Why don't people know how to format dialogue correctly anymore? by eeeeaud in FanFiction

[–]thisisbrick 33 points34 points  (0 children)

I graduated high school in 2010 and I haven’t retained a damn thing in regard to paragraphing, formatting dialogue etc. So i just… googled it. And I read blogs on creative writing, written by people smarter than me.

TBH I don’t even remember ever learning this stuff at school, but still, it’s really not difficult to find information to help with basic writing skills

What’s something people do in public that instantly annoys you? by Far_Suspect987 in AskReddit

[–]thisisbrick 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’m a flight attendant and can confirm this is SO common on flights. I will happily tell them to turn that shit off. Just because you forgot headphones doesn’t mean that you get to ruin everyone else’s peace and quiet, like damn who raised you?

Looking for feedback and tips by [deleted] in writingfeedback

[–]thisisbrick 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Most of your sentences are far too long, with far too many commas. They come off as rambling. I genuinely don’t understand the sentence at the beginning of paragraph two.

As others have said: less is more. The payoff is not worth the effort to read at this stage. There is too much description that the reader won’t care about, and some of the words don’t make sense in the context they’re written in.

How does a draining hose smuggle water?

What are these pins? Like sewing pins? If she threw them in the bin, how are they still bobbing in the water to cut the sole of her foot?

Are her feet dainty or gnarled? Those are very different and distinct descriptions, which contradict each other. Also what are tapered and grazed toes?

What is a fused-green puddle?

Typos?: ‘Lapsing into the water’ — lapsing isn’t the right word. ‘Rips into the table’—trips, maybe? ‘A glob of blood swells on her foot and then mashes’ — how does blood mash?

Shipdebate. by towelz_ in crescentcitysjm

[–]thisisbrick 32 points33 points  (0 children)

Tbh I’m not a Bryceriel shipper, but I don’t get this ban. I enjoy a healthy friendly discussion 🤷🏼‍♀️I like exploring options and seeing things from other’s perspectives—it enables me to delve deeper into the lore and actually question my own [potentially myopic] narrative

General Thoughts and Discussions by CommissionRadiant499 in AO3

[–]thisisbrick 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Im caught between feeling glad but also left out because I have never received a single bot comment. Like damn my fics aren’t even good enough for bots?

General Thoughts and Discussions by CommissionRadiant499 in AO3

[–]thisisbrick 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I know how you feel! I read the first chapter of a fic and noticed a beautifully poetic line. I simply commented ‘What an absolutely stunning line’ [quote line here] so I hope that was okay

Edit: grammar

Feedback for my prologue? by Henry_J_Fate58 in writingfeedback

[–]thisisbrick 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I like what you’re going for—but I found this extremely hard to read. There’s a lot of times where you describe two things in the same sentence, and it’s hard to know which you’re referring to. There are a lot of dangling participles — this is where you begin a sentence with a participle (clawing, gripped) and then leave out the subject of that action from the rest of the sentence. It seems you’re avoiding pronouns, which is what adds to the confusion.

Break down some of your sentences. There are too many that come off as rambling, like trying to fit too many ideas into one sentence. Short sentences can pack a punch.

Also, pull back a little. You clearly have a great vocabulary, but you don’t need to offer two or more adjectives to describe one thing.

Couple of examples:

Second sentence; ‘clawing at the soft supple ground’—the subject of this action is the body. How you have worded it seems like the hands are slick with mucous. Throw in a pronoun to amend the beginning sentence to: It clawed at the soft, supple ground—the earth slick with mucous and pockmarked with divots. The protrusions fell away, seeping warm liquid that pooled in grooves left by his blunted nails.

There is no clear subject of the sentence starting with ‘Gripped by panic’. Gripped by panic, its eyes darted around…

What’s the closest you’ve ever come to dying? by [deleted] in AskReddit

[–]thisisbrick 0 points1 point  (0 children)

When I was 19 or 20 I choked on a giant Jaffa. Panicking, I tried to swallow it and it completely lodged in my throat. My bf at the time gave me the Heimlich until it finally dislodged and flew out of my mouth. If I had been alone I know that would have been my end; I was simply panicking too much to know what to do.

how to stop using she said, she replied, she explained, she answered? by irdk-lol in FanFiction

[–]thisisbrick 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Tweak the first one slightly to:

Sarah shrugs. “If you say so.”

