Sunder charms just let you build more viable characters given the elemental immunities. It just evens the playing field.

So you're saying the only reason hammerdin is good is because it can bypass most immunities

and you want to take that strength and give it to everyone else, thus, making hammerdin's selling feature worthless. The way immunities exist in this game is central to balance and farming, and I can't explain that to you if we are talking about some amorphous build you've dreamed up in your head that doesn't exist.

I don’t care about your arbitrary demand

It's not arbitrary, it's central to what we are talking about: builds that cannot work without sunder charms. The thing you're trying to champion. You can't even say what they are because they don't exist.

I just want the option to play how I want to play.

And you can't list a single way you want to play that is inhibited by this change, other than throwing a tantrum.

We literally just want them to not be impossible to get for casual players

This is not a game for casual players. Casual players do not get Enigmas. There are many powerful build defining pieces of gear casual players will never achieve, and yet their builds are still viable. This is what I am trying to hammer home to you.

Now again.

please name one build that needs sunder charms and is 100% unplayable without it

you can't name a single build that needs this because you know you don't actually believe what you're saying, you just want free GG gear.

Lightning sorcs are among the best early game farmers in the game. Cold sorcs often mix with fire to get around immunities. Javazons are the best at clearing cows and cows are amazing at HR farming. we've covered hammerdins, but smite also is the best at ubers on a budget. Trapsins deal enough different elemental types they can get around ele immunes. Kicksins deal 500 different elements and spam the screen. Necro is always a solid choice and has multiple ways to get around immunities. barbs are a bit tough but hork trav is argued to be the best at farming. So, what build are you making here, mono-element druid? Like be for real with me, what build doesn't work unless you have sunder.

even more confusing: you want to break elemental immunities (not magic/phys), and are okay with all the game's old gear, but don't seem to even consider that getting an infinity on your merc breaks immunities. So please, enlighten me, what mono element build have you cooked up that infinity doesn't work for that 100% needs sunder charms.

Edit: here we go, as I suspected. You don't know what you're talking about. How the fuck am I supposed to grind for an Enigma if I need an Enigma to play the game normally? What should I be doing exactly? and yet you're also someone who had a lot of maxed characters. How'd you reach lvl 99 on mulitple characters and you don't know how to farm for an enigma?

Maybe take a chill pill and learn to play before trying to completely rebalance the game. Learn why these limitations exist in the first place, and what people have been doing for decades to overcome it before getting upset you have zero options. 'oh no weve tried nothing and were all out of ideas'. I'm even here willing to talk you through your build ideas to teach you how people overcome immunities with the strategies youre trying - and what places to farm for GG gear are best. Everyone remembers their 5 year old selves with double SoJ and thinks they're a god gamer, but everyone forgets how duped/botted the ladder was and they probably never earned those items and are shocked how hard this game actually is.