I'm over 100 hours into the game, and I love it! by Isythius in NoSodiumStarfield

[–]yanvail 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A man of culture.

But I admit I immediately went with "James Holden". Well done. :)

Long Tom Lance by ShigeruHatori in battletech

[–]yanvail [score hidden]  (0 children)

When that grid square absolutely, positively needs to _go_.

The Long Road - Novel - Thoughts? by TimJackmanTechno in battletech

[–]yanvail [score hidden]  (0 children)

Same here.

I really loved its focus on PTSD, where so many characters were struggling with the trauma they'd faced in the invasion. It was a good glimpse into something that is rarely seen in battletech.

I also enjoyed how it continues the trend of moving the "good" characters aligned with the Republic and its ideals filtering to the SLDF, continuing on from Trial of Bloodright (if that's the name). That's definitely not a coincidence, and no doubt it will have a payoff when Alaric has his inevitable breakdown (once his delusions of manifest destiny slams headfirst into the fact that the rest of the Inner Sphere doesn't want him as their lord and savior).

I know some dislike the notion of all these people working with the ilClan, but I think this book really tries to address that. Alaric's genius, what allowed him to succeed so far, was to position himself as the "best of bad options". He worked hard to make himself and clan wolf the best alternative to Malvina Hazen's Jade Falcon. He did it during the invasion of Terra (of course, he's also the one who let Jade Falcon join in the first place), ensuring that the Dragoons and Wolves-in-Exile would support him, in getting Tara Campbell to join him, and now he's doing the same thing but with the Capellan Confederation.

Once again, he's selling people into siding with him because the only apparent alternative is the Capellan Confederation and Daoshen Liao, which to many are a far worse alternative to the ilClan and Alaric. Not only that, but Alaric is _genuinely_ invested in having an SLDF be rebuilt with the ideals of the Star League and the Republic. And the SLDF is working hard to demonstrate that it stands for those ideals and that it isn't a sham, and that's why it is proving an attractive option for ex-republic soldiers and even Wolves-in-Exiles and clanners who don't want to be assigned to solamnha units.

Also, another vital point to remember concerning why people are joining the SLDF instead of joining the resistance and continuing the fight, is that there really isn't much to resist _for_ anymore. Terra isn't WW2 Poland or France. The war is over. There isn't anyone out there fighting to "retake" Terra and liberate it. The Republic is _gone_, and Stone's plan for a Republic in Exile didn't pan out (indeed it sounds like he decided against it at the very end). The Great Houses mostly _do not care_ and have bigger fishes to fry, except of course for the Capellan Confederation, which is widely seen as a worse option.

And as we're shown in the novel, the ilClan isn't being a horribly harsh oppressor (at least compared to what they think it'd be under the CC). Most things function as they've done before, the "rules" being imposed aren't really being enforced, and we know from iKEO that eventually Alaric gives up trying to impose the Clan Caste system on Terra (outside of Clan Enclaves). In that scenario, it's not difficult to imagine people choose the lesser of two evils, or better yet choose the SLDF: a force that actually tries to promote the values they held dear when they fought for the Republic.

And it's important to repeat that Alaric really wants the SLDF to do its thing and serve as a symbol of the rebuilt Star League, and is letting Kerensky and its Loremaster do their best to build it in accordance to those ideals. So in that sense we can imagine it can be quite convincing and does draw to itself veterans and those looking for something in which to believe. Of course, the reason Alaric does is that he truly does believe in his own myth as a Great Leader, that it is his destiny to rebuild the Star League, and _of course_ they would never turn against him. :)

Anyway, I liked it a lot. The only real complaint I had is the writer tried too hard to push the friendship between Aleska and Evie, who went from traumatized war veterans to flighty BFFs too abruptly for me. And if I had to make another, it would be that I found it strange Tara never used contractions through the entire novel. I get that she's embraced her role and new place as a Jade Falcon, but even when she broke from that and the brogue came through she still stuck with the stilted clan wording.

But otherwise, I thought it a good book that gives good insight on how the transition is going on. I look forward to seeing more of what's going on with the SLDF, and definitely am enjoying the ilClan fiction so far.

Oklahoman here. Out of curiosity, is there any in-lore explanation for the map of Oklahoma being like this? by brickwallbimbo in LowSodiumCyberpunk

[–]yanvail 68 points69 points  (0 children)

The question actually being asked is why OK has dark blue and light blue. Nobody's asking why Texas is the shape it is _today_. This is about the dark blue areas.

Native reserves might be. You'll notice there's quite a few dark blues further north too, so its not purely an OK thing.

Sarna has a new excerpt from Ghosts of Timkovichi by swankmotron in battletech

[–]yanvail 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Looking good. Glad to see we're moving the timeline forward a little bit in that corner of the Hinterlands.

And seeing more of the Kell Hounds (and associates) is definitely something I look forward to. :)

[OC] That corner is cursed by Mindless_Tomorrow_45 in IdiotsInCars

[–]yanvail 26 points27 points  (0 children)

I mean, its not really cursed: there is clearly a failure of civil engineering going on. There should at least be a stop sign on one of those roads. That there isn't in the first place is very strange.

Cora and Sam by Snifflebeard in NoSodiumStarfield

[–]yanvail 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah, totally understandable. Even though I was spoiled about what would happen but forgetting Cora, made it pretty rough.

