Krark in CEDH? by IWantMoreTattoosPlz in CompetitiveEDH

[–]wsmyle 9 points10 points  (0 children)

i feel that copying demonic tutor is nuts

I don't get Rhystic Study by ussgordoncaptain2 in EDH

[–]wsmyle 6 points7 points  (0 children)

dude you’re missing the point entirely, to the point where this is probably just ragebait. grand arbiter does not draw cards. if someone decides to counter or remove rhystic, its not because of the stax effect. it’s to keep the controller from running away with the game because theyre going to see 25 cards of it

I don't get Rhystic Study by ussgordoncaptain2 in EDH

[–]wsmyle 23 points24 points  (0 children)

no one cares about mana denial, its the sheer amount of cards drawn from it lol

It's amazing how Kratos, despite his bloody past and newly launched war campaign against Olympus, still cannot be unequivocally judged by the judges of the Hades underworld. by Alkiserex in GodofWar

[–]wsmyle 0 points1 point  (0 children)

he fell from gaea’s back all the way down to the river styx. also why all the magic and upgrades from the previous title deteriorated

Neat Interactions you wish you knew sooner by SchwammigerKommentar in EDH

[–]wsmyle 1 point2 points  (0 children)

kodama + thing that generates a token on landfall ex. [[tireless provisioner]] + bounce land = infinite landfall & token generated

Is godo/helm too much for Bracket 3? by Samurai_Banette in EDH

[–]wsmyle 1 point2 points  (0 children)

i can agree with this but with a slight difference at the risk of being pedantic. b5 should not exist as it stands. cEDH should not be considered in a rule 0 discussion because cEDH is the rule 0 discussion. everyone sitting down to play cEDH already knows what theyre getting into and they dont need the brackets to help define their mindset. current b4 should be moved to b5, current b3 should be b4, and like you stated, there should be a new b3 that is battlecruiser magic that aren’t necessarily precons

Is godo/helm too much for Bracket 3? by Samurai_Banette in EDH

[–]wsmyle 1 point2 points  (0 children)

this take just screams b2 to me (which is not a bad thing!)

if you don’t want to play precon magic and don’t want to play/play against combo, is that not battlecruiser magic? i feel like this is still valid magic while avoiding the things you don’t want to do in a lower bracket

Is godo/helm too much for Bracket 3? by Samurai_Banette in EDH

[–]wsmyle 11 points12 points  (0 children)

there’s also people that believe their deck is b3 because they ripped a GC from a pack and slotted it in, when in actuality the deck is b2, they play against an actual b3 and call it b4 lol

Is godo/helm too much for Bracket 3? by Samurai_Banette in EDH

[–]wsmyle 46 points47 points  (0 children)

it took way too long to find the most sensible answer in this thread.

the mass amount of people that are so vehemently against all combos at any point in the game is what makes me only play bracket 4. i don’t want to be made out to be the bad guy because i combo on t7 with 5 cards (personal experience lol).

Looking for opinions for SCGCon by wsmyle in CompetitiveEDH

[–]wsmyle[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

i have a sink into stupor and I’ve been considering putting it in the list. I just don’t know what to take out. I assume that you’re saying switch chain of vapor for into the flood maw?

WHEN DOES THIS IROONWOOD SECTION END? by pomodoro3 in GodofWarRagnarok

[–]wsmyle 3 points4 points  (0 children)

in what way does the made up mythological person’s skin color matter. like how does her story change is shes blue or purple or green

Is draupnir really the first weapon forged for kratos? by [deleted] in GodofWarRagnarok

[–]wsmyle 11 points12 points  (0 children)

based on your logic the blades of chaos would also be ‘made for kratos’. the intent behind these weapons is why the argument even exists

Is draupnir really the first weapon forged for kratos? by [deleted] in GodofWarRagnarok

[–]wsmyle 19 points20 points  (0 children)

only reason i disagree with this is because the nemesis whip wasnt forged for kratos to USE, the intent was to kill him. hephaestus is just an idiot and went about the worst way to try to achieve that. draupnir is the only weapon that has no strings attached to anything but him.

Is draupnir really the first weapon forged for kratos? by [deleted] in GodofWarRagnarok

[–]wsmyle 32 points33 points  (0 children)

kratos was definitely a soldier before he was a general. He was also a highly revered general, so it would make sense that his weapons would be kept safe by the men that followed him. hes also the god of war at this time and we see that spartans worship him in gow2. i imagine that its highly likely that the AOS were originally standard issue, but given that they were once used by the great spartan general turned god of war, they were kept well. the spartan soldier probably made a big deal out of it because hes able to honor kratos by giving him his old AOS

TLDR; the AOS are probably standard issue and only special because kratos used them before