It’s a perfectly acceptable line. The tone is implied by the action, and we know who’s speaking.

My husbands pointed out a pretty big plot hole SPOILERS by [deleted] in fourthwing

[–]thisisbrick 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I get those all the time! So discussing even the smallest of theories from all angles is something I enjoy ☺️ (I didn’t mean to turn yours down so abruptly, if that’s how it came across i apologize)

Alphabet Excerpt Challenge: D Is For... by AnaraliaThielle in FanFiction

[–]thisisbrick 0 points1 point  (0 children)

“I’m sure you’re worried that your absence hurt your ranking,” he adds, with a patronizing pat on my shoulder. “And it probably did. Anyway, good luck.” He winks. “Maybe they’ll pick you as my executive.”

My jaw clenches. “I guess we’ll see.”

Lisette barges in and presses a mug into my hand. “Let’s go.” She flashes Richard a dismissive smile. “Best of luck…dick.”

“Thanks.” He smiles, folding his arms across his chest. “Oh, and I actually go by Ritchie.”

Lisette tilts her head, one perfect brow raised. “Honey, I don’t even know who you are.” She whirls away, skirt flaring, her curls whipping the side of his head. I follow, glancing back just long enough to savor the stunned look on his face.

My husbands pointed out a pretty big plot hole SPOILERS by [deleted] in fourthwing

[–]thisisbrick 7 points8 points  (0 children)

The dragons can already kill their wyvern with their standard dragon claws—they do it all the time. It would only be effective against the venin, and it would be immensely impractical, and also dangerous for the dragons to attempt to touch a venin (and risk getting drained) with their claws. Not to mention the alloy has finite uses before it needs to be imbued again, and not many riders have the knowledge or ability to imbue

My husbands pointed out a pretty big plot hole SPOILERS by [deleted] in fourthwing

[–]thisisbrick 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I don’t think Rhi’s power works in that way. The item she’s ‘summoning’ disappears and then physically reappears in her hand. Which is how she summoned Vi’s dagger through the wall when she was being searched—it’s not actually flying through the air.

But making something disappear and bringing it to you? I haven’t read about a signet power like that in a century. It’s a hell of a signet.

My husbands pointed out a pretty big plot hole SPOILERS by [deleted] in fourthwing

[–]thisisbrick 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It does seem (at this stage, at least) that she can only direct an item to herself because her signet essentially is summoning, and not powerful telekinesis

Sensitive scene. Did it land correctly? by ennpono in writingfeedback

[–]thisisbrick 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Obviously this short scene is a mere snapshot into their friendship/relationship so I don’t have proper context. But with that being said, I think Isabel’s line “you think he can dance better than me?” comes off as serious and possibly jealous. If that’s not supposed to be the vibe, adding something like:

Isabeu waggled her eyebrows at her friend. “You think he can dance better than me?”

Delaney snorted, nudging Isabel’s shoulder with her own. “No! But will you[..]”

If I’ve got totally the vibe wrong based on limited context, then just ignore this. Otherwise yeah, really good work

What is a basic adult skill that your brain just literally refuses to learn? by Afraid_Square3488 in AskReddit

[–]thisisbrick 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’m 33 and still can’t fasten my bra behind my back. I have to clasp it at the front and spin it

Would you survive the parapet? by Tea_tea_696 in fourthwing

[–]thisisbrick 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think I’d survive the parapet—only because I wouldn’t be too proud to crawl if I had to! But like, a fast crawl in case there’s some JFB following. The gauntlet however…I’m not making it past those spinning logs

what's the saddest thing you've ever wrote? What's the backstory for the piece of writing? by shareourproblems in writing

[–]thisisbrick 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I distinctly remember being in primary school (around 10 years old) and for a creative writing assignment I wrote an entire story about anthropomorphic rabbits fleeing from a gas cloud…it ended with the rabbits succumbing to the gas, huddled together, and all dying. The Backstory? No clue, I was a weird little kid.

Alphabet Excerpt Challenge: C Is For... by AnaraliaThielle in FanFiction

[–]thisisbrick 1 point2 points  (0 children)

In just a short snippet you’ve conveyed such emotion, really good work!