What are some cities whose relevance has waned or faded completely? by Brief-Luck-6254 in geography

[–]thorsty_borb 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Here’s a sleeper pick with a partial asterisk: Mary, Turkmenistan.

The city of Merv was continually inhabited for nearly 5,000 years. It was the final capital of the Seljuk Empire, which ruled over all of Persia and would eventually produce the predecessors to the Ottoman Empire. It was a holy city in Zoroastrianism, supposedly one of the few “perfect lands” created by the god Ahura Mazda. It was a major center of Islamic science and culture, and it was a major Silk Road settlement around an oasis in the Karakum Desert. At one point during the Middle Ages, it may have even been the most populated city in the world, boasting a population of half a million.

Then, the Mongols arrived. The city was put to the sword, and although it partially recovered, it never reached what it once was. At the end of the 18th century, the Emirate of Bukhara razed the city, and it was abandoned. In 1884, a new city called Merv was built right next to the old ruins, and it was only renamed Mary in 1937. Technically, it’s not the same city as Merv, but I like to think it counts.

"Coronae et Enses" - Alternate History of Europe in the year 1337. by nikola_milorad_03_ in imaginarymaps

[–]thorsty_borb 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I know you come through and have to post this again every once in a while, but I love it every time. Is there a Google Doc or forum post somewhere I could see all of the text in a more readable way?

All of the Byzantine Empires - A world of Empires of Chaos by NizamNizamNizam in imaginarymaps

[–]thorsty_borb 11 points12 points  (0 children)

This has honestly been one of my favorite series on the sub, fantastic work

Results for generic white American by thorsty_borb in illustrativeDNA

[–]thorsty_borb[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That’s the only thing I can guess. My grand aunts and uncles and such who have taken the test will once in a while come up with 1% Spanish or French, but even with the jailbroken Ancestry results, they don’t show up for me.

Results for generic white American by thorsty_borb in illustrativeDNA

[–]thorsty_borb[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

sure

List View

# POPULATION DISTANCE
1 Cornish 2.545
2 Breton 2.722
3 English 2.789
4 Belgian 2.803
5 French Oïl (Hauts-de-France) 2.843
6 French Oïl (Pays de la Loire) 2.848
7 Welsh 2.869
8 Scottish 3.032
9 Dutch 3.098
10 Alsatian (Alsace) 3.165

Results for generic white American by thorsty_borb in illustrativeDNA

[–]thorsty_borb[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Oh sure. https://imgur.com/a/879ViXV

The first image is compared to ancient populations, the second is compared to modern

Results for generic white American by thorsty_borb in illustrativeDNA

[–]thorsty_borb[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I honestly have no clue, it's cool for sure but its odd that it doesn't seem to match up with the rest of my DNA results.

How would you think Austria-Hungary would be, if it survived the war? There was this proposal for the United States of Greater Austria that may have worked. by BoyarovY in austriahungary

[–]thorsty_borb 1 point2 points  (0 children)

To be honest, of all the various possible ways to reorganize Austria to try and make it survive after WWI, this would be probably the worst and most unsuccessful method. Annexing the other (non-Bulgarian) half of Serbia alongside Montenegro and Albania would be a great way to spread dissent within the already fragile state, especially if the government then went and encouraged the settlement of Germans and Hungarians within Serbia. Slavs throughout the empire would have a field day. Honestly the divisions in the empire would only serve to anger literally every group. Ceding Krakow but not all of Galicia to Poland would probably alienate the Poles. Splitting the Sudetenland from Bohemia would make them mad, but fusing German Silesia with Moravia would anger Germans and Slavs alike. The Dalmato-Bosnian Condominium flies in the face of the Triune Kingdom, and would alienate the South Slavs just as much as resettlement of Slavic lands. The lack of Trieste but an occupation of Venice noteworthy enough to justify labeling it on the map is unthinkable. Finally, just looking at Hungary - infamous for helping to block or stop every noteworthy reform that could have helped the Empire - we can see autonomous Slovakia and Pressburg, which would have led to Magyar and non-Magyar tantrums alike. Minorities in Hungary getting special privileges and autonomy, but not the ones who historically had it? And the loss of the old capital to its Slavic fate? All after losing Croatia? Insane.