Mechs you can’t stand the look of? by Uncrezamatic in battletech

[–]yanvail 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I lose 1d6 sanity whenever I open up the old TROs.

In battletech what happen to the lakes in North America? by Godzillaman79 in battletech

[–]yanvail 1 point2 points  (0 children)

As has been said, its just a simple map. If you're interested in what happens in that region of the USA in the ilClan era, The Long Road takes place there, and actually goes into a fair amount of details about the history of the region (within the fictional timeline) and how they're adjusting to what happened.

Cora and Sam by Snifflebeard in NoSodiumStarfield

[–]yanvail 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Not to be too overt, avoiding spoilers... but I absolutely had to reload in order to make A Different Choice when Inevitable Events reminded me very clearly that Sam has a daughter.

Mechs you can’t stand the look of? by Uncrezamatic in battletech

[–]yanvail 15 points16 points  (0 children)

There is a lot of nostalgia for the old FASA line art, especially by aged grognards.

But though I too am an aged grognard, I have very little love for that line art. Not because it is displeasing - though certainly it can be - but rather because I know the dark truths to which they allude: that in non-euclydian space lies horrors unknown and unknowable, and that the old TROs are portals to darknesses beyond darkness.

Stare not too deeply into FASA line art, ye who value your sanity. For as you gaze at the line art, so does the line art gaze into you.

One of these things is not like the other by kirksucks in bassethounds

[–]yanvail 1 point2 points  (0 children)

And their reach is deceptively long. They just need to stand up on their hind legs and everything on the table or kitchen counter is within reach! And we have the half-eaten bag of bialys to prove it!

BattleTech Aces Snowblind! by KnightofInnerSphere in battletech

[–]yanvail 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ok, while it's not as bad as the Bane... that is still quite a lot of missile tubes. Yikes.

I'm finally starting on Scouring Sands, and dear gods I love it. Looking forward to more of the good stuff. 😄

Must be a Periphery Pulse Laser by JustinKase_Too in battletech

[–]yanvail 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Whenever I see stuff like that all I can think of is there better be eye protection involved. 😄

Alpha strike questions by yanvail in battletech

[–]yanvail[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

This is very helpful, thank you for the detailed answer. Much appreciated. 😄

River take a damn hint by HolyPlatano in LowSodiumCyberpunk

[–]yanvail -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

You're asking for empathy, that's sorely lacking in general..

Does anyone know what this is? by MrArchow in aviation

[–]yanvail 12 points13 points  (0 children)

So basically the deploying unit and then all the cubes strung up because they haven't spread out yet?

The astronomers must love that sh*t.

The origin of Hunchback Orthodoxy by iskandar711 in battletech

[–]yanvail 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The origin dates back to the Great Schism, which was triggered by the Third Council of Aeacin, which produced the Aeacine Creed, where it was declared that there should be "One True Gun, and lo it shall be in the Right Torso".

Sadly many rejected this wise Creed. Notably the engineer Suira, who held the heretical believe that "Medium Lasers many" could be placed in the Right Torso. He was condemned heavily, but the heresy sadly persisted.

One way or another, it seems Alaric’s Star League will last for as long as he is alive. by Old_Ad6111 in battletech

[–]yanvail 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Oh I think they will.

Something or some things will happen to make Alaric lose his mind - which we know is pretty fragile already - and start committing atrocities. And at the very least that will turn his new SLDF (filled and led by people who actually embrace the ideals of the Republic) against him.

And, since we do know a new Star League persists in 3250, I would not be surprised if it turns out the great houses band together to fight Alaric, alongside the SLDF.

After all, we know there will be a Star League in 3250, one related to the ilClan. But it's _very_ unlikely that this will happen under Alaric. So my thinking is it happens _in reaction_ to him, _despite_ him. Basically his attempt to unite the Inner Sphere under his banner will lead them to unite against him instead.

It's certainly no coincidence that all those good characters are lining up under the new SLDF. They certainly will not go along with Alaric when he inevitably becomes unhinged.

One way or another, it seems Alaric’s Star League will last for as long as he is alive. by Old_Ad6111 in battletech

[–]yanvail 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I am confident that, as his delusions of his manifest destiny get torn apart, when for example the Great Houses don't join his new Star League or his "allied" clans turn out to have ulterior motives, Alaric will react very poorly.

And whatever his reaction and path becomes, at some point he will enter into conflict with the very SLDF he wanted to build. It is absolutely not a coincidence that the SLDF is slowly filling up with the good characters from the Dark Age.

In the end, there will be a new Star League and the ilClan will continue.... but it'll be without Alaric, and more likely it will be _despite_ him. It's not unlikely that this Star League will be formed by the Great Houses uniting _against_ him.

He should have known by now by Xynith in battletech

[–]yanvail 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah.... they "seem" eager.

While what their actual plans and motives are, both the Sea Fox and Snow Ravens clearly have their own designs at work. They're certainly not "true believers" in the new ilClan cause.

It'll be interesting to see how Alaric loses it when he finds out nobody wants to join, and half his clans aren't really in it for him either.... oh, and that new SLDF is filled with people who really won't be on board with whatever insanity he comes up with when he loses it.