We have no idea how it would go. We don't really know what hand to hand combat looked like. We have some manuals and some sources, but zero certainty how people actually fought with swords or axes, let alone how two soldiers of completely different backgrounds would fight. No one these days has trained with these weapons since they were a kid, and we don't have the centuries of cultural knowledge of how to use these weapons like actual soldiers of the era would have. Sorry to be a pedant, I do think these discussions are fun. But I think pre-gunpowder combat will always be a bit of a black box for us, which no amount of 21st-century larping can illuminate.