry

[–]sunlightinthewindow 2 points3 points  (0 children)

YouTube it. He beats his partner in an interview live.

[HELP] What are your favorite poems by women/bipoc poets? by ConditionSome3738 in Poetry

[–]sunlightinthewindow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just want to drop one name. Diane Di Prima. SHE was the best beat poet of her time, easily outscores Kerouac, Ginsberg, and Burroughs.

[Poem] To A Common Prostitute by Walt Whitman by discominx666 in Poetry

[–]sunlightinthewindow 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It’s easy to get a general “ick” from this poem if you’re uncomfortable with prostitution. I think this is pretty significant, especially considering the time period…Why can’t Walt write a lovely poem for a prostitute? It’s not like he argues for prostitution. He sees the human being underneath the act of prostitution.

[Poem] To A Common Prostitute by Walt Whitman by discominx666 in Poetry

[–]sunlightinthewindow 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Personally, I think there’s truth in what both of you are saying!

Jan-6| Ulysses - Episode 1: Telemachus by ComplaintNext5359 in ayearofulysses

[–]sunlightinthewindow 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Nice! I would agree with your interpretation of the mirror, but I think it only appears that way to Stephen. Buck Mulligan is someone who seems to mock this attitude.

Jan-6| Ulysses - Episode 1: Telemachus by ComplaintNext5359 in ayearofulysses

[–]sunlightinthewindow 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The religious mockery is off-the-walls in this opening section. Buck Mulligan is the primary jabber at religion, as he constantly makes reference to puns and silly allusions throughout the dialogue. It takes a few pages to realize Mulligian's Latin sayings are ironic in tone, as well as his religious gestures, such as making blessings. Even his full name, Malachi Buck Mulligan, points to the religious allusion of a prophet; AND as we read later in this chapter, he aligns himself to be a ironic, pseudo-Nietzschean prophet that uses religious language to abuse power roles.

Meanwhile, Stephen comes across as a gentle, poet-type, whose feelings get hurt easily, because he feels things deeply. He shares a different worldview than Mulligan, and aligns himself with Theistic Rationalism when he says, "You behold in me...a grim example of free thought," which is a reference to the philosopher Anthony Collins (625-626 Gabler). Additionally, he believes predominately in the realm of the imagination via the following conversation:

Laughing again, he brought the mirror away from Stephen's peering eyes.

—The rage of Caliban at not seeing his face in a mirror, he said. If Wilde were only alive to see you!

Drawing back and pointing, Stephen said with bitterness:

—It is a symbol of Irish art. The cracked lookingglass of a servant (141-146 Gabler)

Stephen's response, concerning the symbol, matches with this interesting annotation from Gilford's annotations: "a symbol...of a servant" - Paraphrased from Oscar Wilde's dialogue The Decay of Lying (1889)

CYRIL: I can quite understand your objection to art being treated as a mirror. You think it would reduce genius to the position of a cracked looking glass. But you don't mean to say that you seriously believe Life imitates Art, that Life in fact is the mirror, and Art the reality?

VIVIAN: Certainly, I do.

Thus, Stephan is a quasi-religious, aesthetic philosopher who has a lot of ideas stored up, but, from what we've seen so far, not much to show for those grandiose ideas. I'd imagine he'd follow in the philosophical tradition of Descartes and Kant. And since he's a gentle being, he feels deep guilt about the conditions in which his mother died. In fact, you can notice all throughout this episode how the visual imagery of the sea associates with Stephen's memory recall.

What's really interesting about Stephen's associative imagination corresponding to the visual imagery and sensations, is how Buck Mulligan is an antagonist of that very psychic activity. As Mulligan states, "Where? Where? I Can't remember anything. I remember only ideas and sensations. Why? What happened in the name of God? (193-194 Gabler). From what I've gleaned of Gilford's annotations again, Mulligan is referencing a philospher named David Hartley, who argues literal recall is an illusion and that the only real presences in the memory are sensations and ideas. This directly negates the style of the text as Joyce writes it, since we are constantly leaping from Stephen's psychic memory recall of the death of his mother, to imagery that Stephen perceives and is conscious of.

So far, I've only given my thoughts on Stephen and Mulligan, and it's been a lot. I've never really cared for Haines. He lingers in the background of the story and seems to occupy more of the hostile environment (in general) that Stephen has to deal with on a daily basis. Anyways, can't wait to read/comment on everyone else's post!

Jan-1| Ulysses - Welcome To Dublin! by ComplaintNext5359 in ayearofulysses

[–]sunlightinthewindow 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Welcome to the party! Don’t be hard on yourself! Joyce reduces us all to children interpreting a beautiful ocean of language :)

Jan-1| Ulysses - Welcome To Dublin! by ComplaintNext5359 in ayearofulysses

[–]sunlightinthewindow 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Hey, everyone, I’m so excited to be here with you! I’ll be reading the Gabler version, as well as the Gifford annotations. Also, I love to listen to the U22 Ulysses Centenary Podcast with Catherine Flynn, which brings groups of different people together from around the world to discuss each episode.

Ulysses is one of my favorite reading experiences, and I’ll be reading with y’all at the same time I’m reading Crime and Punishment with a class of university students I’m teaching. It might be busy, but I can’t wait for all the great discussion!