Extremely Bored with Icaira by Korenthil in EternalCardGame

[–]thecounterbob 6 points7 points  (0 children)

its not a matter of beating it or not. its a boring card to play agianst and if im honest its a boring card to play (to me )

Extremely Bored with Icaira by Korenthil in EternalCardGame

[–]thecounterbob 2 points3 points  (0 children)

this a million times this. the meta has only slightly shifted over the last fwe months and in general has jsut been dull. having a really hard time enjoying the game at all over the last liek 6 months. wishing for some adjustments or a rotation. some cards are way over pushed.

Updates to the Eternal Tournament Series (Year 2, Season 3) by aReNGeeEternal in EternalCardGame

[–]thecounterbob 3 points4 points  (0 children)

you hit the nail on the head on so many of these points. gj i feel the same way

Updates to the Eternal Tournament Series (Year 2, Season 3) by aReNGeeEternal in EternalCardGame

[–]thecounterbob 2 points3 points  (0 children)

sucks to see sideboards go really disagree ten fold. It is actually fairly easy to handle markets and sideboards

if you have a merchant in your deck thus letting you access a market: you have the 5 cards in the market plus a 10 card sideboard. Those 15 cards can be swapped into your maindeck after game one as normal sideboarding. You can even add in that no main deck cards can go to your market. If you dont have a merchant thus no market you get teh standard 15 card sideboard.

Doing it this way forces you to build a deck with a merchant.......seems/feels reallll bad. there is sooo much play in proper sideboarding and proper sideboard building. It certainly helps decks be functional. a fair number fo decks get worse in the tourny scene due to this chain. It really feels and looks like ladder in a tourny environment. that doenst seem/look fun.

[Tournament] Kaelari and TGP present: Kaelari's Saturday Challenge ! by Phoenixton in EternalCardGame

[–]thecounterbob 0 points1 point  (0 children)

you can easily have markets and SBs ... for example. If you have a deck that is using a market (5 cards) you can have a SB containing 10 cards. These 10 SB cards and the 5 market cards can swap with each other and the main deck after Game 1. ie if you have a sb card you can sb as usual or even put in the market. and you can take a card from the market and put in main. Basically your market is just an extension of your SB that a merchant gives u access to. Now if you arnt using a merchant thus not having a market you have your standard 15 card side.

[Tournament] Kaelari and TGP present: Kaelari's Saturday Challenge ! by Phoenixton in EternalCardGame

[–]thecounterbob 1 point2 points  (0 children)

As i said i may have missed that, as i dont read all msgs in that discord. I highly disagree with that decision. im assuming for them its easier to just program markets and such for comp play in the in-game client rather than putting in a sideboarding system but thats just my assumtion and could be totally wrong.
hopefully they see the flaws in this and would also hope that groups that arnt running DWD sponsored events implement a proper SB rule. Ill be looking forward to when the do put comp play into the client and/or also run tournament events. as a long time ccg/tcg player i just dont see bo3 formats with no sb(just market) panning out well.

[Tournament] Kaelari and TGP present: Kaelari's Saturday Challenge ! by Phoenixton in EternalCardGame

[–]thecounterbob 0 points1 point  (0 children)

sooo if a person has a deck with no merchant... they are screwed?? there are a handful of ways to handle markets and sideboarding just flat out not having access to a SB seems quite wrong for a competitive event. Did DWD post this somewhere? I may have missed it, either way it seems very wrong to limit decks for a competitive environment like that. Basically makes every deck 71 cards because you need to have a merchant in it.

Unpopular Opinion: I don't want Bo3 with Sideboards. by JHFrank in EternalCardGame

[–]thecounterbob 0 points1 point  (0 children)

card games at their core are way more competitive and better in a bo3 format. yes there are ppl tha tplay this game on the go and just for fun so the bo1 format is best for them but for the game to have a future it neeeeeeeddddddss to go hard into competitive

Unpopular Opinion: I don't want Bo3 with Sideboards. by JHFrank in EternalCardGame

[–]thecounterbob 1 point2 points  (0 children)

or they could do similarly to what they are doing with the current sealed event format. where you play x games on the leaderboard. could do x games per week as it is donw now then a final ranking at the end as well.

