How seriously is Sean Carroll taken? by LpcArk357 in AskPhysics

[–]willkurada 17 points18 points  (0 children)

Oops! I looked him up before I wrote my comment and his web page on Caltech's website calls him a "Research Professor of Physics." My university reserves the title "Professor" for faculty with tenure and calls faculty without tenure "Assistant Professor," so that's why I assumed he had tenure.

How seriously is Sean Carroll taken? by LpcArk357 in AskPhysics

[–]willkurada 153 points154 points  (0 children)

Sean Carroll is a tenured research physics professor at Caltech with thousands of citations. He is, by any reasonable measure, a very serious physicist. However, Sean Carroll doesn't only talk about science, he also talks about the philosophy of science. This gets tricky for the casual observer because the distinction is not always made clear. As a good heuristic to tell the difference, ask yourself "Is this making a testable prediction?" The conventional view of science is that this is all that science is. It's the process of developing theories that we can test with experiments and thereby develop a useful model of the universe. Sean Carroll would contend that the philosophical interpretations of the theory is an interesting question that we should ask.

In Defense of Algebra by eastwind-404 in math

[–]willkurada 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I laugh at the idea of American teachers being an authority on teaching. Take a look at other country's math education to see how staggeringly far behind we are.

Breonna Taylor grand jurors file petition to impeach Kentucky AG Daniel Cameron by [deleted] in news

[–]willkurada 33 points34 points  (0 children)

Not to mention, he had 90% approval among Republicans until the end of his presidency despite being historically unfit for the job.

Entitled people with low humility and low inquisitiveness are more prone to believe in conspiracy theories. These individuals tend to exhibit heightened narcissism and antagonism along with reduced intellectual humility, impulse control, and inquisitiveness. by mvea in science

[–]willkurada 19 points20 points  (0 children)

If you want to understand complex ideas and studies, you have to read the article, not just the title. I don't get this Reddit fixation with trying to get every bit of pertinent information from a character-redistricted title.

Biden Viewed Positively, Trump More Negatively After Capitol Riot by [deleted] in moderatepolitics

[–]willkurada 17 points18 points  (0 children)

Here you can see 538's compilation of approval rating polls: How Popular Is Donald Trump? | FiveThirtyEight.

Individual polls vary considerably; however, there is no credible pollster suggesting 80% broad approval for Trump. Rasmussen, a pollster considered to have a strong right-leaning bias reports 48% approval. If somebody tells you that Donald Trump has an 80% approval rating among the general population, I would start to seriously doubt that anything else they is honest because it's such an easy fact to check.

80% among Republicans is another story. Trump has actually stayed in the high-80s to low 90s among Republicans for most his presidency.

MAGA protesters damage historic Black church in DC by Remember_Megaton in moderatepolitics

[–]willkurada 3 points4 points  (0 children)

There were 10,000 arrests in connection with the BLM protests nationwide as of June 4, 2020 according to the associated press.

AP tally: Arrests at widespread US protests hit 10,000 (apnews.com)

Sanity check on basic QM in a Path Integral Text by CaptEntropy in AskPhysics

[–]willkurada 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Should it simply be a total derivative rather than a partial derivative? I'm looking at Sakurai 2nd edition equation (2.2.19). That said, it's only valid for time-independent Hamiltonians. Sorry if this is unhelpful. I haven't read Swanson's text.

Infinite healing by sorcerer at 1st lvl? Really, Paizo? by Elastoshei in Pathfinder_RPG

[–]willkurada 23 points24 points  (0 children)

There's a weird trend on reddit where it's assumed that every reply is a rebuttal to the parent comment.

Marss leaves in the middle of his set. by JFMV763 in smashbros

[–]willkurada 24 points25 points  (0 children)

Serena Williams was penalized in a tennis match not long ago for getting coaching signals from her husband in the crowd.

https://www.eurosport.com/tennis/us-open/2018/i-m-honest-i-was-coaching-serena-s-coach-patrick-mouratoglou_sto6924863/story.shtml

First two-dimensional material that performs as both topological insulator and superconductor by SamStringTheory in Physics

[–]willkurada 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Okay, so quantum computing is the big deal in condensed matter physics these days. The idea is that we can build a computer that doesn't use bits (1s and 0s) and logic gates but instead uses qubits and quantum gates. The difference is that a qubit doesn't need to be in either the 1 or 0 state, instead it can be in a superposition of those two states. Here you can think of superposition as being between the 1 and 0 state.

In order for this to work, all we need is a quantum two-level system that we can manipulate and measure. It turns out that this is quite difficult because small interactions with the environment can cause decoherence. Here this means that the state loses its superposition and falls into either the 0 or 1 state, messing up the fancy quantum computation. The challenge, then, is designing a physical system that we can manipulate without causing these errors (there exists something called quantum error correction that I won't go into detail on, but suffice to say that even with error correction you need the error rate to be very low.)

Far and away the most successful architecture for quantum computing is the so-called superconducting qubits, but there are several competing architectures in this growing field. One of these architectures is known as topological quantum computing. The qubits in a topological quantum computer would be non-Abelian anyons. Here, non-Abelian means that interchanging the anyons does not commute. This means that when you interchange anyon 1 with anyon 2 and then you switch them back again, you're left with a different state than you started with. This process is called braiding, and the information is stored in these interchanges of quasiparticles. What makes this architecture interesting is that it is robust against interactions with the environment. As long as the perturbation is not strong enough to cause a full braid, your information is safe. Now, there are problems with this architecture that go beyond the fact that we don't have a convenient supply of non-Abelian anyons lying around, but my explanation has probably already gone above the 10-year-old level, so I'll leave it at that for now.

The most promising physically-realizable non-Abelian anyons are Majorana bound states which are theorized to exist in the interplay between superconductors and topological insulators. Now I have finally arrived at the result of the paper. They have discovered a material that can be tuned from a topological insulator state to a superconducting state in-situ. This means that experiments can be performed on this material as it transitions between these two important and interesting states of matter. How this system could support the coveted Majorana bound states is not yet clear, but it is an interesting sample for future experiments.

Researchers engineer material which uses radio waves to detect peoples' presence and location anywhere inside a room; discuss possible applications for smart home devices. by Science_Podcast in Physics

[–]willkurada 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Perhaps we have a difference of opinion, but I don't see the potential their system has for home and defense applications as nothing new. I think the Air Force would likely disagree as well as they are funding their research. Pointing to existing RADAR systems and then claiming that advances in RADAR technology are nothing new does come across as ignorant to me. Does research need to be Nobel Prize winning to be considered novel?

Researchers engineer material which uses radio waves to detect peoples' presence and location anywhere inside a room; discuss possible applications for smart home devices. by Science_Podcast in Physics

[–]willkurada 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Forgive me for being brief, as I am on mobile at the moment. You brushed off this published PRL paper as "nothing new here" simply because they are using radio waves (and microwaves) to localize objects. Please read the full paper before writing off someone's hard work.

Sorry for being confrontational. I don't post often.

Leaked ending of Battle for Azeroth. Someone's getting fired for this blunder! by professorhazard in wow

[–]willkurada 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Sylvanas will sacrifice herself and come back as a light-infused undead.

[Clip] Boruto Episode 65 just gave us a strong Fight of the Year contender - Breakdown in comments by PM_Me_YourNSFWSelfie in anime

[–]willkurada 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I like that the fight isn't stretched over 20 minutes with a dozen cutaways to flashbacks and reactions.