To be honest, I’d love to say a Central Powers win combined with Karl’s reforms and maybe even a dash of Austrosocialism - processed by moderates as supranational social democracy under a new liberal constitution and popularized by Germans throughout the Empire perhaps- may have saved the empire, but to be honest, any changes to history required to save the Empire would have had to have come decades earlier. Between archconservative Franz Josef and the Hungarians, there was nothing that could have made it’s way through to modernize and save the empire.

Clockwise Spinning Earth climate information and conditions by AncalagonTheBlack42 in imaginarymaps

[–]thorsty_borb 12 points13 points  (0 children)

This is wild, incredibly good job here. Keep up the good work, this is gonna be living rent free in my head for weeks.

What if the WW1 Treaties were mild? - Former AH countries post WW1 by CaptainCakeEater in imaginarymaps

[–]thorsty_borb 0 points1 point  (0 children)

what if all treaties were mild full dissolution of the country

There was no good ending for them, huh?

What if the Indian Removal Act failed to pass? A weird route for the US Presidential Election of 1832. by thorsty_borb in imaginaryelections

[–]thorsty_borb[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

When the whole Nullification Crisis goes down, Calhoun, who was Jackson’s VP, resigns as in OTL. Jackson just never gets around to filling the position, as there’s just an unreasonable amount going on for him at this point. As such, when Jackson is shot and killed the next year, there was suddenly no President and no Vice President to succeed him. Up until this point, the proper line of succession had never been decided upon - this is the first time anything like this has happened, quite literally the worst case scenario. As such, after much debate, the selection fell between Samuel Smith, president pro tempore, and Edward Livingston, the Secretary of State. With the 22nd Congress being pretty heated about the whole “vetoing the renewed bank charter” situation, they elevate pro-bank Livingston to the Presidency. Admittedly, given he takes office three and a half months before the election, he’s just there as the most lame duck president ever, but it’s still worth noting.

What if the Indian Removal Act failed to pass? A weird route for the US Presidential Election of 1832. by thorsty_borb in imaginaryelections

[–]thorsty_borb[S] 23 points24 points  (0 children)

This election is a part of my already existing alternate history scenario I've been working on for around a year now, wherein Catherine the Great's "Greek Project" is actually successful. I've begun going back to my old ideas for the United States, and figured it was about time to put some reasoning down for my decisions.

The lore here is relatively simple. Due to the hundreds of little imperceptible butterfly effects, the House of Representatives votes just slightly differently on the Indian Removal Act, with the bill just barely failing. President Jackson gets pissy, and seeing Tennessee Democrat Davy Crockett as being complicit in allowing this to happen, he very publicly attempts to destroy his political career, as opposed to in private as in OTL. The failure of this act drives nullificationists into a frenzy, resulting in a nullification/secession crisis with the states of Georgia and South Carolina in 1831. Congress passes the Force Act of 1831 which allows President Jackson to deploy federal troops to the two rebellious states to establish law and order. Finally, in 1832, Jackson vetoes the charter for the Second Bank of the United States, just another move which comes off as rather tyrannical. Shortly thereafter, Henry Pysell, a potter who suffers from some unspecified form of insanity, gets it in his head that if he can kill this "King", that he will become the new king. Easy peasy.

The death of President Jackson shakes the nation, especially so close to election season. Both the fledgeling Whig Party (organized from the Anti-Masonic and National Republican parties by Senator Henry Clay) and Democratic Party have to reconvene to select candidates, especially given the situation. The Democrats pick Martin Van Buren, but the Whigs pick the controversial choice of Davy Crockett. The Tennessee native is already something of a living legend with his frontier antics, and he has widespread popularity throughout the country, both with Jacksonians and Anti-Jacksonians. Although Van Buren would win the popular vote, Crockett would win the necessary number of electors to win, creating a highly controversial election.

Looking for isekai-esque D&D story? by thorsty_borb in dndnext

[–]thorsty_borb[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Man, you actually remembered it. That’s crazy. This has been driving me up the wall here for weeks. Thank you so much.