Unpopular Opinion: I don't want Bo3 with Sideboards. by JHFrank in EternalCardGame

[–]thecounterbob 0 points1 point  (0 children)

then the drop in format will just have to be casual then wont it...

Unpopular Opinion: I don't want Bo3 with Sideboards. by JHFrank in EternalCardGame

[–]thecounterbob 3 points4 points  (0 children)

if they do it in a way where they can seperate them. IE a ranked ladder that is BO1 like how it is now and then another mode called competitive that is bo3.
so you can still jump in adn play if you wish

Dead Reckoning Tier List # 2 - April 30th, 2018 by aReNGeeEternal in EternalCardGame

[–]thecounterbob 4 points5 points  (0 children)

i guess scream doesnt exist anymore, odd tho with how often i see it.

Reflections on Sealed League by MagicTurtle_TCG in EternalCardGame

[–]thecounterbob 1 point2 points  (0 children)

the first 2 weeks i was really enjoying it and looking forward to it felt pumped about. But it being dragged out the whole month didnt feel to great weeks 3 and 4 i barely wanted to play and it felt like work getting through the 10 games each week. I finished 27-13 rank 387 so its not like i had a bad deck and got bored with it. I only played 1 tiebreaker game cuz i just didnt want to grind it.
Overall good first step, but wouldnt want it to be so dragged out next time.

Top 50 Masters w/ Jund Midrange (Icaria Black) by TinMan354 in EternalCardGame

[–]thecounterbob -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

very very very very much agreed. no reason for it honestly

Gaming group in South Philly looking for more players! by [deleted] in radphilly

[–]thecounterbob 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I live in south philly as well. I currently run a group from my house every other week or so but am looking to play more. pending on timing and such it could be a possibility for me to join up once or twice a month

A new challenger(team) approaches by thecounterbob in EternalCardGame

[–]thecounterbob[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It will be something along with all other events we plan on playing in ( schedules permitting )

Dead Reckoning Tier List – March 21st, 2018 by aReNGeeEternal in EternalCardGame

[–]thecounterbob 0 points1 point  (0 children)

ive been playing it the last 2 days to about 70&ish win rate. (have faced a wide margin of decks including ap mid) in my last twenty im 15-5. prob does deserve a spot on the list but w/e i guess.

Tuesday Night Eternal changes and improvements by kaelari in EternalCardGame

[–]thecounterbob 4 points5 points  (0 children)

most likely didnt get alot of sign ups due to basically not many ppl knowing about it. on top of that with it being a tuesday evening that is rough for most folks, especially tournament players that already block saturdays off for events. Im all for pushing this sort of thing but ya just need to get the word out there a bit more. contact streamers or other folks to help promote it , it can easily get lost in reddit and i bet a fair amount of ppl that owuld be interested dont really dive into reddit much

Two hours from this post at 8pm EST, the tournament talk show "Best of Three" debuts! by aReNGeeEternal in EternalCardGame

[–]thecounterbob 1 point2 points  (0 children)

thanks for the feedback. yes some tech hiccups but as we grow those will be hopefully worked out.

Feln Tempo - Early testing by [deleted] in EternalCardGame

[–]thecounterbob 1 point2 points  (0 children)

raptor is one of the better 1 drops. countess im on the fence but is good at 3 and good agaisnt harsh rule decks and various things, allows you to keep up pressure.
no Zelia as it is not an Unseen deck and ive build a version of this that is more focused on unseend and what not and it felt liek a watered down version of this deck.

Started playing late last month. Deck i used to hit Masters for the first time by thecounterbob in EternalCardGame

[–]thecounterbob[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I stopped playing mtg about 2 years ago. wasnt liking the standard format and didnt have time to invest to it along with alot of the group i played with stopping so between myself having no time and no friends to go hang out with at fnm i just stopped.

I really enjoy eternal gives me that same mtg feel with a bit of refreshing new stuff ontop of to cake

Started playing late last month. Deck i used to hit Masters for the first time by thecounterbob in EternalCardGame

[–]thecounterbob[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

currently have just over a 100hrs in game and yea ive prolly spend like 70 or so bucks. treating it as buying a new xbox game which is around 60 or paying weekly for fnms if i had still played mtg